Raising white-tailed deer is big business in Pennsylvania. Its regulation was transferred to the state Department of Agriculture in 2006. This transfer of authority, which has occurred in other states, makes wildlife biologists cringe because deer are wildlife, not livestock.

The reasons for deer farming are primarily financial. Farmers sell everything from antlers, velvet, urine and venison to controlled hunts and breeding stock. Bucks with trophy antlers can fetch prices in six figures.

Wildlife biologists worry that captive herds could spread diseases such as chronic wasting disease to wild populations and jeopardize the health of an entire state's deer population. Farmers counter that captive herds are healthier than wild herds.

There is no test for CWD on live animals, and it's always fatal to deer. CWD has been found in wild and captive deer in Pennsylvania, as well as in wild deer in Maryland and West Virginia.

Advertise with us

This year, state and federal officials killed 356 deer at one Iowa farm suspected of harboring an outbreak of chronic wasting disease. Of those, 284 -- or 79.8 percent -- tested positive for CWD. This is a deer biologist's worst nightmare.

Furthermore, a recent Indianapolis Star investigation revealed that the U.S. Department of Agriculture paid the farmer more than $900,000 for the lost deer. That's taxpayer money, not wildlife agency funds.

Agriculture departments see deer as an economic commodity, and in a recent op-ed Charly Seale, president of the North American Elk Breeders Association, wrote that deer farms, "open new paths to economic growth."

But domesticating deer is a bad idea.

Wildlife agencies such as the state Game Commission treat wild deer as renewable resources to be responsibly and sustainably managed. I think wildlife agencies have the better approach.

Scott Shalaway: www.drshalaway.com, sshalaway@aol.com.