ERIE, Pa. — The creek was extremely low and clear when James Swearingen of McKees Rocks cast a single egg into the current. The bait disappeared in the glare.
“I was watching the egg drift until I lost it in the sun, and then I saw white,” he said. “It was the inside of a fish’s mouth. I saw it open.”
His 9-foot noodle rod bowed as the big fish ran, peeling off 4-pound Fluorocarbon line from the reel. During the fight, Swearingen recognized the distinctive robust coloring of a fat, 28-inch brown trout, one of four he had caught in two days on creeks near North East.
In the past couple of years, a brown trout stocking program that was launched in 2008 has come to fruition on Erie County streams. This year, browns are showing up from Twentymile to Crooked Creek. Some veteran steelhead anglers are referring to 2014 as the “year of the brown.”
“This is by far the best year for the return of brown trout,” said Swearingen, who publishes the Steel City Anglers blog on Facebook. So far this year, he has landed 202 steelhead and 10 browns on Erie County waters. Most of the chromers and all of the browns were released.
The state Fish and Boat Commission started planting browns to create a new near-shore fishery and compensate for the 2003 closing of the coho stocking program. Some 100,000 disease-free brown trout eggs were donated by a New York hatchery, and in 2009 the first 7-inch browns, fin clipped for identification, were planted in Presque Isle Bay, Crooked Creek and the protected nursery waters of Godfrey Run and Orchard Beach Creek.
Since then, 50,000-100,000 brown trout — 5-10 percent of the number of steelhead stocked — have been planted in spring and fall near the mouths of select tributaries.
“Their return has been increasing for the last few years,” said Mark Haffley, a Fish and Boat fisheries technician. “Last year was a banner year.”
Both browns and rainbows are cold-water species, but the browns behave quite differently from their anadromous cousins.
Rainbows stocked as smolts leave their home waters and travel in hungry schools throughout the lake. In three years, as sexually mature steelhead, they return to the creeks from about October through March and run upstream in an attempt to spawn in the spring. Most are not successful.
Brown trout stocked as young adults do not remain in the creeks year-round. They congregate near shore in 60-70 feet, mostly on The Mountain, a submerged hump off North East. Browns can outgrow the chromers. They are fall spawners, often entering the creeks with steelhead from late September through early December. Brown trout activity is expected to dwindle this month.
Unlike steelhead, few browns travel far upstream. Most are caught on the lower beats, often near the creek mouths.
“It’s not a fishery that would support itself — more of a big novelty fish suitable for mounting on the wall,” Haffley said. “Like the steelhead, there’s probably some natural reproduction in some of the streams. But the streams get too warm too quickly, and there’s not a lot of gravel, which they need to build redds.”
Haffley said few browns make it past the waterfalls on Walnut or the first impediments on other creeks.
“They’re just not as acrobatic,” he said. “If they can’t swim past the first obstacle, they’ll just stay there.”
Knowledge of that and other spawning behaviors give anglers a tactical advantage.
“Brown trout tend to be more aggressive, more territorial,” Swearingen said. “If they’re not facing upstream, they’re chasing the steelhead, nipping at their tails.”
Capitalizing on the browns’ proprietary interest in submerged real estate, Swearingen taunts them to strike.
“When I locate aggressive browns, I like to show them bigger profile baits,” he said. “Egg sacks, a bigger minnow, a large streamer. We use a No. 16 hook and dead-drift for them.”
Fish and Boat charts the brown trout population through summer assessments on The Mountain and during fall collections in the protected nursery waters of Trout Run.
Browns have increased in number in recent years — Haffley said angler reports from Walnut, Elk, Sixteenmile and Twentymile have been “incredible.” But Fish and Boat is having some trouble quantifying this year’s brown trout return.
Submerged remnants of a former marina immediately to the west of Trout Run, sometimes called The Pig Pen, were altered this year by the private landowner.
As a result, sand has gathered causing the creek to grow deeper, flow slower and turn to the east at the mouth.
“We know the browns are coming in because anglers are catching them more than ever, but this year with the changes they’re not coming in [to Trout Run],” Haffley said. “The steelhead are coming in, and the guys are catching lots of browns off the mouth [of Trout Run], but they’re not coming in for our collections.”
While silver bullets are famous for their tail-walking gymnastic fights, brown trout on the hook are more likely to dig deep. Swearingen said he hopes anglers will recognize the opportunities — and responsibilities — presented by the emergence of a burgeoning new Lake Erie fishery.
“If we ever want to have trophy brown trout water, we have to release them,” he said. “It’s important.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.