The tanker trucks hit the road March 1. Across Pennsylvania, 3.2 million trout will be introduced to lakes and streams one bucket at a time, or by way of troughs that slide them into the water.
To many trout anglers, the calculus that determines which fish go where is a mystery shaded by anecdotal experiences and lingering perceptions about the competence, if not the honesty, of the Fish and Boat Commission.
Through the sale of trout permits and federal Dingle-Johnson Act redistribution of license fees and excise taxes, angler dollars finance the state trout stocking program. Dave Nihart, the agency’s coldwater unit leader and architect of the stocking plan, said a growing understanding of the species and angler habits has led to changes in the way the state stocks trout.
State Fish and Boat Commission stocks Bull Creek
“Back in the ’80s we used a county quota system where the number of fishing licenses sold formed the basis for the number of fish stocked,” he said in a recent phone interview. “In 1983 we started looking at stream resources and it changed our stocking system substantially.”
Four criteria are taken into account when determining whether and when a waterway is stocked and which species it will get:
• Trout abundance, as in estimates of a stream’s wild trout population.
Read More
“This is one thing we really look at closely,” said Mr. Nihart. “We’d rather not stock over native trout, but there are 13 Class A waters that we stock for social reasons. They are very heavily fished on opening day. Remove it and you’re removing a large number of trout available to anglers in that area.”
• Recreational use measures the acreage of streamside land that is public, private and private but open for public use, as well as parking access. Most stocked waters flow through some posted areas, he said, and stocking evaluations take into consideration the changing attitudes of land owners.
• Width of stream can determine how many trout are stocked. Fish and Boat puts them in broad rivers and small streams less than 4 meters wide.
• Human population density is a good barometer of the number of anglers likely to fish a given waterway from opening day until mid-June.
Conspicuously absent from that list is water quality. Mr. Nihart said a high level of water purity is neither necessary nor a consideration.
“Most of the time when we’re stocking, they are marginal trout streams anyway. If they were Class A we probably wouldn’t be stocking trout there,” he said. “There are some holdovers, but these fish really aren’t supposed to spawn or even be there for very long. They’re there so people can catch them. We’re looking at streams that have cold water from opening day to Memorial Day or mid-June, when we’re hoping people will use those fish.”
Pennsylvania hatcheries use species strains that are easily domesticated. Trout live for one year in the raceways, growing quickly to the preferred stocking size of 8 to 11 inches. Rainbow trout account for 2.1 million, nearly one third, of all the trout stocked by the state. Mr. Nihart said 650,000 of the fish are browns and 450,000 are brook trout.
“Based on the [research] we’ve done, people prefer rainbow trout. They’re more easily caught by anglers,” he said. “I don’t know if they’re more aggressive feeders, but they tend to stick around as long as the water is cold. Brown and brook trout try to avoid high [spring] flows, but rainbows do well when the water is high.”
From a biological perspective, rainbows and brook trout are used in most preseason stockings because they do better in colder water than the browns, said Mr. Nihart. In areas like southwestern Pennsylvania, where there has been a lot of mining, brook trout are the preferred stocking species because they tolerate more acidic water. Brown trout are comfortable in slightly warmer water and are often used during in-season stockings.
“If you had a small stream in a rural area that may get 20 people fishing, we might stock 300 fish in it,” he said. “You have 1,000 people fishing it might get 3,000.”
In lakes, stocking criteria include public access, parking and the number of launching ramps. Stocking numbers are determined by how many trout are expected to be caught before the water gets too warm for the cold-water fish.
Golden rainbows are rainbow trout that are hatchery bred for their easy visibility in the water, and trophy status among anglers. Fish and Boat raises them to be 14 inches or longer and stocks 9,600 per year.
The agency does not raise tiger trout, which almost never occur in the wild. If the sterile hybrid of a brown trout hen and a male brook trout is found it public waters, it escaped — with human help or not — from a private stocking.
At the hatcheries some trout are kept for two or three years to serve as brood stock. Once their reproductive peak has passed, those males and females are released in lakes and streams. Breeders can be more than 20 inches long and are the undisputed rock stars of approved trout waters.
Among the streams and rivers managed under Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only regulations, 21 stream sections are also enrolled in the Keystone Select program, in which large numbers of trophy-size breeders are stocked in addition to the regular stockings.
In recent years more has been learned about trout migration. Some fish travel many miles after stocking while others stay put. Science isn’t sure why. Mr. Nihart said migration is often compensated by stocking the fish three days to a week before opening day, as permitted by logistic restrictions. A deep pool under an easily accessible bridge might get a large number of trout in early April. That keeps opening-day crowd happy, while anglers on the move can find those fish scattered up- and downstream for months to come.

Post-Gazette Outdoors Poll
LAST WEEK: Should additional waters be open for trout fishing before the official opening day?
Yes 46 %
No 54 %
250 responses
This poll is an unscientific tally of web postings generated by Civic Science.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.