UNIONTOWN — From the hills of Chestnut Ridge, water flows west to the lazy Monongahela River. To the east, the slopes are steeper, people are fewer and the water spills headlong into the rugged Youghiogheny.
It’s a remote swath of Fayette County known for its black bears and rattlesnakes. A few old-growth hemlocks stand where they grew when Braddock’s army cut a path over the mountain on their interrupted march to Fort Duquesne. The valley streams are popular among trout anglers, and the state Fish and Boat Commission stocks them in the spring. Feeding those creeks are dozens of small tributaries where wild brook trout trace their lineage to ones that scattered when George Washington splashed through more than 200 years ago.
It was on one of those remote creeks — too vulnerable to name and no wider than the length of a fly rod — where I met outdoors author John Nagy of Brookline for a spring morning of fishing and conversation about conserving those fish.
“It’s been a lifelong love for me to catch wild trout,” he said. “I like to fish the mountain streams, so that basically means wild brook trout.”
Mr. Nagy, who is noted for years of guiding steelhead anglers and four editions of “Steelhead Guide: Fly Fishing Techniques and Strategies for Lake Erie Steelhead” (Great Lakes Publishing), said he visits this headwater stream on public land to climb the gradient, catch and release and relax.
“Steelhead fishing is mostly nymphing and swinging flies,” he said. “So for me pure enjoyment, pure heaven, is using a dry fly.
Read More
“Years ago most of these streams had the classic freestone insect hatches — mayflies, stoneflies and caddises. That’s Hendricksons and Quill Gordons early on and later in the summer Sulfurs and Green Drakes. You’re not really matching hatches. It’s just putting on a dry fly that kind of mimics the size, anywhere from 16s to 12s.”
Mr. Nagy said he’s confident in Fish and Boat’s long-term commitment to avoid stocking over Class A Wild Trout Waters, with a few exceptions. The freestone tributaries of Fayette County don’t warrant a Class A rating; they’re acidic and historically compromised by clear cutting, acid rain and mine drainage. But they have “some really good wild trout reproduction.”
“I have a concern that if a main branch is stocked and the feeders have wild trout in them, is there interbreeding?” he said. “These wild trout are resilient and have adapted to endure so much change. Interbreeding — introgression, they call it — would eventually destroy these isolated populations of wild fish.”
The Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources estimates the state has more than 86,500 miles of flowing water, second only to Alaska. Sixty-three of Pennsylvania’s 67 counties have naturally reproducing wild trout. Since 2010, Fish and Boat’s Unassessed Waters Initiative has searched for wild trout and taken baseline water-quality readings on some 13,000 miles of previously unassessed streams. Through the program, Fish and Boat staff and university volunteers have added nearly 2,000 new entries to the list of wild trout stream sections.
More than 15,000 miles of stream and river sections where wild trout have been documented, plus another 20,273 miles of upstream tributaries, have been designated “wild trout waters.” About 12,400 miles of wild trout streams, 35 percent of the total, flow through public land. The best of Pennsylvania’s naturally reproducing wild trout fisheries are considered Class A wild trout streams. About 6 percent of wild trout waters get the Class A stamp, including 61.3 miles in Fayette and Westmoreland counties. Nearly 850 miles of Class A waters are on public land.
Mr. Nagy said his research of genetic introgression studies have tempered some of his concerns, but led to other questions. Interbreeding was proven in studies where hatchery fish were stocked over wild salmon, rainbow trout and other members of the trout family. But in more relevant research, a 2018 Penn State study on the Loyalsock Creek drainage in Lycoming and Sullivan counties found that there was little to no introgression despite decades of trout stocking in a watershed containing wild trout.
“They said the hatchery trout were bred for fast growth and not healthy enough to last very long, so there was no interbreeding,” said Mr. Nagy. “But the concern is the stocked trout could interfere with wild trout reproduction in two ways — competing for food and false spawning. These wild fish could waste their energy in failed spawning attempts with hatchery-raised fish.”
Brook trout evolved in cool Appalachian Mountain water. They show signs of stress when water temperatures rise to about 65 degrees. Unlike the natural temperature control of springfed limestone streams, freestone creeks of Chestnut Ridge and Laurel Ridge to its east can grow too warm for brook trout. A study by researchers at California University of Pennsylvania found that temperatures in Laurel Ridge headwaters reach 65 sooner and stay there longer than they did 30 years ago.
“But they’re finding more wild trout,” Mr. Nagy said. “First because they’re looking for them, and also when mines close and trees grow over the creek and areas are protected from development, the wild trout’s range expands.”
Fly anglers who want to experience the wild trout he loves might start with the listings of Class A wild trout streams and wild trout waters posted on Fish and Boat’s website, or just explore small tributaries with a dry fly.
On these trips, Mr. Nagy carries a 6-foot light-action fly rod, a box of flies with barbless hooks and a bottle of water.
“I prefer to wade wet,” he said. “There’s often no cell phone reception, so I go prepared — leg wraps for snakebites, bear spray, water purifier and a lighter and emergency space blanket in case I have to stay the night.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.