It was harvest time at Rick Lowe's split-level home in rural Perry County, and the flypaper above his living room couch swung heavy with the dead.

Down some stairs, behind wooden doors, the pungent laboratory where Mr. Lowe practices his reverse alchemy was full of needles and glass jars brimming with things few folks would dare jar. Bottles of amber liquid on the shelves looked like apple cider, but the nose doesn't lie.

It was urine, gallons and gallons of whitetail deer urine, waiting to be shipped out and spread across the wilds of America.

"My stuff is fresh," Mr. Lowe, 54, said in his Lowe's Whitetail lab. "I use about a gallon of it myself."

Advertise with us

With Pennsylvania’s statewide archery deer season now underway, and subsequent whitetail seasons open almost continuously through January 2019, urine-based deer scents are in demand at sporting goods stores. They are controversial, however. Many hunters swear by them, but science has not proven their effectiveness and has no way to test the products for a disease that is killing deer nationwide.

The threat was on no one’s radar in 1985 when Paul Carson of Erie County turned 19 wooded acres into a deer farm that specializes in urine collection.

"I fenced in a couple of acres and bought a couple of deer.... I am one of the pioneers in Pennsylvania,” said Mr. Carson, owner of West Wind Whitetails and Scents. It is one of about 1,000 deer farms in the state, the second most in the U.S. after Texas, according to the Pennsylvania Deer Farmers Association.

But only a handful of the state’s deer farmers have managed to turn golden waste into a business. Collecting urine isn't as simple as dropping a bucket under a deer's rear end. They're skittish animals, even those bottle-fed as fawns. Bucks, particularly during the fall mating season, can be ornery.

"We cut their antlers off so they can't kill anyone," said Elam Lapp Jr., whose Nationwide Scents in Millersburg, Dauphin County, is one of the nation's biggest producers of doe urine.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lapp, 28, is Amish, and his family has been farming in Pennsylvania for generations. First, it was dairy cows. Eventually, the Lapps became deer farmers, raising trophy bucks for breeding stock and private hunting ranches before settling on urine.

“They'll pee 6-8 ounces per sitting, about a half-gallon a day, all year,” said Mr. Lapp. “Amish culture is farming. [But] it's just not very viable in this day and age for a small mom-and-pop operation.”

Mr. Lapp's operation doesn't feel mom-and-pop. Hundreds of deer live on more than 200 acres in two locations. They are moved indoors for collection for a few hours, into a 5,000-square-foot facility with raised stalls resembling giant rabbit hutches. They're given food and water; fans whirl loudly for ventilation.

The urine funnels down through filters and basic plumbing into the basement, where the sheer volume boggles the mind.

"They're 55-gallon drums," Mr. Lapp said, pointing to rows of white drums.

Advertise with us

He sells most of his product to companies that relabel it as their own, but has a special batch he freezes and ships direct to customers. The majority of deer urine comes from does, but there are variations. The most valuable is from does in estrus because they produce more estrogen, which some hunter believe draws in bucks ready to mate. Buck urine could attract a male looking to fight.

"I start collecting in the summer and I sell a lot of regular doe pee," Mr. Carson said. "I can sell a gallon of doe-in-estrus for $105 to $110. Dominant buck pee can go for about $60."

Urine industry statistics are murky because producers are lumped together under deer farming, which includes raising trophy deer for hunting preserves and deer for venison. A small percentage deal in urine. Mr. Lapp's operation is touted as the biggest in the country. A 2017 New Yorker article said deer urine was a "$100 million business."

One problem that has complicated the urine business is chronic wasting disease, a fatal, mad cow-like disease that affects deer, elk and moose. Because urine is one of the ways CWD can spread, some states and provinces, including Alaska, Arizona, Vermont, Virginia, Ontario and Nova Scotia, have banned its use in hunting.

Nicholas Haley, an assistant professor of microbiology at Midwestern University in Arizona, has studied CWD for a decade. Of all the liquids and body parts on a deer, Mr. Haley said urine has the lowest levels of “infectivity.” He believes regulatory agencies have targeted it for the wrong reasons.

Advertise with us

“Urine kind of represents this low-hanging fruit,” he said. “It's easy to regulate, and it makes it look like you're doing something to prevent the spread of CWD.”

In Pennsylvania, deer farming comes under the purview of the state Department of Agriculture, which requires farmers to take part in one of two CWD monitoring programs. The disease has not been detected in southwestern Pennsylvania.

After 25 years in the deer-scent business, Mr. Lowe has branched off into other areas, above and beyond mere urine, to attract deer and mask smelly humans. Some of his cover scents smell like acorn or hardwoods. He is experimenting with synthetics, but also makes deer “lures” from parts including testicles.

Like most deer-urine farmers, Mr. Lowe is very secretive about his operation.

“It's taken me years,” he said. “A lot of guys want to know how I make my stuff. I don't want to give enough information to be dangerous. I've had guys want to come out and take tours, and I just can't do it.”

Advertise with us