Read closely -- it's complicated.

By county law, it is illegal to hunt with a centerfire rifle in Allegheny County, but legal to use a shotgun with rifled slugs. Rifle hunting is legal in parts of Wildlife Management Unit 2B that are not in Allegheny County. During the late-season Special Regulations Area hunt in Allegheny County (Dec. 26-Jan. 24), it is legal for a hunter with a 2B doe tag to use a shotgun with rifled slugs for antlerless deer. For the second year, during the 2B flintlock muzzleloader season (Dec. 26-Jan. 24), it is illegal to hunt deer with a rifle or shotgun in parts of 2B outside of Allegheny County, including parts of Beaver, Washington, Westmoreland and Butler counties. Parts of Allegheny County that are within WMU 2A are open for hunting with shotguns and rifled slugs, but Allegheny County centerfire restrictions apply.

Did you get all that? It's all there in the Pennsylvania Hunting and Trapping Digest, but it's easiest to understand if you flip from pages 42 to 53 and back while a patient expert on Pennsylvania hunting regulations explains it to you.

"Yeah, there's a lot there," said Game Commission spokesman Travis Lau.

Advertise with us

In 2013 the Game Commission board returned to county-based wildlife management of the highly populated counties of Allegheny, Bucks, Chester, Delaware, Montgomery and Philadelphia only during the four weeks of the special late deer seasons. WMU management applies during all other seasons applicable to 2B. The explanation was that landowners in 2B but outside of Allegheny County didn't want rifle hunting on their properties in January and couldn't rely on posting, and that hunters were disproportionately using 2B antlerless tags allocated for Allegheny County in parts of the WMU outside of the county.

Last year and at a May 2014 working group meeting, members of the Game Commission's wildlife management division testified that there was no evidence of disproportionate doe tag use within parts of 2B or the Philadelphia WMUs. Property posting is no more or less effective in January than it is throughout the year, and the biologists continued to question the efficacy of returning to county-based wildlife management in select areas for a single month.

"Our job as biologists is to provide the board with the best available data and our experience in the field," said Chris Rosenberry, supervisor of the deer and elk division. "We have the data and the commission is aware of it. I can't explain why [county-based management] is being done. ... The [board of commissioners] members are in the best position to explain."

Last year, the 2B-Allegheny County rule was well received by farmers in the impacted area and resulted in few hunting violations.

"Some of the farmers outside of Allegheny County were very pleased," said board president Robert Schlemmer of Export. "They don't mind muzzleloading season after Christmas, and I got phone calls thanking us for making the change."

Advertise with us

Lau said there were no difficulties in enforcing the rule.

"I remember talking to [wildlife conservation officers] in Washington and Westmoreland counties and asking them specifically if they had problems with this," he said. "There were very few enforcement problems."

Schlemmer said he'll bring up the 2B-Allegheny County regulation at a Game Commission working group meeting Monday.

Other late-season deer hunts in 2B are easier to understand. Flintlock muzzleloaders, but not in-line muzzlerloaders, are legal during the Dec. 26-Jan. 24 flintlock muzzleloader season throughout WMU 2B. And hunters with a muzzleloader permit can tag a buck or a doe with a buck tag.

Following the statewide antlered and antlerless archery hunt Dec. 26-Jan. 10, a special 2B antlered and antlerless archery season runs Jan. 12-24.