Douglass Oster, Post-Gazette
Slippery Rock Creek in Butler County has long been a magnet for trout fishermen in Western Pennsylvania.
Click photo for larger image.
Weighing in on proposed trout stream regulations
Fishing: Re-designation of certain waters doesn't make sense
Trout-fishing regulations will be simpler and will better reflect the desires of anglers if the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission grants final approval to a new proposal.
The Fish and Boat Commission proposes to consolidate several special regulation trout stream categories to simplify regulations and enforcement. The change with the widest effect is a proposed merger of the existing Heritage Trout Angling category with the current Delayed Harvest Fly-Fishing Only class of streams. The consolidation would create a new special regulation category titled "Catch and Release Fly-Fishing Only."
If approved, the most important difference in stream management will be the abolition of the summer harvest period on Delayed Harvest Fly-Fishing Only waters. Currently, Delayed Harvest streams are open to fishing year round, but a maximum of three trout may be creeled in the period from June 15 to the day after Labor Day (Sept. 6 this year). No trout may be taken at other times.
The consolidation will continue year-round trout fishing on all the effected streams but will prohibit the taking of trout at any time. There are currently seven streams managed under the Heritage Trout Angling program, all of which are in central or eastern Pennsylvania. Twenty-six streams are managed as Delayed Harvest Fly-Fishing Only. Among these streams, Western Pennsylvania anglers are most familiar with Yellow Creek in Bedford County, Dunbar Creek in Fayette County, Little Mahoning Creek in Indiana County, the North Fork of Redbank Creek in Jefferson County, Slippery Rock Creek in Lawrence County, Little Sandy Creek in Venango County and Clear Shade Creek in Somerset County.
The proposal makes sense because fly fishermen have expressed support for catch-and-release angling, and surveys indicate that few fly fishermen are interested in killing trout during the harvest period. When the Commission recently considered permitting bait to be used on Delayed Harvest streams during the harvest period, an overwhelming majority of comments from fishermen not only opposed that change but also asked for more restriction on harvesting trout in the summer. Fish and Boat Commissioners subsequently voted down the bait-fishing proposal.
The original thinking behind the Delayed Harvest program was that these streams could not support trout through the warm summer months, so anglers might as well keep some of the trout they catch at that time. But fly anglers increasingly report holdover trout surviving through the summer, offering quality fishing throughout the year.
The threat to the recreational value of stocked or holdover trout in these streams is the illegal taking of trout by those who disregard the regulations. Dunbar Creek is a good example. There, especially in the spring, violators using bait brazenly take trout from the stream despite the Delayed Harvest Fly-Fishing Only rules. It is rare to fish Dunbar without finding discarded bait containers strewn along the bank.
Enforcement is difficult. Violators often use ATVs to access the stream from diverse directions, and disappear at the first sign of detection. Stopping this drain on the recreational value of an otherwise valuable regional resource demands close coordination between Fish and Boat Commission and Game Commission officers (the stream flows through state game lands where ATV use is forbidden), concerned anglers, the local municipality and local magistrates. Conservation officers often have cited ATV violators in the past, but the charges are frequently dismissed in the local courts.
The proposal to consolidate special regulations and curtail summer trout harvest meshes well with the Commission's earlier announcement that it would release the exact date of in-season trout stockings on hundreds of trout streams under general regulation, where all types of tackle are permitted and where anglers may creel five trout per day. Announcing the stocking dates allows those who wish to harvest trout the maximum opportunity to do so. It's a way to make the most efficient use of hatchery-raised trout, an increasingly expensive and limited recreational resource.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.