Two things could have happened Wednesday in Room 60 in the East Wing of the State Capitol.

The House Game and Fisheries Committee could have approved two Senate bills that would authorize the Fish and Boat Commission and Game Commission to set their own license fees -- legislation that was passed overwhelmingly by the Senate as recently as March.

Or the committee could have struck the measures down, a possibility in a vote that would fundamentally change the wildlife agency funding model for the first time in nearly 100 years.

Instead the committee questioned the size of the Game Commission’s motor pool.

Advertise with us

“They brought the Game bill up for discussion and then tabled it because of an audit by the Auditor General. Then they just ended the meeting,” said John Arway, executive director of the Fish and Boat Commission. “They didn’t even bring up our bill. It has nothing to do with the audit. We need that bill for next year. If we don’t get it we can’t meet expenses in the 2017-18 budget. We’re going to have to look at reductions in service.”

PG graphic: Inability to pass Senate Bill 30

(Click image for larger version)

Last year, Auditor General Eugene DePasquale ordered an audit of the Game Commission after questions were raised about the number of motor vehicles in its fleet. Then-executive director Matt Hough acknowledged the proposed audit, but said without a license fee increase his agency, too, would have to do less.

“We are now past the point of making the types of cuts that potentially will go unnoticed,” Hough said in his 2016 Annual Legislative Report, released in February. “... Until we are permitted a license-fee increase that will provide additional revenue, other impactful cuts simply are unavoidable.”

Advertise with us

Bryan J. Burhans, who started last month as the Game Commission’s new executive director, was unavailable for comment.

According to the agency’s 2016 annual report, the Game Fund was in the black in 2015-16 and nearly $7 million higher than in the previous year. Projections through the 2019-20 hunting seasons show a deficit reaching $10 million.

After a year of legislative compromise, jointly advancing Senate Bill 30 (Fish and Boat) and Senate Bill 192 (Game) offered lawmakers their most palatable option in replacing a funding model that no longer works in Pennsylvania.

State fishing and hunting license sales are down over the long term, as are the attached federal contributions. The collapse of the shale gas boom slowed revenues from leases on properties owned by the wildlife agencies. Federal excise taxes on the sale of guns, ammunition, fishing gear and boat fuel, which are redirected proportionally back to the states, are not applied to the growing numbers of hikers, bikers, birders, skiiers and other wildlife watchers who expect to see the results of wildlife management they don’t pay for.

Other funding remedies -- agency merger and direct state funding -- failed to gain legislative traction despite repeated tries.

Advertise with us

Milk prices rise. Gas prices rise. But Pennsylvania fishing license fees have stayed the same since 2005, in fact, the fee was reduced by $1 in 2015. Hunting license fees haven’t budged in nearly 20 years.

Arway said license fees could keep pace with his agency’s rising costs. But there’s a problem.

“We ask the legislature to raise license fees and they tell us it’s the wrong time for them to raise costs on their constituents,” he said. “We ask again year after year and finally the need is so great they approve a big increase, and we lose 10 percent of license sales because of sticker shock.”

The theory pushing SB30 and SB192 is that commissioners at both agencies would raise fees incrementally rather than risk a big bump that would chase away customers. License fee adjustments would be subject to the commissions’ rule-making processes and include public comment periods. And to guard against the possibility of irrationally steep fee increases, a sunset provision would require a legislative vote after three years.

It is not clear if the funding bills will be presented again this year.

Advertise with us

Auditor General DePasquale’s planned audit of the Game Commission is expected to explore the agency’s motor pool, which includes 636 vehicles for its 760 full-time employees. The Legislative Budget and Finance Committee reported that in 2012-13 the agency spent an average of $1,600 on maintenance for each vehicle.

No plan has been announced for a similar audit of Fish and Boat. Last year the agency had 432 vehicles, 381 employees and spent $1,500 on average for maintenance per vehicle.

Spokesmen for the wildlife agencies have noted their use of tanker trucks, off road transports, landscaping equipment and other specialty vehicles.