Movies can offer stunning views of wilderness vistas. But when it comes to documenting outdoor activities, the film industry rarely gets it right.
Demeaning depictions of hunters as beer-drinking, Southern-drawling, gun-blasting lowlifes; wild animals cast as cuddly Bambi pets or vengeful demon spawn; adrenalin-pumping scenes of reckless outdoors behavior -- you'd think no one in Hollywood has ever been outside.
Filmmakers, of course, are under no obligation to create positive role models or provide anything close to situational accuracy. But film-goers would be wise to know the difference between celluloid fantasy and reality, or at least take the right lesson from what the movies characters did wrong.
A case in point: Before you explore the best of nature, prepare for the worst emergencies. Oscar-winning director Danny Boyle had a life lesson in mind for "127 Hours," which is in theaters now. It's based on the book "Between a Rock and a Hard Place" (Atria), a true story by Aron Ralston, a 1997 Carnegie Mellon University graduate in mechanical engineering, who became trapped for five days in an isolated Utah canyon.
In the film, James Franco plays Ralston as a carefree young adventurer who challenges himself with extreme wilderness experiences. Recklessly, he slips alone into a narrow crevasse where a boulder pins his arm to a cave wall, forcing him into a grueling and life-threatening survival experience.
"He's not the greatest guy in the world at the beginning," Boyle told the Post-Gazette in a phone interview this year. "He's a perfect physical specimen, but he's got a lot to learn. ... He's quite almost arrogant or certainly very self-sufficient and independent, or imagines he is, so he's got a journey to go on."
The lesson Boyle hopes audiences will take from the theater is that outdoors adventurers should tell someone where they're going and when they're expected back. Trapped and facing a serious risk of death, Ralston delivers another message for posterity into his camcorder: "Lesson," he says, holding up a worn blade that was not enough to save him. "Don't buy the cheap, made-in-China multi-tool."
But even the American Hiking Society was concerned that "127 Hours" may turn Ralston into an adventure hero.
"Though a hero for his bravery, Ralston is a lesson of what not to do on a hike," they wrote in a recent press release. "He came to realize too late that his unpreparedness and above all, not telling anyone of his whereabouts, were grave errors that almost cost him his life. While Aron's story is one of extraordinary circumstances, it's always best to play it safe, even on short hikes near home. The most dangerous part of your hike is the car trip to the trailhead."
Toni Price of Exkursion Outfitters in Monroeville says she's fond of a little phrase: "They're called accidents because you don't mean for them to happen. But you have to be prepared for anything."
Price, a veteran outdoors adventurer who read Ralston's book, said the CMU grad made a series of mistakes that caused his life-or-death ordeal.
"First, he didn't tell anybody where he was going," she said. "He was in good shape for outdoor activity and didn't think anything [bad] was going to happen, giving him a false sense of security. I firmly believe he made another serious error in judgment when he went down into that crevasse. Was he reckless? I think so."
Price said Ralston would have been in a more survivable position had he packed the Ten Essentials: first-aid kit, food and water for a couple of days, extra clothing, compass, map, knife, fire tools, signaling device, sun protection and light.
Glamorizing recklessness and misunderstanding animal habits are common themes in wilderness adventure films. Director Sean Penn's 2007 "Into the Wild" told the true story of Christopher McCandless, who with no training and few supplies abandoned civilization to live -- and ultimately die -- alone in the Alaska wilds. Penn's film and its inspiration, the 2003 Jon Krakauer book of the same title, made McCandless a folk hero in the eyes of many adventurers. But some Alaskans who knew McCandless thought he was naive, arrogant and unprepared for the harshness of mountain living.
"Grizzly Man," a 2005 film by Werner Herzog recounts the tragic story of Timothy Treadwell, a self-proclaimed naturalist who lived with and filmed Alaska grizzly bears until he and his companion were eaten alive. Herzog's film used Treadwell's actual footage to show him to be recklessly unfamiliar with animal behaviors.
"It's hard for me to watch films like '127 Hours,' 'Into the Wild' and others," said Venture Outdoors program manager Rob Walters. "All of these things could have, and should have, been avoided with planning and preparedness."
Trained in survival skills and with a degree in wildlife biology, Walters said the most valuable outdoors skill is avoiding situations where your survival could be put at risk.
Venture Outdoors organizes some 500 recreational programs a year. Walters said it's constant planning and communicating with participants, trip leaders and the insurance company to make sure things go smoothly.
"Have a plan, that's what we stress," he said. "Unfortunately for a lot of people, all they know about the outdoors is what they see on TV and in the movies. It's Hollywood -- they're going to make it the most exciting story in the world. But you shouldn't base your trip on that."
Post-Gazette movie editor Barbara Vancheri contributed to this story.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.