TOLEDO, Ohio — A state panel again this month delayed implementation of Ohio Gov. John Kasich’s plan to create new regulations on thousands of farms in a bid to reduce fertilizer and manure feeding Lake Erie’s sometimes toxic algae blooms.
The decision by the Ohio Soil and Water Conservation Commission came amid concerns over how the regulations would be put in place and amid pushback from the agriculture industry.
It also coincided with one of the largest explosions in walleye populations on record. Despite the blooms, several extremely successful years since 2013 have resulted in some 50 million walleye in Lake Erie in 2018. It was a banner year for recreational walleye anglers fishing in Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania, New York and Ontario. Chuck Murray, Lake Erie biologist for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, said very good catch rates and sizes exceeding 30 inches were expected in the next several years.
Toxic algae blooms are believed to be more detrimental to bass, panfish and other sport fishes that spend most of their time in one general area within a few feet of the surface. Most Lake Erie walleye are highly mobile and can avoid surface contact with the algae and deep oxygen-deprived areas caused by the algae.
The delay in implementing Mr. Kasich’s cleanup plan was a blow to his attempt to take a more aggressive approach against the persistent blooms before he leaves office at year’s end.
By a 4-3 vote, the commission opted to wait on approving the plan until at least February 2019 to allow more time to establish rules overseeing the changes.
“Clearly it is going to take other avenues and other measures to achieve the protections we need, and we urge everyone who cares about water quality in Ohio and in the Great Lakes to come together to save the lake before it’s too late,” said Jon Keeling, Mr. Kasich’s spokesman.
Mr. Kasich issued an executive order in July that called for issuing “distressed watershed” designations for eight creeks and rivers in northwestern Ohio. Those are the source of large amounts of phosphorus-rich fertilizer and manure.
The designations would require the owners of 7,000 farms across nearly 2 million acres to evaluate their land and make changes. Some could be costly and force farmers to buy expensive machinery that injects fertilizer into the ground or build storage for livestock manure. But the plan needs the soil and water commission’s approval.
Some of its members said they know the matter needs to be addressed, but warned there are too many unknowns about the governor’s proposal and how much it will cost.
Members of Mr. Kasich’s administration urged the commission not to delay. It already had delayed immediate action in July by calling for a study of the issue after farmers and some Republicans lawmakers raised concerns.
Craig Butler, director of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, said research clearly shows that the eight areas targeted by the governor are the biggest contributors to the phosphorus that fuels the algae.
“Do not play politics with this issue,” he told the commission.
For more than a decade, algae blooms on the lake’s western end have been the cause of tainted drinking water, fish kills and beach closures. An outbreak in 2014 contaminated tap water for two days for more than 400,000 people around Toledo.
In October, a federal judge in Ohio threw out a lawsuit seeking to force the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to take stronger action on Lake Erie’s ongoing toxic algae problem. The lawsuit sought increased pollution controls and limits on phosphorus that flows into the lake.
In dismissing the lawsuit, U.S. District Judge James Carr said it was too early to decide the issue because Ohio designated the lake’s western basin as impaired in March. The Toledo-based judge said the environmental groups that brought the lawsuit couldn't argue yet that Ohio wasn’t doing enough to combat the algae blooms.
Two Ohio lawmakers who criticized Gov. Kasich’s proposed farm regulations convened a panel of legislators to study the lake’s long-term health. The legislature’s Republican leadership began setting up the panel after Mr. Kasich issued the executive order calling for a more aggressive approach to limit the farm fertilizer and manure that feed the algae blooms.
Members of the “Toward A Cleaner Lake Erie” legislative panel, described as a bipartisan working group, held meetings in the fall chaired by two Republicans who lead agriculture committees in the legislature, Ohio state Sen. Bob Hackett and state Rep. Brian Hill.
The Republican legislators complained they weren’t given a chance to play a role in developing such a major policy, a charge that Mr. Kasich, a fellow Republican, denied. “They had their chance and they blinked,” he said.
A week after Mr. Kasich’s order was announced, Mr. Hill said that the governor’s proposal targets farmers who already have made changes to reduce agricultural runoff. It doesn’t consider other factors that contribute to algae, he said.
“Additional burdensome regulations focused solely on farmers through rules without their input is very concerning,” Mr. Hill said.
The Kasich administration said earlier this year that the steps farmers have taken aren’t working fast enough for Ohio to reach its goal of significantly reducing the amount of phosphorus entering the lake in the next seven years.
Research shows that the largest source, by far, of phosphorus and nitrogen in the lake comes from farmland, although federal researchers said the Lake Erie algae bloom this year was relatively mild compared with past years. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said the algae outbreak also fell short of what scientists had expected.
An algae bloom began forming in June in western Lake Erie a few weeks earlier than usual. But dry conditions settled across the region during the summer. Scientists say the algae bloom broke apart after a big storm in early September and was gone by October, earlier than most years.
A federal grant awarded this year will help improve a system that provides early warnings about harmful algae blooms in the lake. U.S. Rep. Debbie Dingell of Michigan says the Great Lakes Observing System Regional Association in Ann Arbor will receive $585,702 from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Improvements to the observing system funded by the grant will provide water managers and researchers with timely and user-friendly access to critical monitoring data during future blooms.
John Hayes contributed to this story.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.