On a stretch of the Gauley River in West Virginia that is one of the country's premier white-water runs, a landowner's decision to stop letting boaters go in and out is threatening the river's fall season.

West Virginia Division of Tourism photo

Rafting enthusiasts head out for fall adventure on the Gauley River. The Gauley River National Recreation Area was created 21 years ago.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

In this three-cornered dispute, every party wants to find a solution to keep the 25 miles of spectacularly difficult white water which plunges down the Gauley River gorge accessible to the boaters who love it.

But the National Park Service, the landowner involved and a group representing private boaters who run the river haven't found a way to solve a half-million-dollar-plus difference of opinion.

At issue is access to an area midway down the Gauley run, which each year attracts thousands of rafters, kayakers and canoeists during the September-October season of controlled dam releases, which occur four days a week over six weeks. Because 25 miles is more than many people want to do in a day, the river is usually divided into two sections, the upper and the lower. Boaters take out in that midpoint area, or put in there for the lower run.

The one used by most private boaters, those who go on their own, whether in rafts, kayaks or canoes, rather than on a guided trip with a commercial outfitter, is at Woods Ferry. The land belongs to Lost Paddle Inc., run by the owners of Class VI outfitter in partnership with Imre and Janet Szilagyi, who own commercial rafting operations. They have allowed private boaters the use of the land, said Class VI co-owner Dave Arnold, and the money from a $5 charge for shuttle service, a bus or truck that hauls boaters and their boats up and down the road to the river, is donated to West Virginia Rivers Coalition, a conservation group.

This year, they have closed it and their other access points to private boaters. They own almost all of the land around the midpoint section of the river, thus, they are choking off nearly all access for boaters who want to get off or on the river in that area.

Advertise with us

Cal Hite, superintendent of the National Recreation Area, said that, in recent years, 10,000 to 15,000 private boaters ran the river annually.

When the Gauley River National Recreation Area was created 21 years ago, the plan was for the National Park Service to acquire land along the river, including access for boaters.

The Park Service buys only from willing sellers, Hite said, and, therefore, the acquisition has been slow.

"The National Recreation Area is 11,500 acres. Right now, the public domain consists of 4,100 of that 11,500," he said.

The Park Service has made an offer to Lost Paddle based on its appraisals of the Woods Ferry area parcel. The owners have their own appraisal, and say the Park Service offer wouldn't cover the money they have put into the land over the years.

Advertise with us

The Park Service would pay about $400,00 for the parcel, or $275,000 if the owners retained the right to use the river access for 20 years. Lost Paddle has never named a price, Arnold said, but its appraisal is at "substantially more than $1 million," he said. The sides have remained far apart in the eight years in which they have been trying to reach some agreement.

Arnold said those expecting Lost Paddle to sell the land for a lower price fail to realize how much it's worth; how much he and his partners have put into it, including $200,000 to create a better road in 2000; and the realities of running a business.

Lost Paddle permitted access from the beginning with the understanding that it was a temporary situation, he said. He and his partners allowed private boaters to use their land and didn't attempt to make money from them. But they always expected the Park Service to buy the land and make it a public access area.

"We have this great relationship with the Rivers Coalition, but it was fragile. It was never meant to be a long-term answer," Arnold said.

"If 10,000 people were walking through the Post-Gazette to get to a park, wouldn't someone say, 'Hey, what's going on?' It's private land. We just don't want to be in the business of managing private boaters."

Advertise with us

He said his attorneys had told him he ran the risk of litigation, because those who use the land don't sign liability release forms.

The closing this year of the Woods Ferry and other access points Lost Paddle owns was the only way to get people to take the issue seriously.

"We did it for years as a Band-Aid. In 1988, when we first did this, if you'd said, 'Dave, do you think you'll still be doing this in 2005?' I would have laughed."

But, he said: "You can't give land away for less than you have in it. What we're trying to do is focus attention on the issue to be addressed: There needs to be [public] midpoint access."

Hite agrees, but says the Park Service can offer only the appraised amount. He is hoping some agreement can be worked out, and said the Park Service was open to any options, including having a third party help out.

Advertise with us

Bill Tanger, of Roanoke, Va., heads Friends of the Rivers of Virginia and is helping to create an organization of boaters from a number of organizations called Friends of the Gauley. He said there was precedent for third parties to buy land from private owners and to give or resell it to the Park Service.

He initially sought to explore that possibility, but found the dollar amounts were too far apart. "Closing that differential -- a half million -- is just pointless. It's got to be something within the realm of reality."

Tanger and other volunteers have spent the past few months pulling out stumps, hacking down rhododendron and putting in cobbles on an old public road in order to create an alternative for private boaters.

"It's an old road, 100 years old, that goes to what used to be the ferry," Tanger said. The West Virginia Department of Transportation gave his group permission to work on improving it.

"We have about 1,200 feet of road to reopen. We're about third of way through." He estimates it will cost about $15,000, $4,000 of which has been raised.

Advertise with us

"That way we, hopefully, can manage the Gauley season this year, so it's not a major economic loss to the area this year, not to mention a loss to boaters."

But parking at the site is limited, the road is very steep, and shuttle vehicles will have to be four-wheel-drive equipped with two-way radios to avoid hood-to-hood meetings on the narrow access route. Tanger said he thought he could accommodate the numbers of private boaters there, but most paddlers think it will be a tight fit, at best.

"I can't see how they're going to run a truck up and down with people wandering around," said Charlie Walbridge, of American Whitewater, a longtime paddler who was among the first to call paddlers' attention to the problem.

Nobody knows exactly what will happen Sept. 9, the first day of Gauley season, Arnold said. "Any resolution is open for consideration that leads to a permanent fix."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.