William Kimmel and David Argent, California University of Pennsylvania biologists working on the paddlefish restoration project, show off a paddlefish they netted in their survey work on the Ohio River in May.
Click photo for larger image.
Fishing Notebook:
State has vacancies for waterways officers
Douglas Laney of Turtle Creek had no idea what was on the end of his line when he scrambled around a fishing pier on the Allegheny River in Kittanning late last month to unhook a 44-inch fish with a foot-long beak.
"I've been fishing for 35 years and never saw anything like it," said Laney, who learned from Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologists that his heart-pounding catch was a paddlefish. The Fish and Boat Commission and biologists at two state universities are working to reintroduce the ancient species into the Western Pennsylvania rivers they were extirpated from more than a century ago as a consequence of pollution and over-harvesting.
Two of those biologists, David Argent and William Kimmel of California (Pa.) University, caught two paddlefish in trap-nets on the Allegheny and Ohio rivers earlier in May, near where thousands of tagged fish have been stocked annually for a decade. Argent's fish were 50 inches, including the 11-inch snouts (rostrums) that give the "Polyodon (many teeth) spathula (spatula)" its common name.
"We'd been hoping to see paddlefish for three years," said an elated Argent. "The literature suggests it takes 1,000 hours of net time to catch one paddlefish, and that's in areas of great density with commercial seasons. To turn up two fish in 2,000 hours of net time means we're pretty much on the money."
Argent's Allegheny River fish was a 20-pound male and the Ohio River fish a 32-pound female that had spawned. Both were about 8 years old and just approaching the age where they could reproduce, since it takes paddlefish a decade to become sexually mature. Those from the earliest years of the stocking program are just now entering the critical period where Argent can begin to determine whether they will reproduce in the wild. It is the bottom line to a federally funded Fish Commission managed effort to restore paddlefish to the area's vastly improved rivers.
Argent plans to return to the Allegheny and Ohio rivers next spring with very fine mesh nets to try to cull larvae -- which are thinner than the lead in a pencil -- from likely spawning habitat in a process called plankton towing.
The Fish Commission has stocked about 6,800 tagged paddlefish (1.6 per acre) a year using eggs from South Dakota, where there is a paddlefish sport-angling season, and from West Virginia, where paddlefish are planted below Morgantown in the Monongahela River.
A paddlefish captured by the Fish Commission at Gray's Landing on the Monongahela River during survey work on other species a couple of years ago probably migrated from West Virginia, Argent said, since they are a fish with a vast range.
"What we've learned from commercial anglers in Tennessee is that their peak periods are in late April and May. That's when they migrate to the dams to spawn," Argent said. Historically, Western Pennsylvania has represented the eastern most part of the paddlefish's native range in the Mississippi River watershed. That probably indicates that, although they were an integral part of the river system, they did not exist here in big numbers, Argent said. The last known catch of a wild paddlefish on local rivers was in 1919.
Though the installation of locks and dams is commonly believed to have added to the paddlefish's extirpation, Argent said it is less of a factor than pollution and over-harvesting.
"The dams here are open and shut doors, so they're not a complete barrier," he said. "In fact, the literature suggests that the tailrace of dams is where you'll find paddlefish, because it creates turbulent water for their food supply and habitat."
But finding them is difficult because they are an elusive species, he said. Underwater cameras don't provide reliable enough documentation because river water 10 to 15 feet down is usually too murky.
The paddlefish uses its rostrum to detect electrical pulses from plankton, Argent said, explaining that the sensory organ compensates for the poor vision of the paddlefish's penny-size eyes. Paddlefish eat only plankton, which cannot grow in polluted water. If plankton can't survive, paddlefish probably can't either.
"That we netted 8-year old fish that are existing entirely on zooplankton says something about the rivers' health," Argent said.
Penn State University also has been involved in the paddlefish study. Using transmitters to try to track paddlefish movements, its biologists found in the fall of 2002 and 2003 that 70 to 80 percent of paddlefish swam upriver toward the direction of the nearest dam and stayed there.
"Whether that was because of the dam impediment or it is their preferred habitat, we can't tell," Argent said. Efforts to track movements in the spring failed because of problems with the transmitters.
Paddlefish are still caught for sport in some Midwestern states. As a cousin of sturgeon, they are coveted for their caviar, or roe. But a paddlefish sport fishery isn't part of Argent's vision for Western Pennsylvania.
"They are part of the native fauna in the state and became extirpated at the hand of man, so it's our responsibility to restore the population," he said.
At this point, paddlefish remain an unclassified species though Argent would opt for designating them a "recovering" population. "We haven't captured young fish that have bred in the wild, or eggs, but we'll be entering a window where we could see some natural reproduction," he said. "We'll have to at some point, because the Fish Commission can't keep pumping money into the project. At some point, Mother Nature has to step in."
For more on Argent's work, visit www.Workforce.cup.edu/argent
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.