The faded, hand-written signs on a suburban street-side utility pole catch an angler’s eye, perhaps the way a crankbait calls to a bass.
“Fishing LURES,” reads one. Below that, “OVER 400 HAND MADE.”
An arrow points toward the front door, just steps off the street, of a modest Castle Shannon apartment, on which hangs another sign: “Grandpa’s Bait Shop.”
So the angler knocks. A man answers and invites the angler in.
There, on a table just inside the door, are boards displaying scores of colorful beaded spinners, all of which the man indeed makes by hand.
He is Jim Comley, 70, himself a lifelong angler. About 15 years ago, on an annual fishing trip on the Allegheny River up around Tionesta, what with various snags and line breaks, he lost $85 worth of lures.
“I said, ‘Hey! I’m building ’em myself.”
And so he came home and started doing just that, using beads from craft stores and hooks from Walmart. The prop spinners he cuts from sheet metal and bends and polishes, using a Dremel tool and emery boards. He blows on one to show how well it spins.
“It gives more vibration, which I think is better,” he says. “They can hear it.”
He pulls out a twin spinner the likes of which the angler has not seen — his invention — and says, “These are my favorites,” explaining how aggravating all that vibration is to the fish. “Aggravation is 50 percent of catching fish.”
Jim Comley and his fishing lures
And he doesn’t just make spinners.
From beneath the table he pulls a box of floating poppers made of cork and wood and decorated in a colorful array of paint, tacks, even feathers. In his palm he holds out an unfinished pair of mice, painted gray with black details, with eyes, nose and whiskers, legs and tails made from old paint brushes.
Another box is full of plugs, also decorated so artfully that the angler can’t believe the prices that the boxes also display: Two for $5 for the plugs, $2 for the poppers, three for $5 for the spinners.
The angler notices that the underside of the metal lips on the plugs are marked “G.”
That stands for “Good,” explains Comley, who will take his lures out to Peters Lake, Washington County, to test them to make sure the swimming and diving actions are just right. He’s tested them in a buddy’s aquarium and in a pool. He runs them under the faucet.
He’s loved fishing ever since he was a boy, growing up in the McKees Rocks Bottoms, beneath the McKees Rocks Bridge, where he’d fish for catfish and carp.
He worked building pallet racking — warehouse shelving — for H.J. Heinz, traveling the country with a crew, and he’d fish on those trips, too.
Now that he’s retired and divorced, his fishing lure workshop is in the bedroom of his apartment. The living room is his main sales showroom. Sometimes he still goes to Trader Jack’s Flea Market in Collier, where on a good day he might sell a couple hundred lures. But that’s hard on his legs.
His hands are good, though. He also uses them to craft battery-powered minnow buckets that he also sells. And walking sticks.
He even makes dollhouse furniture. But, “For my granddaughter. Nobody else.”
She’s the one who picked the electric turquoise, purple and pink for one of the poppers he made, cleverly carved so the hook would ride above the water and not get caught in the weeds. Not his usual color scheme but, “Girls fish, too.”
He smiles recounting how one woman asked him to cut off the barbs on the hooks of two of his spinners so she could wear them as earrings. “They looked good, too.” Another woman slammed on the brakes as she drove past his place so she could yell, “I caught a smallmouth bass and a big bluegill on your lure!”
On nice nights, he’ll sit out there on his front porch and work on lures while listening to the Pirates or the Steelers on his White-Westinghouse radio, pausing occasionally to smoke a Pall Mall. He starts with branches and bits of small oak trees from the woods behind the apartment. With his thumb covered with protective tape, whittles off the bark and sands them so smooth and white that they look and feel like bones.
From there, he says, “Whatever I feel like, that’s what I make. I make whatever comes out, you know what I mean?”
He insists it’s not difficult, but no, he hasn’t inspired any of his buddies to make their own. Not when they can try to mooch them off him. Even they tell him he should charge other people more money. But he says, “I’m not looking to make a killing on them.”
He knows how valuable some old handmade fishing lures can be, and seems to realize that his prices are low, but he may not fully appreciate his lures as little works of folk art. The angler buys a handful, thinking for a moment that he might rather collect than use them, and what a shame it’d be to lose one on a snag. But then he thinks what a shame it would be to not fish with them.
“To take it to the water and catch fish on it,” Comley says, “that’s what it’s all about. I love that.”
You can catch Comley some Sundays at Trader Jack’s as well as at 831 Sleepy Hollow Road, Castle Shannon, PA 15234 and reach him by calling 412-354-2192.
Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.