Across Southwest Pennsylvania, where municipalities struggle to contain growing deer populations, the deer are winning.
Many communities provide no stewardship in second-growth woodlands with no large predators, lush residential yards and gardens -- perfect man-made habitat for white-tail deer -- as if "nature" will somehow take care of itself. In those unnatural environments, it can't. Where human populations are high, most hunting is impractical.
The white-tail deer is a unique keystone species. A 150-pound deer eats 10 to 12 pounds of vegetation every day, or more than 1 ton of flora per year, out-competing other animals for food and destroying their habitat. Each doe reaches sexual maturity within one year and almost all breed, often bearing twins and sometimes triplets. Unchecked, deer density doubles every two years and deer-related problems are inevitable.
When swelling suburban deer populations threaten public safety, paid consultants and Game Commission advisors caution civic leaders that the only practical way to return deer to sustainable levels is through professional culls followed by additional lethal population maintenance.
That scenario unfolded again Monday in upscale Mt. Lebanon. At a packed council meeting, residents argued for and against a deer management plan to replace one that was terminated in 2008. Then, new council members cancelled an unfinished program in which sharpshooters from the U.S. Department of Agriculture culled deer in problem areas, reducing deer-vehicle collisions in Mt. Lebanon. When the program ended, the deer rebounded, and during subsequent years of public indecision the population skyrocketed. By 2013, combined road kills and deer-vehicle collisions had more than doubled.
A no-deer-feeding ordinance is on the books, but it hasn't been legally enforced. Two consultants have advised Mt. Lebanon council that a cull is necessary to get deer to manageable levels, followed by routine population maintenance.
Monday, council introduced an ordinance that would amend the 2014 budget, adding items including $68,000 for deer management. They'll vote Nov. 11. If approved, a contentious community debate is likely to erupt over how to achieve council's goal of reducing deer-vehicle collisions by half in five years.
"The culling -- sharpshooters using high-powered guns in our backyards -- is more of a public safety hazard than the deer," said resident Stacey Chick, who helped mobilize citizens opposed to funding lethal deer management. She prefers non-lethal means including surgical sterilization, in which volunteer veterinarians would perform hysterectomies on does.
Marilyn J. Narey, one of the organizers of Lebo Deer, said the group wants to do whatever it takes to control deer.
"For the health and safety of people, deer and the entire ecosystem, the deer population must be reduced to a manageable size, and then maintained annually," she said. "Our group does not recommend any particular method, but we strongly believe that the commissioners must listen to their own experts that they have hired to assess the problem and develop proposals."
Erie violations
The state Fish and Boat Commission reports that daily "saturation patrols" involving uniformed and plain-clothed officers have resulted in "many prosecutions" among steelhead anglers. The most common offenses are snagging or foul hooking fish, littering and over-limit violations.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.