Amy Sancetta, Associated Press

A young whitetail deer takes a break under a tree.

Click photo for larger image.

Pennsylvania's deer management woes now echo beyond local outdoor pages and sportsman's club meetings. The current issues of two respected national magazines, Audubon and Field & Stream, feature articles on Pennsylvania's deer debate.

Advertise with us

Both join the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal on the list of national publications reporting recently that overabundant deer are ruining Pennsylvania's forests and farms, that a vocal segment of deer hunters demand more deer anyway and that the institutional ability of the Pennsylvania Game Commission's to resolve the problem is suspect.

Noting the resignation of Game Commission deer biologist Dr. Gary Alt, Audubon editor-at-large Ted Williams writes in the July-August issue: "In the more than three years since I covered the national deer crisis in the March 2002 Audubon ("Wanted: More Deer Hunters"), the situation in Pennsylvania has gone from hopeful to hideous. Apparently the state will remain the continent's most graphic example of ecological blight wrought by backward, politically inspired management. ... No state is worse than Pennsylvania, but vast tracts in Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, Maryland, and Virginia have been stripped of low vegetation."

Williams confirms the vital role of hunters in wildlife management and conservation but asserts that Pennsylvania hunters on the "more deer" side of the argument are tainting hunting's public image, and that of their state, nationwide. He compares disgruntled hunters' affect on public opinion with that of the "anti-hunters" they fear and despise.

"The deer advocates who create the worst trouble for wildlife managers and present the only real threat to biodiversity and the future of hunting are the hunters themselves," he writes. Later, with the skill of a journalist who blends truth and imagery, Williams continues: "If they [dissatisfied deer hunters] imagined or perceived the slightest diminution in deer numbers, they shrieked like crated shoats."

In his latest piece Williams informs the nation that Pennsylvania has had ample time to deal with overabundant deer. He cites a quote from then, and subsequently dismissed, commission deer biologist Roger Latham who wondered in 1950 if Pennsylvania's deer would be managed by "well-trained wildlife men or ... the whims, fancies, and selfish desires of the deer hunters themselves."

Advertise with us

Despite his view from outside the state, or perhaps because of it, Williams pins Pennsylvania's impotence in dealing with deer and deer hunters on the way we fund wildlife management. "In Pennsylvania, 71 percent of the public wants deer brought into balance with the land, but this cannot happen when the hunters provide virtually 100 percent of the Game Commission's money. The hunters and the commission reject all outside funding proposals because they want to keep the power where it is."

The Wall Street Journal sensed the same funding flaw. In December 2004, the Journal cited this quote: "Not only is the deer population out of control, the managerial model of deer control is broken. Deer density is increasing, hunter density is decreasing. Hunters [who buy licenses and fund the Commission] are aging, mentors are going. We're pretty much headed for a train wreck."

Williams describes alternative funding models used in places most Pennsylvanians would not consider especially progressive -- Arkansas and Missouri. In 1976, Missouri set up a one-tenth-of-a-cent sales tax to fund its conservation department, which "has elevated Missouri's conservation program to No. 1 nationally, both in funding and in scope."

Many of the same hunters who demand more deer will dismiss the warnings of "environmental" magazines such as Audubon and urban papers such as the New York Times, but Pennsylvania's deer controversy is also making news in the national outdoor press.

Field & Stream this month calls the rift a "civil war" in a state "where deer hunting ranks with God and family, and the battle has spilled over into the mainstream media, politics and courtrooms."

Advertise with us

In the same Field & Stream feature, Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania president Ralph Saggiomo unwittingly confirms Williams' Audubon assertion -- that deer hunters want their way, no matter the cost to the public and Pennsylvania's other natural resources. "We want them [the Game Commission] to be independent and free from outside influences," Saggiomo told Field & Stream. "But they should be concerned about hunters first. That's their job."

Don't look for the national spotlight on Pennsylvania's deer to dim. Field & Stream's article closes with this quote from Alt: "This no longer is just about hunting -- it's a social and environmental issue that is 100 times larger than our sport. If we can't act responsibly, we'll be out on our ear."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.