It’s common among mammals for males to leave or be pushed from family groups, disperse beyond their home ranges, establish and defend their own territories and compete with other males for mating rights. Hunters and wildlife managers have long acted on the assumption that the familiar mechanism applied to white-tailed deer.

But a study published last month in the Journal of Wildlife Management found that although whitetail does disperse at a lower rate than bucks, those that relocate typically travel more than twice as far as the males and wander in more convoluted paths covering larger areas.

Dispersal, the permanent movement of an animal away from its place of birth, is evolutionarily important because it controls gene flow and reduces the potential for inbreeding. Dispersal cuts down on competition for breeding partners, food and other resources, and influences overall population growth.

The new data will likely be of interest among wildlife managers, hunters concerned about antlerless deer allocations and urban governments searching for deer control options.

Advertise with us

“The motivation for our work was scientific. It’s interesting to understand how doe dispersal might impact deer dynamics,” said noted deer researcher Duane Diefenbach, an adjunct professor of wildlife ecology at Penn State, leader of the Pennsylvania Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit and a co-author of the report. “But I can see how some of the data could be of value to other purposes, particularly in controlling the spread of diseases.”

The paper was co-authored by Chris Rosenberry, head of the deer and elk team at the state Game Commission, and Clayton Lutz, a Penn State masters degree candidate who has since been hired by the Game Commission.

Dispersal among male deer occurs at a high rate and much about it is known. Male yearlings are most likely to set off on their own in spring when they’re chased off by their mothers or socially dominant females, or during the rut when they find themselves on the losing end of mating competition. Bucks typically disperse 5 to 7½ miles, but movements of 125 miles and more have been reported.

Female dispersal is less common. The low rate has limited efforts to identify influences that impact relocation. Diefenbach said new technology made the current research possible.

In four Pennsylvania wildlife management units located in Armstrong, Wayne, Potter and Elk, and Juniata and Perry counties, 227 juvenile does were fitted with GPS radio collars. Twenty-seven dispersed beyond home ranges. The behavior occurred when the does were 1 year old, coincided with the spring fawning season and generally lasted two days. In an unexpected find, about half of all yearling females journeyed several miles outside of their natal ranges before returning home without permanently dispersing.

Advertise with us

The movements were anything but consistent. One doe in the study wandered for more than 55 days, traveling 160 miles crossing an interstate highway twice and three major rivers four times before settling on a new territory just 20 miles from where she was born.

As with the males, the dispersal paths followed no common direction or speed.

“Clayton went back into the literature and found studies of female dispersal,” said Diefenbach. “Data from other studies helped us to identify the relationship between deer density and female dispersal. As the population rises there an increase in the percentage of yearling females that disperse.”

The research has deer-management implications in states like Pennsylvania, where chronic wasting disease is spreading among wild, free-ranging deer.

"Containing the spread of chronic wasting disease is going to be difficult,” said Diefenbach. “Although not as many females disperse — 8 to 24 percent of females versus 50 to 75 percent of males — there ends up being more [does] because they live longer and disperse an average of 11 miles compared to 5 miles for males.”

Advertise with us

Reducing deer density in disease management areas, he said, would reduce female dispersal rates and likely slow the spread of the disease.

“There are different ways to reduce deer density,” said Diefenbach. “The most efficient is recreational hunting.”

The new understanding of doe relocation could be important to wildlife managers searching for deer control options in urban areas.

“For any population-control method to be effective, it must consider the effect of immigration from dispersing females on the target population,” said Rosenberry, in a statement.

Managers of controlled hunts and sharpshooting programs that target does might revisit their plans to compensate for doe dispersal in the target area. Non-lethal deer removal strategies including trap-and-transfer, use of contraceptives and surgical sterilization don’t apply to the study, said Diefenbach, because “that doesn’t reduce deer density to begin with.”