Robert J. Pavuchak, Post-Gazette

The west end of Dutch Fork Lake had only a small amount of water in the center last October after Hurricane Ivan damaged the spillway and the lake had to be drained.

Click photo for larger image.

More Fishing News:

Advertise with us

What are PMF ratings?

Fishing Notebook: Sharpsburg hopes to add ramp

The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission is finally taking steps to stem the flow of sediment from the defunct Dutch Fork Lake into Dutch Fork Creek, a problem that forced cancellation of a recent trout stocking.

According to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, very fine silt -- 3 feet of it in spots -- has built up along 2 miles of the creek within the high quality Buffalo Creek watershed, impacting aquatic life. DEP's assessment came weeks after anglers first noticed the discharge and began pressuring state agencies to do something.

"If any private contractor did what the fish commission's doing, they'd be shut down," said retired fish commission waterways conservation officer Keith Small, when he visited Buffalo Creek just outside Claysville in Washington County on the eve of opening day. "It looked gray and slurryish, almost septic."

Advertise with us

"It's ugly," agreed Gary Stokum, executive director of the Washington County Conservation District, an environmental group funded by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture. "The fish commission should be caring for the environment and they're blatantly allowing the pollution to occur, which is a contradiction in their purpose. They could have minimized this and it wouldn't have been costly."

While making the dam functional again would cost $3 million -- money the fish commission says it doesn't have -- the commission recently announced that it will install 6 foot planks to slow the flow of sediment-charged water at least until warm weather spurs the growth of vegetation that will help stabilize the old lake bed.

As of Thursday, the work hadn't been done, said commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick, because the creek was running too fast. The commission closed Dutch Fork, a popular 91-acre impoundment, last fall after heavy rains threatened its structural integrity. The commission drew down the lake but heavy rains kept filling it.

In January, at DEP's direction, the commission breached the dam to hasten flow and removed an emergency spillway to facilitate drainage, Tredinnick said. "There's 40 years worth of sediment with no dam to hold it back now. The stream will rechannelize to its pre-dam condition. We just need to let nature take its course."

The folks living around Dutch Fork Lake weren't comfortable with that prospect. "The blue herons don't even use the creek much because they can't see anything to catch," said walleye pro Keith Eshbaugh, who owns a farm in nearby West Alexander, and joined with Small, his neighbor, in seeking action a month ago. "The lake is why we're here. I bought a canoe and two kayaks for the lake. It's the only public waterway on the I-70 corridor and we want it back."

Advertise with us

Dutch Fork isn't the only fish commission-maintained dam with serious problems. Anglers on Canonsburg Lake, a 78-acre stocked trout impoundment on Little Chartiers Creek in Washington County with an excellent largemouth population, know how shallow the upper end has become.

Though the lake remains open, the buildup of silt is so enormous, "the upper end is more of a wetlands, it's basically filling in," Tredinnick said.

Estimates for dredging have been as low as $3 million, but the dam needs almost $1 million in repairs and reinforcements if it is to withstand future siltation, Tredinnick added. Canonsburg is one of 18 dams on the commission's high hazard list, which is based on the outmoded designs of dams and their proximity to populated areas.

The commission maintains 62 dams, but doesn't own them. Like the hatcheries the commission manages, they are deeded to the commonwealth. All must meet DEP standards for environmental quality and safety. When they don't, and when repairs need to be made, the Fish and Boat Commission, not the commonwealth, is expected to pay.

Currently, hatcheries and dams need more than $100 million in repairs, although the commission can barely meet its operating budget, since it derives most of its revenue from fishing license fees and sales have been down for a decade.

Advertise with us

The commission is hoping that if the governor's $625 million Growing Greener budget is approved in the May 17 primary, it will mean money for dams and hatcheries. The commission is trying to rally support for the bond initiative through letters to bass tournament clubs, Trout Unlimited and other sportsmen's groups.

Tredinnick said the commission has been given no guarantees about funding, and even if voters say they are willing to incur debt over six years, it will be up to legislators to decide how to divide funds.

"We've been promised nothing, but we're asking voters to support Growing Greener because, at the very least, they'll benefit indirectly by improvements to watersheds," Tredinnick said.

The commission's high hazard list includes several dams in this area that were built decades ago with materials and designs considered obsolete today. They is Upper Hereford Manor Lake, which has been drawn down and now serves as a catch basin for the lower lake, a stocked trout impoundment. The commission would like to someday close both lakes and construct one big impoundment, Tredinnick said.

Also on the list is Virgin Run Dam, Somerset Lake, Highpoint Lake, Hemlock Lake and Donegal Lake. Though each is safe, Tredinnick said, none is considered capable of handling a worst-case rainfall event, or a "probable maximum flood" as defined by the National Weather Service. Canonsburg has a PMF of 22 percent and Dutch Fork, 16 percent.

Advertise with us

The commission, like the private sector, is required to inspect the dams for which it is responsible on a quarterly or annual basis, and to furnish data to DEP.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.