Outdoors Notebook

If the results of new research into fishing mortality are correct, catch-and-release should be called catch, release — and kill.

The popular conservation ethic was challenged in a California University at Riverside study of fishing mortality published last week in The Journal of Experimental Biology. Researchers reported that mouth injuries caused by hook removal after catch-and-release hampered the ability of suction-feeding fish to capture prey.

The report stated that bass, salmon, trout and perch eat by rapidly expanding their mouths, creating negative pressure that sucks the prey inside. Timothy E. Higham, an associate professor studying the biomechanics and hydrodynamics of suction feeding, said in a release that the team explored whether a hole in the mouth caused by hook removal might reduce the pressure gradient, negatively impacting the fish’s ability to feed.

Advertise with us

“The suction feeding system is somewhat similar to how we drink liquid through a straw,” Mr. Higham said. “If you poke a hole in the side of your straw, it’s not going to work properly.”

In the study,10 shiner perch were caught with a hook and 10 were netted. All were immediately taken to a research station where feeding was recorded using a high-speed camera at 500 frames per second . Compared with the control group, maximum prey velocity -- striking speed -- was significantly lower in the injured group.

“As we predicted, the fish with the mouth injuries exhibited a reduction in the speed at which they were able to draw prey into their mouths,” Mr. Higham said.

The abstract concluded that despite hook-related inefficiencies in suction feeding, “it is currently unclear whether this has a significant impact on survival.”

The study was met with skepticism by anglers, fishing bloggers and fisheries management professionals. Immediate observation of the feeding of hooked-and-released fish before cheek wounds could heal was a poor way to evaluate their survival rate, many said.

Advertise with us

Domenick Swentosky, a fly fisherman, fishing guide and author of the TroutStricken.com blog, said he’s seen the impact of catch-and-release regulations first hand.

“There is no question that rivers and streams with C&R regs hold more trout than rivers without the restrictions,” he said. “The difference in fish population is dramatically different, even when only a section of a river is designated C&R. The catch and release sections always hold more trout.”

An abstract prepared by the California study’s authors began with a statement that sport fishing “may contribute to declining fish stocks.” However, that is not the case among the brackish-water surfperch studied or the bass, trout and salmon cited as examples.

The authors cited “questions about the practice of catch-and release fishing, which is viewed by many as a way to conserve at-risk fish species.” With no open seasons on endangered, threatened or threatened-candidate fish species in Pennsylvania, catch and release regulations on “at risk” species don’t apply.

Kristopher M. Kuhn, chief of the Fisheries Management Division at the state Fish and Boat Commission, said sport fisheries are managed at the population level, not with the intent to save the life of an individual fish. Incidental loss of an accidentally caught and poorly released fish does not threaten the population, he said.

Advertise with us

“Legal-sized or catchable hatchery-reared trout are stocked into select waters of the commonwealth to provide recreational angling opportunities for trout where they otherwise would not exist or to supplement low-density wild trout populations to enhance angling opportunities on a seasonal basis,” said Mr. Kuhn.

“They are stocked to provide immediate put-and-take fisheries, and the PFBC has no expectation that they will ‘hold over’ and reside in stocked waters for extended periods of time.”

The PFBC annually stocks approximately 3.15 million adult trout in 720 streams and 126 lakes open to public angling. With the popularity of catch and release, particularly in Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only areas, it is believed that anglers catch far more than 3.15 million trout per year despite the presence of hook holes in the mouths of some.

Fishing awards

At the end of the free 20-week TriAnglers fishing program, in which more than 400 participants caught 20 fish species off the North Shore, Venture Outdoors handed out commemorative plaques Wednesday to the most successful city-fishing participants.

Advertise with us

John Force of McKees Rocks won the Golden Rod Award for his summer of 101 catches, no doubt related to his accompanying Perfect Attendance Award. Frank McCormick of McKees Rocks was awarded for the Largest Catch, a 32-inch common carp. Landing six fish totaling 70 inches, Aubriee Syratton, 13, of the North Side won the Kids Golden Rod Award, and Vince Griffin, 8, of Mt. Lebanon got the Largest Kids Catch, a 24-inch common carp taken on a crawler.

See all of the TriAnglers awards at the Facebook group Explore the Outdoors with John Hayes.

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.

                                       Post-Gazette Outdoors Poll                                       

LAST WEEK: Will leashed dogs used to track wounded deer interfere with the hunts of others?

Advertise with us

Yes  63 %

No 37 %

625 responses

The poll is an unscientific tally of web postings generated by CivicScience.