Chronic Wasting Disease is known to be present in New York's wild deer herd less than 100 miles from the Pennsylvania border. Pennsylvania officials say our herd is vulnerable to CWD, in fact it may be here, but there are things the state can do to minimize its impact and spread.

A month after CWD was detected in captive deer herds in Oneida County, N.Y., in late March, an intensive monitoring effort found two CWD-infected wild deer nearby. There is no way to test living deer for the disease. Deer must be killed and the brain stem removed for testing. CWD is fatal. It is one of a class of diseases known as spongiform encephalopathies caused by abnormal proteins, called prions, in the brain and nervous system. CWD is related to but distinctly different from mad cow disease. Wildlife pathologists believe it is transmissible only among deer and elk. There is no evidence that humans can contract CWD by eating infected venison but a related malady of unknown origin, Creutzfeldt-Jakob Syndrome, has been found in humans.

According to veterinarians and wildlife officials in other states dealing with CWD, keeping deer densities low is one of the most important strategies in minimizing the spread of CWD among wild deer.

"If we manage our deer herd wisely -- keeping deer densities low and not allowing animals to be congregated -- CWD is much less likely to become a big problem in Pennsylvania," said David Wolfgang, an extension veterinarian in Penn State's College of Agricultural Sciences.

Advertise with us

Deer density is the big issue with CWD. The deer densities Pennsylvania experienced in recent decades before deer numbers were lowered might have been a problem. We know the best way to keep our deer herd healthy -- and the best way to prevent the spread of CWD and other diseases -- is to keep deer densities low and not allow animals to congregate."

Despite that caution and similar warnings from Wisconsin where CWD appeared in wild deer herds in 2002, Game Commissioners voted in April to reduce the 2005 allocation of antlerless deer licenses by 44 percent in parts of northern Pennsylvania near the New York border. The Game Commission had received many complaints from dissatisfied hunters after the 2004 deer seasons who said there were too few deer in northern forests.

Pennsylvania currently uses three different approaches to detect CWD. The Game Commission asks state residents to report sick deer to a local wildlife officer or Commission regional office. These deer, if found, are destroyed and tested for CWD. Game Commission biologists also take samples of brain tissue from deer at meat processing plants during the hunting season.

Biologists sent brain samples from 3,699 deer to labs for testing in 2004. All tested negative for CWD but Bob Boyd, assistant director of the Commission's Bureau of Wildlife Management and Pennsylvania's representative on the International Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies' Wildlife Disease Committee is not sleeping any better because of those tests.

"Even that ambitious effort is a small sample size from the total harvest of more than 400,000 deer," Boyd said.

Advertise with us

Statisticians agree that the random sampling is insufficient to assure 99 percent confidence that CWD is not lurking in Pennsylvania's deer herd.

The Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture also runs a voluntary monitoring program for captive deer herds, such as those at hunting reserves and "deer farms." But there are between 800 and 1,000 such facilities in the state and less than a third participate in the voluntary monitoring. Transport of captive deer among deer farms and other facilities is believed to be the way CWD has traveled from the West to Wisconsin and New York.

Regulation prohibits import of deer into Pennsylvania unless they come from a monitored herd free of CWD, but there is no mandatory monitoring program for captive deer herds within the state.

Boyd and the Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen's Clubs, which has asked the legislature to provide funding, would like to see a mandatory CWD monitoring program for captive herds. The Department of Agriculture estimates mandatory monitoring would cost $500,000 per year and says it doesn't have that amount available in its budget.

Wolfgang maintains CWD will be a lot more expensive than that if it shows up in Pennsylvania. Wisconsin spent about $14 million to combat CWD the first year, according to Wolfgang, and it has spent about $5.5 million every year since, with most that money coming from hunting license fees.