ERIE, Pa. -- At the first hint of a bump you react, driving the barb deep into something so heavy and immovable you’re sure it’s a submerged log. Until the log starts moving upstream and you realize you’ve hooked into a 2 ½-foot slab of tail-walking muscle.

As steelhead circle off Lake Erie tributaries, staging to run with the next big rain, northbound anglers should put some thought into improving their chances of landing big fish. Newcomers to Steelhead Alley will have little use for their experience with most stocked trout, and even veteran steelheaders could shake off old habits that have kept their “hookups” higher than their “catches.”

Big fish are different. They know they’re big. They bully smaller fish, steal the best feeding lanes and expect to get their way. On the hook they play the current, run, wrap around structure, scrape against rocks and defiantly leap out of the water. In most cases they have the advantage. Anglers who simply throw their trout gear into the trunk may have already made their first mistake.

Steelhead bus trip

Advertise with us

Join outdoors editor John Hayes and Trout Unlimited fishing coaches on a motorcoach fishing trip to a Lake Erie tributary on Sat., Nov. 19. The cost is $50. Live bait, flies and spinners welcome. Valid state fishing license and Lake Erie permit required. Free all-day parking at International Angler, Robinson. Under 18 years accompanied by an adult. Pack a lunch and water, and prepare for all weather. Buy-your-own dinner stop on the ride home. No alcohol. Reserve your seat at 412-263-1741.

“You can get away with it, but you’ll find out very quickly that you’re outgunned,” said steelhead guide and author John Nagy of Brookline, whose book “Steelhead Guide: Fly Fishing Techniques and Strategies for Lake Erie Steelhead" (Great Lakes Publishing) is now in its fourth edition.

The tip of a fly or spinning rod should be light and flexible enough that the fish won’t feel it on the pickup. A sturdy butt section helps maintain control during the fight.

A medium- or light-weight spinning outfit will do, but it will lose more big fish than a smarter, lighter alternative. Noodle rods, named for their pretzel flexibility, are longer -- 10 ½ feet or more provides better leverage on the fish. The slow spring action provides a continuous pull away from the fish, keeping the line tight and the fish on. Noodle rods can be used to fish bait, lures or flies.

“Most fly rods are designed for casting fly lines at distance. They’re not designed to play big fish on a light tippet,” said Nagy. “Use the lightest fly rod you can get. A stiffer 9-foot fly rod can work, but a 10 ½-foot rod and 6-weight line is better.”

Advertise with us

On his website (www.johnnagysteelheadguide.com), Nagy markets a custom “noodle” fly rod crafted to his specifications.

Leave the trout flies at home -- steelhead will straighten those thin-wire hooks. Nagy ties steelhead patterns on scud, nymph or streamer hooks made of high-strength steel rated 2x or 3x strong. Smaller is better for bigger steelhead, he said -- hook size 12 to 14 or smaller. Before the first cast, with spinning and fly reels, set the drag to force the fish to use valuable energy when pulling out line.

Unless a mono line is badly nicked up, it is weakest at the knots. Tippets might be too light for the fight, but in most cases when the line snaps from the stress of a big fish, it’s at a knot. The curly tip at the end of a break-off shows where a weak knot unraveled.

Fighting a big, strong steelhead requires rod-handling techniques that may never be needed on stocked trout. It’s all about control -- rod control, line control, fish control. Lose control -- give it to the fish -- and it’s likely to win the fight.

“Never point the line straight at the fish. It will probably snap the line,” said Ed Kissell, vice-president of S.O.N.S. of Lake Erie, a long-time Lake Erie fishing advocacy group. “If you hold the rod straight up you’ll have no leverage on the fish. You want the rod at an angle, so its spring action absorbs [the fish’s movements] while keeping constant tension on the line.”

Advertise with us

Big fish will not forgive a moment of slack line. Keep it tight throughout the fight. If the fish runs toward you, reel or strip in fast. Big fish on a hook try to loosen the line by jumping. Allow a little slack and that bruiser is the one that got away.

“I would probably let a big fish have its way until it’s tired out,” said Kissell. “But if it’s running for an overhang or a fallen tree, or going downstream in a fast current, you have to control its movement. You have to turn the fish.”

With the rod bowed, swing it downward to the right or left until it’s nearly parallel to the water surface. Do it right -- no slack, no horsing -- and the fish will be turned in the direction of the pressure.

At the end of the fight, you have two options: banking or netting. When the shoreline is right and the fish has tired, you might be able to scootch it into very shallow water or onto the bank. Horse the line and the tippet will snap; allow slack and you’ve lost control and might lose the fish.

“On the lake or a creek, I’d rather net a big fish if I can,” said Kissell. “You want a larger net with a 3-foot handle. When the fish is tired, reel in to about the rod’s length and lift the tip.”

Advertise with us

As you do, the fish will be slowly pulled closer. Be prepared to react to a sudden run. If it’s cooperating, hold the net a foot downstream from the tail and let your trophy drift backward into the net and lift. You got him.

“Don’t play these steelhead too long,” said Kissell. “The guys around you won’t like you taking that much time, and the fish could die from exhaustion, which is a terrible thing if you’re releasing.”