When the Pennsylvania Game Commission set up 100 cameras in the woods, it wasn’t looking to film the next “Blair Witch Project.” With the cameras set up for a total of 17,944 24-hour periods in 339 locations taking more than 200,000 photos, the Game Commission studied the population of fawns and their survival habits in three Pennsylvania forests starting in 2015.

“Consistent survival rates create a more straightforward deer management situation in Pennsylvania than in other areas where survival varies from year to year,” said Chris Rosenberry, Ph. D., the Pennsylvania Game Commission’s deer and elk section leader. “Because of this consistency, we can more productively manage deer population trends by adjusting antlerless harvest”

There has been no evidence of predators taking too many fawns in the 23 wildlife management units (WMUs) in Pennsylvania, with four WMUs having their populations increase in the past several years, with the other 19 remaining stable. However, the Pennsylvania Game Commission has set a plan in case predators make a significant impact on the fawn population.

“If predator impacts are too high, management options are limited, but some can be effective,” Rosenberry said. He added that though the first thought usually is to control or reduce predator populations, those options are typically not effective for several reasons, including the fact that in Pennsylvania, many deer hunters do not support reducing the bear population to increase the population of deer. “As a result, reducing bear populations would be difficult from a social perspective,” he said.

Advertise with us

Another reason Rosenberry gave as to why predator management would not be effective was the resiliency of the coyote population. He mentioned that hunters can hunt coyotes 24/7, 365 days a year, but in Pennsylvania, the population does fairly well regardless.

The last option Rosenberry gave, should fawn survival ever become an issue, was adjustment of antlerless deer hunting opportunities across the commonwealth. He said that fawn to doe ratios are measured each year and represent the fawns that survive predators during the harvest season and that 90 percent of all deer survive from season to season. Predators do kill fawns, but the current plan is to mentor predator impacts and adjust deer harvests as needed to sustain deer populations.

“Studies have shown that when fawn survival changes a lot over time, it can influence population growth rates,” said Tess Gingery, a wildlife and fisheries science grad student at Penn State. “But since Pennsylvania fawn survival shows little change over time, this means that it’s probably pretty stable and this is a definite good thing for managers and everyone else.”

Gingery presented statistics comparing the current studies done in the northern area, Susquehannock State Forest, and in the southern area, Rothrock and Bald Eagle State Forests, with 2000-01 studies done in Quehanna and in Penns Valley, respectively.

She found that the main sources of fawn mortality are predation, in the form of black bears, bobcats, and coyotes; natural death, from starvation, disease and abandonment; and humans, both directly through hunting and becoming roadkill and indirectly, such as when they become caught in fences.

Advertise with us

In the Quehanna study in 2001, it was discovered that 34-week survival among fawns was 38 percent, with the leading cause of mortality being predation, with black bears being the predator 69.5 percent of the time. In this year’s northern area study, those numbers went up, with 40 percent of fawns surviving the timeframe and black bears being 75 percent of total predation mortalities.

In the original Penns Valley study, the survival was 53 percent with the leading cause of death being humans at 42.6 percent. Predation only accounted for 17 percent. In the current southern study, the survival rate dropped to 51 percent, with predation being the leading cause of mortality at 47.4 percent. Humans only contributed to 13.2 percent of deaths. This was attributed to the fact that Penns Valley had more agricultural land cover where sources of mortality came from humans.

“Ultimately, the no differences in fawn survival between study areas currently and no differences between 2000 and now is a good thing,” Gingery said.

The United States Geological Survey (USGS) Pennsylvania cooperative fish and wildlife research unit representative, Duane Diefenbach, Ph.D., discussed that at this point of the year, approximately half of the fawns have been born and the other half will be born by late June or early July.

As of 2018, 2,649 fawns have been captured and monitored in North America, 383 (15 percent) of which have come from Pennsylvania. Diefenbach said that, in the 1990s, technology to study fawns improved, which allowed for better research. He added that the collar that is still used today was designed for the 2000-01 Pennsylvania study. Pennsylvania is the only state that has studied fawn survival in four different areas and two different time periods.

Advertise with us

Gingery said that of 82 fawns tracked in the northern study, 44 died, with six mortalities coming from humans, with five killed in harvest and one on the road. Five were natural death, and 33 were attributed to predators (18 bear, 8 coyote, 2 bobcat, 5 unknown).

Of the 83 fawns from the southern study, there were 38 mortalities, five from humans, with three harvested and two as roadkill, 13 natural deaths, 18 predator deaths, five from bears, six from coyotes, five from bobcats, and two unknown, with two additional mortalities where the cause of death was unknown.

From 2002-05, predator density increased 40 percent and deer density decreased 21 percent and have increased or remained stable since.

Asia Murphy, an ecology grad student at Penn State explained that scent attractants were added to the cameras to lure carnivores to the sites. She said that raccoons detected the most, that bears also a major detection, and that regardless, fawns were detected more often than the three main predators — bears (64 percent of sites), coyotes (36 percent), and bobcats (60 percent).

The study also accounted for predators in the area that were not detected, saying that the percentage for coyotes would go up to 42 percent and bobcats would spike to 60. Deer were found at 97 percent of sites, with fawns seen at 44 percent, 47 when calculating in the percentage of cameras that did not detect fawns.

Murphy also detailed how fawns were more likely to be found in non-forest areas, as it is safer to raise fawns there. She said that does also tended to move outside the forests for the summer to raise the fawns to avoid predators.