Grouse hunters are optimists by nature. They'll need that trait this fall because population predictions for their favorite bird are again not exactly exciting.
Last season, grouse hunters who participate in the Game Commission's flushing rate study recorded the lowest flushing rate per hour hunted since the study began four decades ago. Bill Palmer, the Game Commission's grouse biologist who has been studying the birds and their population swings for over 20 years says hunters generally can expect more of the same this season. But Palmer counters his cautions with the caveat that there is still some good grouse hunting out there for those who know where to look.
"It's still just to early to tell what kind of populations we'll have out there this fall," Palmer said. "There was a lot of concern last year and that will continue. We don't have the habitat we formerly did in Pennsylvania but the hunting pressure has declined simultaneously, so we still have some decent grouse hunting in this state."
Grouse populations are known to fluctuate widely on cycles of roughly 10 to 11 years. Pennsylvania's grouse as well as those in other Appalachian grouse states such as West Virginia and Ohio seem to have been at the low ebb for the last couple of seasons and hunters and biologists are eager to see the birds rebound.
There is no evidence that hunting causes grouse populations to cycle. Palmer studies grouse on a tract of Centre County state game lands designated for grouse research. Grouse hunting is prohibited on the study grounds but Palmer has documented the same population swings as on hunted lands. He is considering a new theory formulated by researchers in Great Britian, who studied red grouse subject to similar population cycles. There, biologists concluded that cyclical weather patterns affected the number and virulence of internal parasites, which in turn influenced grouse numbers. Weather patterns that favored the grouse parasites indirectly suppressed the grouse. As grouse numbers tumbled, so did the parasites that depend on them, giving the birds a chance to rebuild and start the cycle anew. So goes the theory, anyway.
Palmer has decades of data that show grouse in Pennsylvania woodlands do bounce back. Flushing rates reported by hunters were nearly identical (1.4 birds flushed per hour hunted) in 1979, 1989 and 1999, interspersed with cycles of higher and lower flushing rates.
What worries Palmer is the slow but steady drop in ideal grouse habitat. Ruffed grouse are what biologists call an "early successional species." They thrive best in young brushy forests, optimally about 7 to 10 years following timber harvest.
Despite the seemingly constant flow of loaded log trucks on the highways, U. S. Forest Service data indicates that young brushy forests have declined in Pennsylvania as forests matured, from 3.3 million acres (21 percent of total forest acreage) in 1979 to just over 2 million acres today (11 percent of total forest acreage).
"There is less of that good habitat all the time, and it's being fragmented into smaller pieces, scattered farther apart," Palmer said. "This trend represents a huge drop in early successional habitat. We're talking almost 2 million acres of woods."
Palmer said he is concerned that the trend could possibly result in long-term damage to local grouse populations.
"When we had more good habitat, grouse could fill in and re-populate places that had been hunted hard," he explained. "But it's possible to overshoot small fragments of habitat with no opportunity for new birds to disperse into the area."
The only thing offsetting the trend toward less grouse habitat, Palmer said, is the population trend of grouse hunters themselves.
Despite that eternal optimism cited above, the number of grouse hunters has plummeted faster than the birds or their brushy haunts.
In 1979, there were just over a half-million grouse hunters stomping the coverts across the commonwealth. Today, Palmer's surveys suggest there are barely more than 100,000.
So, even though the grouse cycle is in the dumps, and good habitat is waning, there is less competition for a piece of the grouse-hunting pie. "It is good news that, even with less habitat and fewer birds statewide, hunters can still experience excellent grouse hunting," Palmer said.
Still, he could not suppress that grouse hunter's optimism. "We were seeing more birds all through June," he said. "There's no doubt that what we're seeing is up a bit. I would think that if brood survival continues as it has thus far this summer we might have a few more birds this fall."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.