An Erie County boater who claims that an illegal stop by state Fish and Boat Commission authorities violated his Constitutional rights will face a panel of Pennsylvania Superior Court justices in Pittsburgh Tuesday.

Fred Karash of Erie claims he was boating on Lake Erie in May, 2017, when Fish and Boat Conservation officers stopped his vessel, boarded and inspected it. The officers notes he had just four life jackets when his party of five was required by state law to have five jackets aboard. PFBC issued Karash a $40 ticket and a judge found him guilty.

Claiming the stop was illegal, Karash appealed the ticket and represented himself before three Superior Court justices in August.

“His argument was, the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution says police cannot search [a citizen’s] home or possessions without probable cause,” said Caroline Mitchell, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union who is now representing Karash. “He and friends were peacefully motor boating on Lake Erie … The waterways conservation officers stopped Fred’s boat at 7:30 p.m. for an hour to do a ‘stop and board equipment inspection.’ A PFBC boat with flashing lights pursues you, then they command you to stop and be boarded. Officers come on board and start looking through all your equipment,” she said in an email message.

Advertise with us

Mitchell said the stop was done without probable cause that Karash had committed a crime, such as not having the proper navigation lights or current registration numbers.

In a 2 to 1 decision, the Superior Court agreed with Karash, voiding the stop on grounds that it violated the Fourth Amendment. In turn, Fish and Boat appealed and the case will be heard Tuesday.

“The ACLU believes this is a very important case,” said Mitchell. “The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, since 1980, has been stopping any boat anywhere. PFBC gets to keep all the money it collects in fines, almost $1 million last year.

Mitchell said if the Superior Court rules in favor of Karash, Fish and Boat will no longer be allowed to stop boaters, demand ID and search the people, their boats and cars for evidence of crimes unless the officer first has reasonable suspicion that the citizen has committed a crime.

“The Pennsylvania General Assembly has given Waterways Conservation Officers the authority by statute to conduct boating safety inspections to help keep Pennsylvania boats and their passengers safe,” said John Arway, executive director of the Fish and Boat Commission. “We are confident that the Superior Court will see these safety inspections as the valuable tool they are for protecting the lives of Pennsylvania’s boaters.”

Advertise with us

Tackle shop closes

In 2007 the Post-Gazette needed live bait. Ed Vaccari, owner of Tackle Unlimited, was netting shiners from an aerated tub when he learned the bait would be used at a children’s fishing event. He paused.

“Put your money away,” he said. “These are on me. Any time you’re doing anything for kids you come to me and I’ll supply the bait.”

Since then Tackle Unlimited of Jefferson Hills has donated hundreds of dozens of red worms, crawlers, mealworms, waxworms, butter worms, shiners and fatheads for use at Post-Gazette Family Fishing activities throughout southwestern Pennsylvania. He requested that his name and shop not be credited with the donations, and there’s no telling how many kids caught their first fish on Vaccari’s bait.

After 50 years in the bait and tackle business, Vaccari will retire at the end of April. Tackle Unlimited, the Route 51 fishing shop with the shark head above the door, will close its doors for good.

Advertise with us

“It’s been a long haul,” Vaccari said. “This started as a hardware shop in Clairton where we sold some bait, and it grew into its own place. I always liked to help the kids because they’re the future. If they don’t learn how to fish now they’ll probably never pick it up.”

Tackle Unlimited’s going-out-of-business sale will continue through the month, but Vaccari made a final donation for kids of the Pittsburgh region — enough live bait to supply all of the Post-Gazette Family Fishing events through 2018.

Vaccari’s son will carry on the family business in West Newton, Westmoreland County. Joe’s Tackle Unlimited will open May 1 at 112 Walnut Lane behind the Rite-Aid. For details, call 412-735-9769.