Scott McCloskey, Associated Press

An estimated 6,000 antlerless deer were taken in Allegheny County last year.

Click photo for larger image.

By the numbers

Advertise with us

The following is the area county-by-county harvest estimates from the Pennsylvania game Commission on last year's deer harvest:

Allegheny:

2,100 antlered, 6,000 antlerless.

Armstrong:

3,200 antlered, 6,700 antlerless.

Advertise with us

Beaver:

1,200 antlered, 3,600 antlerless.

Bedford:

3,100 antlered, 6,700 antlerless.

Blair:

Advertise with us

1,300 antlered, 2,400 antlerless.

Bradford:

4,300 antlered, 8,400 antlerless.

Butler:

2,800 antlered, 6,600 antlerless.

Advertise with us

Cambria:

2,100 antlered, 3,900 antlerless.

Clarion:

2,300 antlered, 4,800 antlerless.

Clearfield:

Advertise with us

3,300 antlered, 6,000 antlerless.

Clinton:

1,100 antlered; 2,000 antlerless.

Crawford:

3,200 antlered, 7,600 antlerless.

Advertise with us

Elk:

1,200 antlered, 2,400 antlerless.

Erie:

1,700 antlered, 3,900 antlerless.

Fayette:

Advertise with us

2,000 antlered, 4,200 antlerless.

Forest:

1,200 antlered, 2,500 antlerless.

Franklin:

1,700 antlered, 4,200 antlerless.

Advertise with us

Greene:

2,800 antlered, 6,700 antlerless.

Indiana:

3,400 antlered, 6,400 antlerless.

Jefferson:

Advertise with us

2,800 antlered, 5,800 antlerless.

Lawrence:

500 antlered, 1,800 antlerless.

McKean:

1,400 antlered, 3,800 antlerless.

Advertise with us

Mercer:

2,00 antlered, 6,000 antlerless.

Somerset:

2,200 antlered, 7,300 antlerless.

Venango:

Advertise with us

2,200 antlered, 5,400 antlerless.

Warren:

2,200 antlered, 5,000 antlerless.

Washington:

4,000 antlered, 9,400 antlerless.

Advertise with us

Westmoreland:

4,000 antlered, 9,600 antlerless.

In the fall, deer hunters took home the sixth-highest number of deer in any year since the Pennsylvania Game Commission began estimating deer-kill numbers in 1986, according to statistics released by the agency last week. The total kill was 409,320, 12 percent lower than the total take in 2003. Hunters tagged 124,410 antlered bucks and 284,910 antlerless deer.

Bowhunters took 62,460 deer (28,070 and 34,390 antlerless deer), while hunters using muzzleloaders shot 31,270 whitetails (1,240 bucks and 34,420 antlerless). The much larger antlerless kill by muzzleloaders is expected because the October muzzleloader season is for antlerless deer only and the after-Christmas flintlock hunt occurs after bucks have dropped their antlers.

Compared to 2003, the 2004 statewide take of antlered bucks was down 13 percent, ranging from a decline of 35 percent in Wildlife Management Unit (WMU) 2G to an increase of 13 percent in Wildlife Management Unit 4B. Hunters killed 12 percent fewer antlerless deer last year compared to 2003. But trends in the antlerless kill differed widely across the state, from a 48-percent decline in WMU 2G to a 51 percent jump in WMU 2B.

Advertise with us

"As we've been saying all along, deer populations and their trends are not the same across the Commonwealth," said Calvin W. DuBrock, Game Commission Wildlife Management Bureau director. "Harvests declining by more than 20 percent in WMUs 1B, 2C, 2E, 2F, 2G, 3D and 4D coincide with areas where hunters have expressed concerns of too few deer. But harvest data in some units -- such as WMUs 2A and 5C -- indicate good populations."

Southwestern Pennsylvania illustrates DuBrock's observation, continuing its recent trend of high deer harvests. Wildlife Management Units 1A, 2A, 2B, 2C and 2D, which cover all of southwestern Pennsylvania, accounted for 29 percent of the statewide buck kill and 32 percent of the doe take.

On a county basis, southwestern Pennsylvania's dominance in deer hunting was even more evident. Westmoreland and Washington counties were first and second in total deer kill (13,600 and 13,400, respectively), and the southwest had four counties -- Westmoreland, Washington, Armstrong and Indiana -- in the state's top 10 in total harvest, with Greene and Somerset counties tied for 11th position. The region's high numbers are noteworthy because antler restrictions are stricter in much of the region, with a legal minimum of four points to one side of the rack.

A decided shift in deer hunting pressure away from mountainous counties toward suburban areas is evident in last season's statistics, as it has been in recent years. Wildlife Management Unit 2B, which includes Allegheny County and the surrounding suburban fringes of Butler, Beaver, Washington and Westmoreland counties, yielded a total of 20,200 deer, more than all the traditional deer hunting regions along the northern tier.

And deer kills per square mile in WMU 2B's suburban fringe outside Allegheny County are among the highest anywhere.

Advertise with us

The vast majority of the land area within Wildlife Management Unit 2B is in Allegheny County. Yet, Allegheny County yielded only 40 percent of the deer taken in WMU 2B. That indicates that hunters killed more than 12,000 deer in the narrow urbanizing fringe zone of southern Butler, eastern Beaver, northern Washington and western Westmoreland counties. It also shows that hunters tagged more deer in Pittsburgh's suburban ring than in all of rural, mountainous Wildlife Management Unit 2G, once the epicenter of Pennsylvania deer hunting.

DuBrock indicated in his remarks that northern mountain areas where harvests were lowest cannot presently support higher deer populations without sacrificing the future health of forests.

"By decreasing the deer herd, and thereby deer impacts on the habitat in these areas, we believe that overbrowsed habitat will begin to recover so that these areas can one day sustain higher deer numbers, as well as other game and non-game species," DuBrock said. After reviewing the 2004 deer data, the Game Commission will finalize deer seasons and antlerless allocations for 2005 at its meeting in Harrisburg next month.

The statewide deer harvest declined about 12 percent in 2004.

-- Photo by Ben Plank, Associated Press

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.