The Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (DCNR) has released data from its aerial count of deer herds on state forests in northern and central Pennsylvania.
Following a high-level clash with the Game Commission over the pace of deer herd reductions on state forests damaged by deer browsing, DCNR hired Vision Air Research, an independent wildlife research firm based in Idaho, to fly over 250,000 acres of state forest land and count deer with infrared cameras. Known as FLIR (forward looking infrared), the technology detects and records heat images emitted by a deer's body at altitudes at or above 1,000 feet.
Observers reviewed the tapes to distinguish deer from coyotes, bears, elk and other mammals. Results released April 19 are from about 30 percent of the contracted areas. The completed flights surveyed state forest lands in Centre, Clinton, Lycoming, Pike, Potter, Tioga and Union counties.
"In some areas, our flights show deer density far beyond what the Pennsylvania Game Commission deems suitable for available habitat," Vision Air Research president Susan Bernatas said. "And in other areas, the numbers were lower. Like the terrain over which we flew, deer numbers varied significantly from forest tract to forest tract."
The flights counted the highest densities of deer in the Promised Land area of the Delaware State forest in Pike County in northeastern Pennsylvania. Flying above 20 square miles at Promised Land, the FLIR cameras recorded heat images of 446 deer for a calculated density of 23.7 per square mile. The lowest concentrations observed were in the Cedar Run section of Tioga State Forest, Tioga County, 9.64; followed by the southern section of Sproul State Forest, in Clinton County, 10.69.
DCNR wildlife biologist Merlin Benner pointed out that the numbers reflect a minimum count. "It's important to note that the plane's camera may well miss deer if they are bedded down in hemlock or dense cover, but it does show that deer exist in these areas--and in some areas well beyond the Game Commission's [target] over-wintering density," he said.
Tests of the FLIR technology show that 60 percent of deer can escape detection if they are hidden in heavy cover, such as laurel, rhododendron or hemlock. Steep terrain can also affect the results.
Target densities, which average about 15 deer per square mile in the surveyed forests, are based on deer impacts on commercially valuable tree species and do not take into account browsing on wildflowers, shrubs and other preferred plants that can be eliminated from the forest at densities below those known to impact timber regeneration.
Benner also pointed out that the counts were made during the time of year when deer populations are at their lowest -- after the hunting season. Birth of fawns this spring could boost local populations by 30-40 percent.
"We intend to combine the infrared data with habitat information to see where we may continue to seek changes in deer densities," DCNR secretary Michael DiBerardinis said. "It should be no surprise to anyone that this snapshot shows fewer deer in areas where there is no regeneration, little food and sparse habitat. A healthy, regenerating forest means a healthy deer herd."
The head of the state's largest sportsman organization also believes deer numbers have dropped but said it is time to take the pressure off the herd by reducing the allocation of antlerless permits.
"We feel the commission's deer reduction program has worked,'' said Melody Zullinger, executive director of the Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen's Clubs, which represents more than 90,000 members. "They're finally admitting the hunters did the job. Now, let's set the [antlerless] allocation to reflect that.''
But even on the lands with the lowest observed deer densities, DCNR must still erect deer-proof fences to allow tree seedlings to grow after timber harvests. Deer fences cost the DCNR more than $1 million each year. More than 31,000 acres of forest land are now behind fences and off-limits to hunting, fishing, hiking and other forms of recreation. DCNR believes it may be reaching the limit of how much fenced-off land the outdoor public will tolerate.
According to DCNR professionals in the field, though, deer fence is the only thing allowing some native plants to grow on state forests. Tim Carr, a forester on the Delaware State Forest said, "Here are some plant species that our foresters of 30 years did not recognize because they did not recall ever seeing them. I had to go to my field guides to determine them. And note that they were found in abundance within the fences."
Looking down
Aerial surveys of selected state forest lands show deer densities near or above levels that harm forests. The count was done before the spring birth of fawns and includes only deer that were actually recorded by infra-red cameras.
Survey site
No. of deer counted
Winter density
Habitat condition
Tioga State Forest
104
9.6/sq. mile
poor-very poor
Sproul State Forest
263
10.7/sq. mile
very poor
Bald Eagle State Park
254
14.3/sq mile
very poor
Tioga State Forest
335
10.9/sq. mile
poor
Algerine Wild Area
109
14.0/sq. mile
very poor
McIntyre Wild Area
359
18.2/sq. mile
poor




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.