Over the next eight weeks, Neotropical migratory birds will return to Western Pennsylvania. Some will move on; others will stay and nest locally. On a good morning, birders can count 15 species of warblers. Add a handful of vireos, flycatchers, orioles and thrushes, and a morning can be spectacular.

But seeing large numbers of species together, often in feeding flocks in the same trees, raises an interesting ecological question. How can they all occupy the same place at the same time? That violates a basic ecological principle: Two or more species cannot occupy the same niche at the same time, that is, they cannot do the same thing at the same time. The result is competition, and only one species can prevail.

This is where careful observations can resolve ecological puzzles. A classic example of multiple species occupying the same space comes from the boreal forests of the northeastern United States. Five species of small, insectivorous warblers live and nest among these conifers. Visiting birders would find all five species living in the same trees, even seeming to eat the same foods.

Careful observations, however, reveal that though these species do inhabit the same trees, they use them in different ways. In the 1950s, ecologist Robert MacArthur recorded the amount of time each species spent in different parts of the trees. Though they used the same trees, they divvied up the trees into sections.

Advertise with us

Cape May warblers, for example, spent most of their time foraging in highest, outermost branches. Yellow-rumped warblers spent most of their time in the lower branches close to the ground. Black-throated green warblers used the outer branches of the trees' midsection. Blackburnian warblers concentrated on the outer branches from the middle to the top of the tree. Bay-breasted warblers spent most of their time on the interior branches in the middle of the trees.

Though all five species spent most of their time in the same trees, they minimized competition by using different parts of the trees to find food. And some foraged at different times of day. Birding is more than learning names. It's also about studying behavior to better understand each species' natural history.