To the millions of reasons to fish for walleye at Lake Erie, add two more. The high walleye density of 2018 is expected to be topped this summer, and last year’s throwaways will be this year’s keepers.

The population boom, a result of unusually successful spawns in consecutive years, led to a walleye angler success rate that crested at three times the 30-year average. In 2019, however, conditions are different.

Continuing a trend that began several years ago, the Great Lakes are rising. Floodwaters spilling over the shorelines of western Lake Erie have swamped streets and homes, shut down ferries and carried dangerous debris inland. In April, water spilled over a seawall and cut Ohio’s South Bass Island in half. Snow melt and recent winds and rains increased the problem. Lake Erie is already 26 inches above its long-term average, and water levels are expected to topple records this summer, according to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

Also, this year’s waters are slightly cooler than normal. The National Weather Service reported last week that water temperatures ranged from the 30s in Lake Superior to the 50s in lakes Michigan, St. Clair and Erie.

Advertise with us

“A slow warm-up may delay the migration of west basin fish slightly,” said Chuck Murray, Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission’s chief Lake Erie biologist.

“Out migration from the west starts when water temperatures hit the upper 40s and most have moved out by the time temperatures hit the low 70s. Typically, this occurs from late April through the beginning of July, but there may be some delay in this movement due to cooler lake temperatures.”

Fishing reports showed a steady bite off Port Clinton and Sandusky last week, suggesting that the walleye had traveled at least that far east. The first walleye wave was expected to cross the Ohio-Pennsylvania line this week.

Resident walleye, those genetically driven to spawn in eastern Lake Erie waters, were caught off Erie County by shore anglers and some near-shore boaters last week.

“Our walleye fishery is firing on all cylinders right now,” said Mr. Murray. “Limits are being caught in a few hours.”

Advertise with us

How will 150 million walleye deal with the expanded acreage and depth of a rising Lake Erie? Mr. Murray said he’s more concerned about how anglers will deal with it.

“It is already impacting boat anglers. Many of the docks at the launch ramps are submerged, so anglers need rubber boots to access their boats,” he said, adding that the most serious issue is navigational hazards.

“A lot of pilings, rock jetties and concrete structures around the launch facilities that are just under the surface of the water and difficult to see.”

Mr. Murray said these hazards could cause serious damage to boat hulls and lower motor units, and could injure anglers if they approach the ramps too aggressively. Maintenance crews were stacking concrete blocks to mark the end of some docks.

The first week of June, most charter captains were still taking clients on lake trout and yellow perch trips, but a few had begun trolling for near-shore walleye. Walleye charters out of Erie County usually cost $700-$750 for four or five clients for eight hours. A half-day trip of five hours might cost the same group $600.

Advertise with us

Last year, the Perch Pirate head boat moored at Liberty Pier pivoted from 40-passenger perch trips to 20-passenger, half-day walleye drift trips costing only $50 per person. Senior Capt. Bob Zawadzki said he’s expecting his electronics to start marking migrating walleye in mid-June. He and John Krasa, owner of the boat and Tell No Tales Charters, are booking morning and evening trips Wednesdays through Sundays.

According to the Perch Pirate’s daily logs, nearly 1,200 walleye were boated and many sublegal ones were thrown back in 2018. Evening trips caught about 100 more walleye than morning trips, and clients also caught a lot of jumbo perch and some steelhead trout.

While most walleye charter captains troll, Mr. Zawadzki drifts the head boat over schools, turning it 180 degrees every 30 minutes to give anglers fishing over the port and starboard rails equal chances of hooking up.

“Those who learned the cast, count and drag method using all types of spinners caught the majority of the ′eyes,” he said.

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.