The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission has appointed a replacement for exiting executive director John Arway. So is it likely the state Legislature will finally approve a funding increase?

Commissioners voted unanimously last week to appoint Tim Schaeffer at the state agency’s top job. Currently Mr. Schaeffer is deputy secretary for the office of water programs at the state Department of Environmental Protection. He will assume the position Nov. 13.

The new job will mark the second time Mr. Schaeffer has been on the Fish and Boat payroll. He was the agency’s director of policy and planning from 2008 to 2017. Eric Hussar, president of the Fish and Boat board of commissioners, said in a statement that Mr. Schaeffer’s experience speaks for itself.

“We look forward to seeing how he’s going to lead us into the future and advance our mission,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Schaeffer’s appointment to the executive branch agency is subject to the approval of Gov. Tom Wolf, who is expected to confirm him.

In a statement Mr. Schaeffer said he’s excited to get to work. He and his family live in New Cumberland, Cumberland County.

Theoretically the appointment ends an eight-year funding kerfuffle that grew into a political embarrassment for the Commonwealth.

Fish and Boat is a user-funded agency that receives no funding from state taxes. The primary source of its $54 million annual budget is the sale of licenses and permits. The cost of an adult resident fishing license has remained the same, $22.90, since 2005. Fish and Boat license-holder surveys showed a general approval for a license-fee increase.

The Legislature doesn’t fund the agency, but by statute it controls license fees. Lawmakers refused for 13 years to permit a general license fee increase. Fish and Boat isn’t alone in its funding quandary. Another executive branch agency, the state Game Commission, has not seen a bump in license fees since 1999.

Advertise with us

Throughout Mr. Arway’s eight-year battle with the Legislature he got creative with ways to both save and make money. Staff was slashed by attrition from 432 to 366 full-time employees. The addition of new voluntary youth fishing licenses and vintage license buttons boosted the state’s federal Dingell-Johnson Sport Fish Restoration Act reapportionment. But legislators wouldn’t budge on raising license fees. Some objected to Fish and Boat’s long-term policy of holding a cash reserve about equal to its yearly budget — a “financial cushion” that would ensure the survival of the agency’s long-term wildlife and habitat programs should there be a costly ecological catastrophe.

Last year, with Fish and Boat unable to meet annual pension obligations and afford structural repair-or-replace priorities, commissioners ordered Mr. Arway to get a funding increase or trim $2 million per year from the budget beginning with the 2018-19 fiscal year. He calculated the agency would save about $2 million if it closed a cool-water shad research program in Juniata County, shrank the cooperative fish nursery program and closed cold-water trout hatcheries in Potter and Erie counties at a loss of 220,000 trout out of the 3.2 million that the agency stocks annually.

In an attempt to play Pennsylvania hardball with a legislature that invented the game, Mr. Arway announced that the streams that would not be stocked would be in the jurisdictions of legislators who opposed increasing Fish and Boat funding. A map showing political divisions and waterways that would not get trout went up on Fish and Boat's website. The graphic was abruptly pulled, but not before lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, even those who had supported a revenue increase, turned on Mr. Arway. Instead of raising license fees they proposed Senate Bill 935, which would cap the position of Fish and Boat executive director to an eight-year term. Legislators vowed that no legislative action on license fees would occur until Mr. Arway was out.

“The Legislature doesn’t want fisheries resources used as a bargaining chip,” said state Sen. Patrick Stefano, R-Fayette, chairman of the Game and Fisheries Committee, shortly after Mr. Arway announced his retirement. “Anglers can know that Fish and Boat will be put back on course, and we’re taking the politics out of wildlife conservation.”

Senate Bill 935 was dropped on news of Mr. Arway’s retirement. His last day will be Nov. 2. Mr. Stefano and company now have the chance to get the unfunded agency “back on course” — not with money they control, but by allowing fishing and boating license holders to pay what they’ve long said was a fair increase for services rendered.

Advertise with us

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.