LIGONIER, Pa. — In the winter, waterways are mostly quiet, slow and measured. Patient as droplets upon an icicle.

Below the surface of running streams, the life cycle continues. When it is warm and energy is abundant, the attack of predators can be explosive. As metabolism is slowed in winter, the predator-prey relationship continues, but in slow motion.

In the weeks before and after Dec. 21, the official start of winter, trout anglers can find themselves alone on quiet waters casting to hungry fish. In Pennsylvania, the weather often is about the same as in the early spring days of trout season, but the drop in water temperature has coaxed micro-invertebrates, forage fish and trout into winter behavior patterns.

For anglers aware of what’s happening beneath the surface, it can be a great time to be on the water. It’s a bad time, however, to rely on earthworms and live minnows. Despite the smell, trout are unlikely to move more than a few feet when water temperatures are just a few degrees north of freezing. Spin anglers may find that in the current, a salmon egg or paste bait fished like a single egg can attract late-season trout. But in winter their primary food is tiny, and the advantage goes to the fly rod.

Advertise with us

On a recent sunny morning, ankle-deep in Loyalhanna Creek in Westmoreland County, I fished a beaded latex nymph at the mouth of a tributary, releasing one 14-inch brown trout and amusing several others. That far above the Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only area, which was stocked with rainbows in October, I was certain my brown was a holdover that had lived in the creek at least since April, the last time these waters were stocked.

At the end of each upstream roll cast, I lifted my rod tip and tried to advance the fly as it flowed toward and past my position. Farther up the tributary, in waters more narrow than the length of my rod, the line tightened on first cast and zigzagged across a dark pool. The fight was brief but more exciting than the sluggish drag I felt from the brown trout. Brightly colored, the undisputed apex predator of the tributary pool, was a wild 7-inch brook trout, no doubt the progeny of 18th-century ancestors that literally smelled blood during the Indian battle waged outside of nearby Fort Ligonier.

By the time I reeled in the line around noon, I had released two trout but had the feeling I should have had more hookups. Driving west on Route 30 through Loyalhanna Gorge, I considered my fly choices, fishing tactics and seasonal changes in biology, wondering what I could have done better.

“Any fish I catch, stocked or wild, in winter is a special fish to me,” said Stephen Sautner, a New Jersey-based author who’s written outdoors columns for The New York Times and articles for Outdoor Life and other magazines. His collection of angling essays, “Fish On, Fish Off” (Lyons Press, 2016) was followed this year by the release of “A Cast in the Woods,” an absorbing story about stewardship of a stream at his Catskills fishing camp, with chapters separated by detailed entries from his fishing journal.

“In spring I’m a dry fly guy, but in the winter it’s a slow, slow game of bouncing nymphs on the bottom, keeping them deep and methodically working the water,” said Mr. Sautner. “They’re not really actively feeding, but put something in front of them and the trout will hit it because they’re hungry. But you have to keep it deep. They won’t rise for it.”

Advertise with us

To keep his presentations down and slow in winter, Mr. Sautner said he’s been experimenting with adaptations of European fly fishing techniques.

“Not the Czech nymphing with three flies,” he said. “I’ve been using a heavily weighted nymph — I don’t mind using split shot — a long length of non-tapered tippet, 8 feet of quick-sinking 4x line and a long, light 10-foot 3-weight rod. The fly sinks quickly and the drift covers a lot of water.”

Unlike dead-drifting with a strike indicator, in his adaptation of the Euro drift Mr. Sautner works the line slightly ahead of the current while feeling the rap of lead shot skipping over rocks. He likes weighted stonefly nymphs, bead-head caddis and beaded hare’s ear nymphs. Sometimes, he said, he ties on a green single-egg pattern or even a bright streamer, a “big nasty thing” that bounces across the stones.

Aquatic biologists see the water in a different light. After working for decades as a biologist and environmental director for the state Fish and Boat Commission, and eight years as its executive director, John Arway is recently retired and eager to go fishing. Successful winter trout fishing, he said, is all about the seasonal differences in food availability and energy conservation.

“As they adjust their body temperature to match the environment, their metabolism slows down and they spend their energy in much different ways,” he said. “There are not many hatches — winter stoneflies hatch when it’s cold — but this time of year the majority of foods that trout eat are in the drift. In other seasons they’ll find food throughout the water column. In winter [their positioning] in the stream changes. They’ll go to the channels where the most food passes. Anglers have to be aware of that.”

Advertise with us

More than ever, said Mr. Arway, winter trout anglers should fish on the slow side of seams, behind rocks and any place where the fish can expend minimal energy to acquire maximum energy. Big trout will still eat a bait fish, but they won’t chase it as far as in the spring or summer.

“You have to kind of put it right under their noses,” he said.

After a month in the water, stocked trout have learned where and how to get food. Mr. Arway said in the winter, hatchery trout generally behave about the same as wild trout and can be found staging in the same stream positions.

“In winter it’s usually not worth fishing through riffles and other fast waters,” he said. “Better to hopscotch to holding waters where they’re more likely to be waiting in slow current for food to come their way.”

Stephen Sautner’s “A Cast in the Woods” (Lyons Press, 2018) is available at International Angler in Robinson and Amazon.com.

Advertise with us