In a pending vote that has piqued the attention of Pennsylvania anglers, state Fish and Boat commissioners will decide in July whether a limestone Class A Wild Trout Stream section should be managed for all-tackle fishing or artificial lures only. Whatever action commissioners take could indicate the outcome of similar special-regulations rulings on other waters.

Spruce Creek in Huntingdon County, a Little Juniata River tributary known to be favored by several fly-fishing U.S. presidents, is almost entirely owned by private sporting groups. Two small sections, including a stretch recently acquired by Fish and Boat from the former Indian Caverns attraction, are open to the public and managed under standard Commonwealth Inland Waters regulations. In January, commissioners added the stream section to its list of Class A Wild Trout Streams, a high-quality designation indicating native trout reproduction.

“Since the 800-foot Section 03 was designated as Class A in January, it is now illegal to stock trout directly into that reach and it is managed for wild trout,” said Kris Kuhn, chief of Fish and Boat’s fisheries management division. “However, the water immediately upstream and downstream from the Indian Caverns property is not designated as Class A and is classified as private, closed to fishing.”

The board also tabled a decision to manage the stream section under Catch-and-Release Artificial Lures Only regulations or for Catch-and-Release All-Tackle. If the board rules for artificials-only use, flies and spinners will be the only baits permitted. An all-tackle ruling will make the use of live bait legal. Catch and release fishing will be required either way.

Advertise with us

In a heated debate at the January meeting, several commissioners referenced research showing that fishing mortality is the same — about 5% — whether a fish was hooked with an artificial lure or a hook and live bait. Some anglers have suggested that while far more people fish with live bait, a culture of conservation-based voluntary catch-and-release is already common among users of artificial lures.

Spruce Creek is not stocked by Fish and Boat, but many of its private owners legally stock their parts of the stream with trophy-size hatchery trout and feed them with nutrition pellets. The wild and native trout cohabitate. In November, 2018, Wil Snyder of Bridgeville caught a stocked 26-inch brown and a native 3-inch fry in the same stretch of the stream.

“It should be noted that the qualifying survey for the Class A designation excluded hatchery fish from the estimate and represented the wild brown trout population only,” said Mr. Kuhn.

One of the stream’s private fishing groups, the exclusive Homewaters Club owned by entrepreneur Donny Beaver, was formerly named the Spring Ridge Club. In 2007 the club lost a landmark Pennsylvania legal battle regarding Mr. Beaver’s claim of ownership of a portion of the Little J at the mouth of Spruce Creek. The ruling confirmed the state’s colonial-era definition of “public waters” as a waterway that has been historically navigated for commerce. Spruce Creek does not fit that description.

Public comments on the regulatory proposal will be accepted through June 24. Find details at fishandboat.com.

Advertise with us

Game Commission audit

Following a performance audit ordered by state legislators, the Pennsylvania Game Commission agreed to settle lawmakers’ biggest beef — oversight of the agency’s cash reserves.

Initiated at the request of state Rep. Frank Dermody, D-Oakmont, and Rep. Mike Hanna, D-Clinton, the audit, or anticipation of one, has put the agency’s request for a license fee increase in limbo since 2016. A resident adult hunting license sells for $20.90. The Legislature last approved an increase in hunting license fees in 1998.

With a budget of about $100 million, PGC employs some 700 full-time staff and issues about 900,000 hunting licenses annually. Auditor General Eugene DePasquale’s office raised questions about the PGC’s Game Fund balance, a $72.8 million reserve that the agency does not factor into its budget or include when making financial decisions.

“Beyond the nearly $73 million balance in the Game Fund, we found there was an additional $6.5 million in various escrow accounts – which the commission’s financial officer didn’t even have knowledge of the specific accounts, balances or purposes [of] until my audit,” Mr. DePasquale said in a statement.

Advertise with us

Among 40 recommendations in the audit is an advisement that PGC place the escrow accounts under the control of the Pennsylvania Treasury, where Mr. DePasquale said there would be more transparency.

Bryan Burhans, executive director of the Game Commission, said the agency would comply with all but one of the recommendations regarding documentation of employee hours, which he said would contradict a Game and Wildlife Code requirement on habitat spending.

The audit cited no misappropriations of funds. It recommended that PGC could save money by reorganizing its vehicle fleet, and did not include management of whitetail deer and ruffed grouse, both of which were described as major issues in early reports of the audit’s mandate.