The first hit jolted my spinnerbait after just a few casts, and the fish was boated in seconds. The second smallmouth ran deeper and fought longer.
Jet-boating among the Allegheny River riffles and drifting through the fast water, hookups occurred at nearly every stop. By about 1:30 p.m., guide Jeff Knapp and I had released about 20 smallmouths, most between 15 and 17 inches. He called it an “average” day on the Middle Allegheny.
Something is happening on Pennsylvania’s waterways. The change isn’t visible but it’s as certain as the first frost.
As daylight hours shorten and the weather starts to cool, rivers and their tributaries begin to lose their summer warmth and enter an annual winter phase. Just when most anglers are getting off the water, conditions favor the bigger fish.
“Usually around the end of September, early October, the water temperature will get down to the low 60s. Smallmouth bass in particular make a shift from where they were in summer,” said Knapp, an outdoors writer and proprietor of Keystone Connection guide service.
“In the summer months when water temperatures are warm -- 75 to 80 degrees -- they’re typically in areas that are associated with current. It could be pocket water close to a riffle, the heads of pools where a chute of water comes in, tail-outs of pools where the velocity increases as the pool shallows off,” he said. “As temperatures drop they’ll start making a shift in their location into areas with less current. By the time the water gets cold, down to the 40-degree range, they’ll be in deeper water where they’ll be all winter,” said Knapp.
Now is the in-between time, the annual transition period when smallmouths follow forage fish as they move from warm shallow water to deeper well-protected areas and back when the water warms again.
The shift in smallmouth holding positions generally begins in late September and early October. Three days before we launched in lower Venango County, moderate rain had dropped the water temperature to about 60 degrees. The river was high and slightly cloudy.
“Today we caught them in their summer spots. The water is up close to 70 degrees,” said Knapp. “We were faced with a river that was 1 ½-feet higher than a few days before -- not only higher flows but dirtier flows. That change shifted the fish’s position somewhat. That’s one of the challenges of fishing a river. You have to be versatile.”
We caught bass on spinnerbaits and brightly colored soft-plastics.
Bait fish, small and with slower metabolism, have a hard time adjusting to winter temperatures. They don’t have the energy to fight the force of current. They’re slower in cooler water and they know it. Feeling safer in deeper, slow-moving pools with rocky structure, they lead the predators out of the riffles when the temperature cools.
“In the Allegheny there are a lot of things [for smallmouths] to eat, but one of the main food species is the streamlined chub, which the locals call ripple runners or bluedots,” said Knabb. “That baitfish, as the name implies, likes the fast water. That keeps the smallmouths and walleye up in the faster water when the weather is warm. In early fall, when water temperatures can vary, [baitfish] stay in the shallows when they can but when it cools they’ll drop into deeper pools and the predators follow.”
Habitat changes and winter flow also dictate where smallmouths will position for feeding.
“Fish regardless of species are subject to the physical force of the current,” said Knapp. “The current is the biggest influence on any river fish. Winter flow is different than in the summer and that will impact to a degree where the fish are.”
Metabolism is also the reason that cooler waters favor bigger fish. It’s a law of nature that applies equally in lakes and rivers.
“Smaller fish will move because of flow, but temperature probably has more to do with it,” said Knapp. “All the bass will follow forage fish to deeper areas when the water cools -- I don’t think the smaller bass do that any less than big bass. But the bigger bass with greater metabolism are faster, more mobile and might be getting to the bait faster.”
He said his clients start pulling out more bass 20 inches or greater during the current in-between time, and the frequency of big catches increases through November.
“After that, everything is pretty well settled for winter,” said Knapp. “Water conditions will affect the fishing, but there’s not another major change until spring.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.