Until weeks ago, Pennsylvania was the only state that still banned all hunting use of air rifles and semiautomatic rifles.

But the perception of contradicting signals and restrictions ultimately placed on their use have quashed what would normally be a surge in sales following the rare introduction of new classes of sporting arms.

Since the 1960s, only two new categories of sporting arms have been permitted for hunting in Pennsylvania: compound bows and crossbows. While the gradual introduction of the crossbow was controversial, the legal hunting use of both were met with predictable spikes in retail sales.

Not so with air rifles and semi-automatic rifles, which became legal for some hunting with the start of the 2017-18 seasons.

Advertise with us

In 2016 the state legislature amended the Game and Wildlife Code to make the rifles legal for hunting under regulatory structures to be set by the state Game Commission. In January 2017 commissioners preliminarily approved a proposal that would have allowed air rifles and semiautomatic rifles to be used in any hunting season that permitted the use of traditional sporting arms. Such a ruling would not have introduced new categories of guns into the state, and many range shooters who had been using them for years were excited by the prospect of finally taking them into the field.

But at the commissioners’ meeting in March, members unexpectedly voted to go slow, approving the hunting use of semiautomatic rifles and air rifles but only in low calibers for some game animals. The board made no additions to the list of lawful sporting arms for hunting big game.

“Well, that took the wind out of the sails for a lot of guys who’ve been shooting semi-automatics at targets and expected to use them for deer,” said Walter Annigan of Westmoreland County, who said he likes the “bam-bam-bam” of the centerfire semiautomatics he shoots on his backyard range. “What stopped [commissioners] so abruptly after signaling that they’d be legal [for hunting]?” he asked.

“We listened to our hunters,” said Brian Hoover, Game Commission president, in a statement.

According to a March release, following the preliminary vote in January Game Commission staff conducted a random sample mail survey of 4,000 Pennsylvania hunters. In more than 2,000 responses hunters expressed mixed support for the introduction of semiautomatic rifles. The findings showed clear support for their use in hunting furbearers (55 percent supported or strongly supported) and woodchucks (51 percent supported or strongly supported). For small game 42 percent supported or strongly supported the use of semiautomatic rifles, and 12 percent neither supported nor opposed.

Advertise with us

The survey showed, however, that Pennsylvania hunters drew the line at big game hunting.

“... While 28 percent of survey respondents expressed support or strong support for semiautomatic rifles, 64 percent of respondents said they opposed or strongly opposed semiautomatic rifles for big game hunting, with 52 percent saying they were strongly opposed,” stated the Game Commission release. “The results bolstered the expressed opposition to hunting big game with semiautomatic rifles that appeared to a lesser extent in the written comments the Game Commission received [prior to the January meeting].”

As a result of the board’s appraisal of the the survey, in the 2017-18 license year semiautomatic rifles in .22-caliber or smaller propelling a single projectile are legal for small game. There are no caliber restrictions for the semiautomatic rifle hunting of groundhogs and furbearers. There are no magazine-capacity restrictions for any lawful hunting use of semiautomatic rifles.

Modern air rifles powered by compressed air, gas or chemicals have muzzle velocities far slower than traditional firearms, but they’re fast enough to cause a "crack" when their pellets or bullets break the sound barrier. They’re not toys. High-caliber air rifles are capable of dropping African big game at 100 yards, but in Pennsylvania their hunting use may have been restricted simply because the proposal was attached to the semi-automatic rifle law.

In the 2017-18 seasons, air rifles in calibers ranging from .177 to .22 and propelling single-projectile pellets or bullets are legal for hunting small game, groundhogs and furbearers including foxes and coyotes. The use of air guns to hunt big game, including deer, remains illegal statewide. It remains illegal to shoot any animal with BBs.

Advertise with us

The Game Commission board said in March that if hunter support for harvesting big game with semiautomatic rifles were to grow, further regulatory changes would be considered, suggesting that semiautomatic deer hunting could be in Pennsylvania’s future.

The Oct. 14 opening of squirrel season was the most likely time for the introduction of hunting with semiautomatic rifles and air rifles, but the “bam-bam-bam” and quiet sonic crack are being heard rarely anywhere in the state. Neither the Game Commission, gun trade associations or the retail shops that were queried knew of any significant increases in the sale of air rifles or semiautomatic rifles.

“Customers haven’t really asked us about them,” said Bruce Piendl, owner of Allegheny Arms and Gun Works in Bethel Park. “I have a fairly good understanding of the products, and we can get them in easily, but I don’t think there’s much enthusiasm for them. It’s more like confusion.”

Piendl said the Game Commission’s hot and cool approach to regulating semiautomatics has left potential customers uncertain about making the investment.

“Based on what was said [in January], we thought when [semiautomatics] were made legal we would see centerfires,” he said. “We made sure to get the most common centerfire magazines for semiautomatics. Then they didn’t follow through with it.”

Advertise with us

From his side of the counter, said Piendl, it appears that younger shooters, particularly those with military experience, are most likely to embrace semiautomatic rifles. In fact, questions have been raised regarding the methodology of the Game Commission survey that swayed the decision to restrict their use. If most licensed Pennsylvania hunters are of an older generation raised with traditional sporting arms, the survey may have unintentionally under-represented younger range shooters who might buy a license if they could use their semiautomatic rifles for deer.

“At a time when license sales are down, that’s something that maybe should be considered,” said Piendl.

Nationwide sales of semiautomatic rifles have been growing since the end of World War II. Mike Bazinet, spokesman for the National Shooting Sports Foundation trade association, suggested the Pennsylvania ban on their hunting use has curbed sales as compared to other states.

“I don’t remember people talking about [semiautomatic rifles] controversially in any way, except the die-hard conservative hunters,” he said. “We don’t keep records on air rifles, but it seems that as hunters learn that they can humanely dispatch an animal, and the ammunition is less expensive, sales naturally increase. It wouldn’t surprise me if once Pennsylvania accepts [semiautomatic rifles and air rifles] as sporting arms, the market for them will grow.”