Matt Weber of Ellwood City who is holding a 501/2-inch, 30-pound muskie he caught May 28.
Click photo for larger image.
Fishing Notebook:
When the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission's top biologist, Rick Hoopes, was in Pittsburgh this spring for the Three Rivers Muskies Inc. annual banquet, his talk about the agency's muskellunge management program opened a can of worms.
"We expect people to be passionate about their fishing," said Hoopes, following a barrage of criticism about the Fish Commission's current practices and complaints that anglers have to go to Canada, New York or Wisconsin for a shot at a 50- to 60-pound trophy muskie, and fast action on smaller muskie.
Tomorrow night, in a meeting open to the public, the Fish Commission's top warm-water biologist, Bob Lorantas, will speak to the group about possible changes to muskie management as a result, at least in part, of feedback generated by a survey in which anglers were asked to rank muskie waters on their performance and potential.
"We're not sure we can match the Midwestern states or Ontario because we don't have the same number of lakes and flowages," said Lorantas, who lives in Bellefonte but grew up near Pittsburgh. "But we have some very good habitats that we can enhance and improve.
"Could we increase muskie density by limiting harvest and increasing stockings? That's one issue we're looking at. Size is another."
Muskie madness
Here are the top muskie waters as ranked by 68 anglers who participated in the commission's recent survey:
1. Lake Arthur
2. Pymatuning Reservoir
3. Tamarack Lake
4. Conneaut Lake
5. Woodcock Creek Lake
6. Lake Wilhelm
7. Tionesta Lake
8. Glendale Lake
9. Keystone Lake (Armstrong County)
10. Edinboro Lake
11. Allegheny River (Kinzua Dam to Conewango Creek)
12. Allegheny River (Tionesta Creek to Oil Creek)
13. Sugar Lake
14. Canadohta Lake
15. Shenango Reservoir
Muskie guide Howard Wagner of Fombell, whose best catch so far is a rare 54-inch, 52-pound muskie landed on a winter day on an Allegheny River tributary, believes Pennsylvania could rival the Midwest if the commission would tighten up size and creel limits, and apply special regulations to the best waters, which is what Wisconsin does.
"When I talk to other places, they think we're Neanderthals with two a day (limit) at 30 inches. In parts of New York, Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Canada, they put release limits of between 48 and 55 inches on fish. And they do it for economic reasons, because they know it brings in people who will spend money to fish."
Pennsylvania should increase its basic size minimum to 36 inches and cut the daily creel limit in half, to one a day, Wagner said. "From there, you could get into special regulations."
Currently, the only waters with exceptional size restrictions on muskie are Sugar Lake, a 90-acre natural lake and muskie nursery water in Crawford County where the minimum is 36 inches, and Presque Isle Bay in Erie, where a 40-inch minimum was established 10 years ago in an effort to foster natural reproduction.
Muskie rankings
Here are the fish commission's rankings of stocked muskie waters based on its "catch per hour" data, from highest to least high. (M) indicates muskie. (TM) indicates tiger muskie.
Tamarack Lake (M); Lake Arthur (M); Keystone Lake in Armstrong County (M/TM); Lake Wilhelm (M); Conneaut Lake (M); Pymatuning Lake (M); Marsh Creek Lake (TM); Raystown Lake and tailwater (M/TM); Cowanesque Reservoir (M/TM); Presque Isle Bay (M); Monongahela River from Elizabeth to Charleroi (M/TM); Susquehanna River, west branch, from Loyalsock Creek to the mouth (M); Monongahela River from Braddock to Point State Park, (M/TM); Monongahela River from Gray's Landing to Maxwell (M/TM); Allegheny River from Natrona Heights to Actemonia (M/TM); Allegheny River from Lock No. 7 to Clinton (M); Woodcock Creek Lake (M); Sugar Lake (M); Edinboro Lake (M); Canadohta Lake (M); Loyalhanna Lake (M/TM); Lake Somerset (M/TM); Frances Slocum Lake (M); Shawnee Lake (M); Hills Creek Lake (M) and Donegal Lake (M/TM).
Though Lorantas said deep seining techniques provide some evidence that it is working, Wagner said there are too many pike in the bay for a natural trophy muskie fishery to develop. The Fish Commission also uses muskie from inland waters to stock Lake Erie, although Great Lakes spotted muskie are indigenous to the lake. Wagner believes native numbers are small but slowly increasing, given how much cleaner water has become.
Pennsylvania stocks more muskie than Midwestern states because natural reproduction here is more limited, although Wagner thinks it is greater than the Fish Commission knows. Clean spawning habitat is the key to wild muskie reproduction and so, too, is an abundance of food fish. Wagner said newly hatched muskie prefer carp fry and other tiny fish over plankton in the wild, and Lorantas said studies indicate that feeding hatchery muskie minnow diets appears to give them a survival advantage after release.
The Fish Commission also stocks tiger muskie -- a faster growing pike-muskie hybrid -- that Wagner would like to see reduced to impoundments such as North Park, Deer Lakes and Hereford Manor, so it can focus its resources on true muskie.
"Tiger muskie are so aggressive, they never reach trophy size. They're a waste of money," he said.
Lorantas said the Fish Commission relies on anglers for information about good muskie fisheries since field surveys are limited. "The big ones tend to elude our trap nets, so we don't see many trophies," he said. "But anglers are out there catching them."
He and Wagner agree that the best muskie fisheries are in Western Pennsylvania, and especially Northwestern Pennsylvania where small natural lakes represent the muskie's native range. Conneaut Lake, a glacial lake near Meadville, produced the 54-pound, 3-ounce state record muskie that has remained unbeaten for 75 years. Conneaut also yielded a 56 incher to Al Munson of Meadville in 1970. There hasn't been one that size since, said Wagner, who blames fishing pressure plus an abundance of northern pike.
He said noise and emissions pollution from heavy boat traffic has impacted natural reproduction on Conneaut, and it would take extreme regulations to bring back the quality of muskie caught there 50 years ago.
Other natural muskie waters include LeBoeuf, Edinboro and Canadohta. As big reservoirs go, Wagner likes the Kinzua, Pymatuning and Raystown, but 45-plus pounders common 20 and 30 years ago have been depleted in those waters, he said, because too few restrictions were imposed. "They have the potential to come back with better management."
Loranatas' presentation begins at 7:30 p.m. tomorrow at the Northside Sportsmen's Club off Route 19 in Warrendale. It's open to the public. For more, visit threerivers.muskiesinc.org/
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.