Darrell Sapp, Post-Gazette

A doe is seen near a stream along Clifton Road in Bethel Park.

Click photo for larger image.

Antlerless Allocations

Advertise with us

The following are the anterless deer allocations as set by the Pennsylvania Game Commission for Wildlife Management Units in Western Pennsylvania last year and this season with the percentage of change:

WMU

2004

2005

% change

Advertise with us

1A

48,000

40,000

-17

1B

Advertise with us

33,000

27,000

-18

2A

55,000

Advertise with us

55,000

0

2B

68,000

68,000

Advertise with us

0

2C

75,000

53,000

-29

Advertise with us

2D

58,000

56,000

-3

After months of complaints from hunters and legislators about too few deer, and in dire need of a hunting license increase that only the state legislature can grant, the Pennsylvania Game Commission met in Harrisburg last week to finalize the framework for the 2005 hunting season.

Advertise with us

Commissioners voted to cut the allocation of antlerless (doe) licenses by 15 percent statewide, from 1,039,000 doe tags last year to 879,000 for the coming season.

"In the past, we used a goal and a number," Commission wildlife management bureau director Calvin DuBrock said. "Now we're looking at a variety of things, deer health, productivity, winter kill, landowner objectives. Generally, we are looking to stabilize populations."

But the cuts in doe licenses were far deeper in some Wildlife Management Units. Commissioners reduced the allocation by 44 percent in WMU 2G in northcentral Pennsylvania. That unit holds extensive blocks of state forest land owned by the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (DCNR) and has been at the center of the debate over deer numbers and their impact on forest regeneration, native plant diversity and other wildlife such as songbirds, small mammals and ruffed grouse.

The Commission cut the allocation in WMU 2F, which includes the Allegheny National Forest in parts of Elk, Forest, McKean and Warren counties, by 32 percent, and in WMU 2C, covering southwestern Pennsylvania's Laurel Highlands, by 29 percent. Commissioners also made large cuts in the 2005 allocation for agricultural zones. WMUs 5A and 5B, covering the intensively farmed Cumberland and Susquehanna valleys had their allocations reduced by 13 percent. Statewide, farmers lose between $70 million and $90 million annually in crop damage caused by deer.

Commissioner Russ Schleiden said that although the allocations were significantly reduced, the agency hoped enough deer could be killed with DMAP (Deer Management Assistance Program) permits, especially in WMU 2G, to offset the reduction. DMAP provides antlerless permits to landowners in addition to the overall WMU allocation. DCNR has been the major DMAP participant the past two hunting seasons.

Advertise with us

"I look at this as a major adjustment, and I am a little concerned about some of these areas." Schleiden said.

Prior to setting the antlerless allocations, the Commission voted to liberalize the DMAP program, permitting landowners to issue two DMAP coupons per hunter for each DMAP property.

But questions remain about the effectiveness of DMAP. Managers do not know, for instance, if DMAP contributes to additional deer harvest or if hunters simply elect to tag their deer with a DMAP tag instead of a regular antlerless tag, resulting in no net increase in deer kill.

"I foresee that we'll be enrolling larger areas in DMAP on a general basis and to focus on hot spots if we can," said DCNR wildlife biologist Merlin Benner. "Virtually everywhere in [WMU] 2G where they cut the tags so much, we still have to fence to get trees to grow. We're still seeing severe overbrowsing."

Benner said forest recovery in the northern mountains could not be accomplished in one or two years.

Advertise with us

"There are a few pockets where we are beginning to get some forest regeneration, but they are not in the bank yet. They need time to grow and get a start above the deer. If we would actually allow this habitat to recover we'd ultimately have a much better habitat for deer, but it seems we're unwilling to get to that point in the long run," he said.

More than 31,000 acres of state forest land are behind deer fences to allow seedling growth, costing state taxpayers more than one million dollars annually. The Game Commission also uses deer fences on state game lands.

Commissioner Thomas Boop did not share Benner's concern for fencing. "I'm not sympathetic to DCNR's argument about fencing," Boop said. "You have to fence to keep wildlife in or wildlife out."

"DCNR mismanaged those forests for 50 years," added Commissioner Steve Mohr. "I hope someone takes responsibility for that."

But scientists note the same kinds of conditions on the Allegheny National Forest, managed by the U.S. Forest Service in WMU 2G. "One thing that we are finding pretty typical is the habitat here on the Allegheny is still pretty beaten," said Brad Nelson, a wildlife biologist with the U.S. Forest Service.

Advertise with us

Like Benner, Nelson said there were pockets of improvement in the woods. "I've been here on the forest for 20 years, and I can see some improvement in the habitat," he said. "It's not much but in some places you can see a little bit of hemlock regeneration and a we're getting some blackberry now when we cut. But there's not a lot out there to eat and it's going to take a while having low deer numbers to get this habitat back."

Despite a push by the Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania, which had threatened to sue the Commission for reducing the deer herd, commissioners voted 4-2 to retain the 2-week concurrent season for bucks and antlerless deer. Boop moved to shorten the concurrent season by one week.

"I can't support you on that," Schleiden said. "There are already accusations of a lack of science. We're trying to get some consistency here to see trends over time."

"I was disappointed they didn't follow through with Boop's motion," said Unified Sportsmen board chairman Greg Levengood. "I would have liked something more aggressive. A lot of guys would like to go back to a bucks-only season."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.