Last week, following the discovery of pollutants in catfish, a 4-mile stretch of the Susquehanna River was declared to be “impaired.” It’s a legal term that releases state and federal remediation funds and sets consequences if the problem is not resolved.

But the real news out of the state Department of Environmental Protection, according the agency’s research partners, is that the rest of the river didn’t get the same designation.

Since 2005, the Susquehanna’s legendary smallmouth bass fishery has suffered widespread young-of-year mortality, and some 20,000 smallmouths have been sampled bearing sores, lesions and melanoma spots. No clear cause for the disease has been found and, curiously, it only impacts smallmouths.

The river has additional problems. In 2003, researchers at Chesapeake Bay found the Susquehanna was responsible for 44 percent of the nitrogen, 21 percent of the phosphorus and 21 percent of the sediment pouring into the bay at 18 million gallons per minute, contributing to oxygen-deprived “dead zones” where most aquatic animals can not survive.

Advertise with us

In a joint study of the bass disease released this year, DEP, the state Fish and Boat Commission and partner organizations confirmed a connection between smallmouth infections, agricultural runoff and municipal sewage discharge, with parasite infestation a secondary complication.

But DEP’s analysis of the report did not result in a downgrade of the Susquehanna’s water-quality status. A few miles where catfish contain PCB chemicals got the “impaired” designation. An existing fish consumption advisory was expanded, and action on the declining smallmouth population was deferred until 2018.

John Arway, executive director of Fish and Boat, saidt based on the report’s mission and findings, the DEP focus on contaminated catfish makes no sense.

“Despite how long this has been going on, all the research that’s been done, this doesn’t address the issue,” he said. “The primary decision about whether to list [as impaired] or not was because of the health of the bass. The local [catfish] issue that the DEP deals with here has nothing to do with the health of the bass and the larger problems that we’ve researched.”

Harry Campbell, executive director of the Chesapeake Bay Foundation, said DEP’s limited impairment designation also doesn’t address the Lower Susquehanna’s impacts on the bay.

Advertise with us

“Considering the plight of the smallmouth bass, not declaring the Lower Susquehanna to be impaired is another example of Pennsylvania’s continued lack of leadership, dedication and investment when it comes to following through...,” he said in a statement. “Pennsylvania is not serving the needs of its citizens or the animals that rely on clean water for their very lives.”

In a subsequent telephone interview Campbell softened his tone, conceding that DEP is tasked with managing an issue that is “extremely complicated and complex.”

“As a scientist, I think I understand their reasoning. They’re trying to be risk averse,” he said. “[Pennsylvania] has no fully developed protocols and standards to list a river as impaired due to a single fish species. Macroinvertebrates are what we typically utilize in identifying water quality.”

But Maryland and other states have issued aquatic impairment designations based on unidentified problems plaguing a single fish species.

“We’ve studied this,” Campbell said. “Whatever it is, we know smallmouth bass are acutely affected by it -- they’re the canary in the coalmine as it pertains to water quality.”

Advertise with us

The report sheds light on.the limited impairment decision. Since 2012, continuous monitoring of water temperature, dissolved oxygen, pH and specific conductance every half hour at numerous locations in the river has not detected water quality criteria violations, with the exception of high bacteria counts in some places. Despite all the research, the report states there’s not enough data to satisfy established protocols required for assessing whether it’s a problem with the fish or a problem with the water.

“DEP needs to first establish the diseases are caused by water quality problems or show that the fish or macroinvertebrate communities as a whole are impaired,” said DEP spokesman Neil Shader. “Neither is yet established with any certainty.”

The study identified hormone-altering chemicals and micro-organisims common in agricultural runoff and municipal sewage, as well as parasites, as the most likely causes of the smallmouth problem.

“DEP has greatly expanded its efforts to collect samples to determine if they are found in areas where the diseases are present,” said Shader.

But DEP’s major collaborators in the study say remediation can -- in fact, must by legal contract -- start before a definitive cause of the disease is proven. In 2010 Pennsylvania committed to a timetable, the Clean Water Blueprint, mandating that 60 percent of relevant pollution-reduction actions must be in place by 2017. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency was to enforce the Blueprint, but has taken no actions despite missed deadline.

Advertise with us

“DEP [seems to be] afraid to act because of what we don’t know, so they’ve postponed decisions until we know,” said Arway. “EPA has come in to take control when they believed the state wasn’t acting to the letter of the law in other Clean Water Act issues The question is, will they now?”

Campbell said the issue puts DEP in a tough spot politically.

“By listing the river as impaired, the primary thing it does is hold accountable current and future [Pennsylvania] administrations,” he said. “Once it’s listed as impaired, a source has to be found and it has to improve.”