Pennsylvania’s state muskellunge record has stood for nearly 100 years but not without controversy.
In 1924, Lewis Walker Jr. of Meadville reported catching a 59-inch muskellunge weighing 54 pounds, 3 ounces in Conneaut Lake, Crawford County. A photo shows Mr. Walker with a muskie that seems to be nearly as long as he was tall.
Years later, he wrote that he hooked the fish while trolling an 8-inch chub with a cane pole spooled with 42-pound line and a leader made of picture wire.
“Finally, a half-hour or more after I had hooked the fish, it came to the top of the water for the first time about 60 feet away from the boat,” he wrote. “I will have to admit frankly that when I saw what I had on the end of the line, I did have a few moments of buck fever, even after all my years of catching muskies. It looked as big as the boat!”
Although it was apparently the biggest fish ever caught in Pennsylvania, its size was never certified. Most state records weren’t independently verified in those days. An attempt to verify Mr. Walker’s claim, is the source of the continuing controversy.
Mr. Walker had the mammoth muskie stuffed, mounted and displayed at the Fish and Boat Commission’s Linesville fish hatchery, now called the Pymatuning Wildlife Learning Center. The mount was subsequently stolen and recovered, but it was damaged before being returned to the Learning Center.
Read More
In 1984, fisheries biologists surveying Allegheny Reservoir in Warren County discovered a massive muskie that had become tangled in a gill net and died. At 54⅝ inches and 53 pounds, the Kinzua Giant is generally accepted as the state’s second largest muskellunge, although it was not caught with a rod and reel and is not in line for the record. It, too, was mounted and displayed at Linesville beside Mr. Walker’s catch.
Some folks say the Kinzua Giant appears to be fatter than Mr. Walker’s fish. Others say damage to the earlier mount makes it look smaller. Debate continues about the uncertified state record. To put Mr. Walker’s catch in perspective, Fish and Boat reported that the five largest angler-caught muskies registered in Pennsylvania in 2018 ranged from 41½ inches to 52 inches in length and weighed from 18½ pounds to 40½ pounds.
Want to learn more about muskellunge? Western Pennsylvania Muskie Max Plus will be at Printscape Arena at Southpointe, 114 Southpointe Blvd., Canonsburg. 9 a.m.-6 p.m. March 2 and 10 a.m.-3 p.m. March 3. Details at muskiemax.com and 724-758-2701.
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.