The standoff between landowners on blue-ribbon trout streams and advocates of public access is being played out over a vacancy on the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission board.

For two years, south central Pennsylvania has been without a representative to the board that sets fishing policies and regulations. The governor's office last year nominated Len Lichvar of Bolivar, an environmentalist active in Trout Unlimited and an advocate of public access -- which the Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen's Clubs says anglers are losing at an alarming rate -- but the nomination hasn't made it to the Senate floor.

Gov. Ed Rendell last week recalled the nomination, which buys him time to reintroduce Lichvar's name or nominate someone else. His spokesman, Kate Phillips, wouldn't say which option is likely, nor would she comment on any of the issues raised by Lichvar's supporters. They contend that the Senate's most powerful legislator, Sen. Robert Jubelirer, the Senate's president pro tem and a Blair County Republican, is stonewalling Lichvar because Lichvar has raised the hackles of landowners in Jubelirer's district.

"Landowners?" said Steve DeFrank, chief of staff to Sen. Rich Kasunic, a Fayette County Democrat, from Lichvar's district. "I know of only one: Donny Beaver."

Advertise with us

Beaver is a Huntington County entrepreneur being sued by the fish commission and two state agencies over his decades-long effort to keep anglers off the Little Juniata River. He runs an exclusive angling club, the Spring Ridge Club, that -- according to the club's promotional literature -- charges members at least $55,000 to fish on the "Little J" and other streams Beaver's club leases from landowners. Bob Ging, an environmental law attorney and Trout Unlimited activist who keeps a section of Laurel Hill Creek on his own property open to public fishing said Beaver began to oppose Lichvar after Lichvar and Trout Unlimited disseminated information about access on Yellow Creek, which Beaver was trying to lease for his club.

Beaver is on the board of the Pennsylvania Landowners Association, a group that opposes government regulation of private property and believes that anglers -- known in PLA jargon as "the free-lunch crowd" -- should pay to fish streams, after the European model of those who can afford it. Postings appear to be at an all-time high in Pennsylvania and nationwide, and the fish commission and sportsmen's groups are trying to stem the trend. In its lawsuit, the state and the commission assert that the Little Juniata, by virtue of Colonial-era law, is navigable, meaning it is big enough to be used for commerce and, as such, should be open to the public.

In response to the lawsuit, Beaver has said in the past that the property owner he leases from at Espy Farm owns the streambed along with the adjacent property. In the years leading up to the lawsuit, the conflict between Beaver and non-paying anglers who wade near his club's property has gotten ugly at times, according to both sides in what has become for many a symbol of one of fishing's most ominous issues.

"It's perfectly legitimate in Pennsylvania to post and charge people to fish," said Bob Bachman of Lancaster, who recommended Lichvar to the governor a year ago. Bachman serves on the Governor's Advisory Council on Hunting, Fishing and the Outdoors and chairs the subcommittee charged with finding a nominee. "People get aggressive on both sides when you have differences of opinion."

"But it isn't a reason to hold up a perfectly qualified nomination," said Bachman. "I think the question is, 'Hey, Sen. Jubelirer. You haven't even given Len a hearing, so what's the problem?' "

Advertise with us

Jubelirer's aide, John Giannelli, said landowners have written letters to the senator asking him to not move forward with the Lichvar nomination. "Let's leave it at this, we've heard a wide variety of opposition from Donny Beaver and others," Giannelli said. "It seems to be focused on private property rights and Lichvar's activities there. It seems to be centered on the controversy associated with property owners versus sportsmen. There are court cases going on, a lot is tied up in legal descriptions. The senator is concerned about a controversy coming up."

Giannelli said Jubelier also has received letters in support of Lichvar. The Governor's Sportsmen's Advisory Council has also received letters touting Lichvar's attributes as a well-informed conservationist. At 51, he would be one of the youngest members of the fish commission board, which includes representatives who have served for decades. "I'll be an out-of-the-box thinker," he had pledged last fall, before the Senate failed to vote.

One puzzling aspect of the Lichvar saga, said Bachman, is a meeting he arranged with Beaver and Lichvar last year. "The meeting seemed to go well," he said. "Beaver seemed to think Lichvar would be a good candidate for the board. And then, the next day, I got an e-mail from him saying he'd reconsidered."

As to why, said Bachman, "That's the mystery."

Beaver would not comment for this story, nor would Lichvar.

Advertise with us

DeFrank said he expects Lichvar's nomination to be reintroduced this week, but isn't hopeful it will pass. Whether support could be mustered despite Jubelirer's opposition is uncertain, DeFrank indicated.

"The governor has other fights. So do other senators," he said.

Ging believes the nomination could be moved forward if Beaver were to "publicly withdraw his opposition."

Lichvar is the only nomination to the fish commission being considered, although there is another vacancy on the board, one created by the death of commissioner Leon Reed in northeastern Pennsylvania earlier this year. That leaves eight commissioners to make decisions.

"Eight can change the balance of power," said fish and boat commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick. "It only takes four votes to kill something now, because a tie vote means a proposal fails."