The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission will hold a special meeting Wednesday in Harrisburg to consider proposals to overhaul trout fishing regulations and to stock streams with bigger fish -- making up for what didn't get handled when the January board meeting was canceled because of bad weather.
The eight-member commission (which is still short two members) is expected to vote to increase the size of hatchery-raised trout, beginning in 2007. The move would mean more rainbows and half the usual number of brown trout. It also is expected to begin the process of streamlining trout fishing regulations, although a final vote will not be taken until later this year. It is part of an initiative by the commission's executive director Doug Austen to get more folks fishing -- and buying more licenses -- by making it simpler to target trout. He directed staff to look at ways in which programs could be consolidated or eliminated. They came up with the following proposals:
Eliminate the Heritage Trout Angling Program (seven waters) and the Delayed Harvest Fly Fishing Only Program (26 waters) and replace them with a new program called Catch and Release Fly Fishing Only. This would provide for year-round fishing with no harvest, no restrictions on hours or wading and no requirement for barbless hooks.
Rename the All-Tackle Trophy Trout Program to Trophy Trout All Tackle and increase the minimum size of a trophy trout from 14 inches to 16 inches. The daily harvest limit would be one (not two) trout, and the wading restriction would be lifted. The section of the Allegheny River below the Kinzua Dam in Warren County under "miscellaneous special regulations" would be put into this program.
Create a Trophy Trout Artificial Lures Only Program that would replace the existing Trophy Trout Program (eight waters) and Catch and Release Program (18 waters). The 16-inch, one trout a day creel limit would apply. Barbed hooks, wading and year-round fishing would be allowed.
Create a new program called Catch and Release All-Tackle for two waters currently managed under "miscellaneous special regulations," which are Spring Creek in Centre County and Valley Creek in Chester County.
Amend the Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only Program to remove the dawn to dusk rule and allow for 24 hour fishing.
The Wild Brook Trout Enhancement Program and Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only Program are expected to remain unchanged.
Commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick said these changes are what anglers have indicated they want after a series of focus group meetings. However, not all group members support all of the proposals.
Representatives of Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited object to turning Catch and Release streams into Trophy Trout waters, which allow for the harvesting of fish. If the commission decides to move ahead with new regulations, the process would require a public comment period and a final vote later this year.
The commission does not need to seek angler input before approving a plan to increase the average size of hatchery trout from 10 to 11 inches and .45 pounds to .58 pounds, even though it would mean 20 percent fewer fish and many more rainbows than browns.
Because hatcheries can produce only 1.9 million pounds of trout a year, the total number of fish would drop from 4 million to 3.2 million a year, Tredinnick said. It also would mean an increase in the number of rainbows from 40 percent to 60 percent, and a decrease in brown trout from 40 percent to 20 percent. The percentage of brook trout would remain at 20, Tredinnick said.
"Rainbow trout are the easiest to raise in a hatchery setting. It's easier to grow them big, fast, and they don't mind crowding. They're more domesticated. Browns need more space. They're more disease prone. Brookies are somewhere in the middle," Tredinnick said.
Not everyone is happy with the prospect of fewer browns. "For the fly fisherman, browns are more of a challenge," said steelhead guide John Nagy of Brookline, who also fly fishes for trout. "They're by and large more selective than rainbows and brookies. Because of their preference for slower water, they have more time to examine what floats in front of them. Rainbows and brookies are more opportunistic."
Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited has expressed concern that rainbows would be stocked over wild browns in some streams, which is a likely prospect, Tredinnick said. The new production goals would not affect the 130,000 trout purchased from the private Tellico hatchery in North Carolina, the one million obtained from the Cooperative Nursery Program, or the 100,000 received from the Allegheny National Fish Hatchery.
Other issues are expected to get action or consideration in April, when the commission holds its regularly scheduled quarterly meeting. They include:
Eliminating traditional formulas for stocking trout in lakes and streams and giving staff more leeway in allocating fish, based on factors such as fishing pressure and public access.
Revamping its list of wild trout streams.
Restoring creel limits and sizes on Lake Erie walleye next year to the 15-inch minimum, five fish a day maximum. Because the 2003 year class is shaping up to be the best in 19 years, the commission says the 18-inch, three per day limit is no longer necessary.
Increasing the minimum age of personal watercraft operators to 16 years old.
Allowing gas engines on the commission's 19 largest lakes which are restricted to unpowered boats and electric only motors
For details on agenda items, visit www.fish.state.pa.us. To send comments to the commission, e-mail www.state.pa.us/Fish/regcomments, or post letters to Executive Director, Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, P.O. Box 67000, Harrisburg, Pa. 17106-7000.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.