Owning a tackle shop can be an upstream swim for some, but the partners of International Angler, an Aspinwall fly fishing retailer, are planning to open a second location in Robinson Township, just in time for spring trout season.
Fishing Notebook:
Fishing camps registrations needed
"We're rolling the dice," said the shop's managing partner Chuck Thompson, who is hoping to open the Robinson shop by April 1. "But everything's a gamble. We looked a long time for a good location and this one has perfect access."
Thompson and his partners Nick Pribanic, Franklin Gorrell and Chuck Gomulka are transforming a defunct Sunoco service station into a 2,300 square foot shop on Route 60 just a quarter mile from I-79. It is the state's densest corridor in terms of fishing license sales. Thompson believes location plus competitive prices and personalized service can buck competition from big box stores and Internet sales, which have been a problem for others in the business.
"The Internet killed us," said Bill Hile of Highland Sports, the Murrysville tackle shop that closed last Christmas Eve after eight years. "Part of it was two years of construction on Route 22, but mostly it was the Internet. We kept pouring more money into the shop, trying to compete and finally said, that's enough."
Highland Sports was the third fly shop to close last year in south-western Pennsylvania. The others were South Hills Rod and Reel in Dormont and DeFrank's Fly Shop in Chalk Hill near Nemacolin Woodlands. Some shops have cut services. Allegheny Bait and Tackle in Tarentum, for instance, didn't offer fly tying classes in January for the first time in eight years because so few folks showed interest, said owner Rick DiMichele.
In general, fishing is down -- although fly fishing has taken less of a hit than other types -- according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 2000 census.
"Fishing is stable to dropping, a trend we're trying to reverse," Gander Mountain regional marketing manager Jeff Siegle said. "And Pittsburgh, frankly, is one of our toughest markets, between the declining population and competition among the bigger box stores. You've got Cabela's in Wheeling, Bass Pro in Harrisburg and Dick's defending its home turf."
Fishing accounts for just two percent of Gander Mountain's overall business, except in Erie where it is 40 percent, Siegle said. Erie also has proved to be an excellent market for the Lake Erie Ultimate Angler, which Steve Brugger and Forest County Sports Center's Dan Habjanetz opened two years ago.
"We're the only game in town for pure fly fishing," Brugger said. "We have outfits from $59 to $725 and we're willing to show people how to use them, how to tie knots and flies and where to fish. Big box stores don't like breaking open packages for people."
When customers are willing to forgo personal service, many will buy on-line or from catalogues. Dick's Sporting Goods' senior vice president of strategic planning, Jeffrey R. Hennion, said his company's on-line business is growing, and even small shops find e-commerce lucrative.
"You can do as much business as you're willing to sit in front of a computer," said Rich Zoog of Orchard View Angler in the South Hills. "Instead of 20 pairs of eyes looking at something, you have 100. And they're looking for a particular item, so it's good for hard to move merchandise."
Gander Mountain presently does no Internet or catalogue sales, since it sold its mail order business to Cabela's a decade ago, Siegle said.
"People have to come into our stores to buy," Siegle said. And there will be 18 new stores, including one in Johnstown, by the end of this year for a total of 100, nationally, he said.
Dick's has 240 stores in 32 states but, Hennion said, "We view everybody as competition, even small specialty shops."
Dick's has been widening its selection of upscale merchandise, said Hennion. "We felt we'd moved away from, and not offered as much of, an assortment of high end tackle. We're shifting toward that customer. People aren't shy about telling us what they want. They want the cheapest price and service to go with it."
Siegle said Gander Mountain also is striving to provide "the best small-store service with larger store prices," through classes and promotional events. "Can we do it to the level of the entrepreneur? Probably not," he said. "But we come awfully close."
Thompson, meanwhile, said he and his partners haven't settled on a name for their new shop, although it may include Outfitter, given the store's relationship with Frontiers International Travel, the locally based company that arranges fishing and hunting excursions to exotic places most folks only dream of. International Angler outfits Frontiers' customers for those trips.
"Chains can't offer the same level of service we do, where we not only custom choose your rod and hand pick your flies, we take you outside and work with you on your casting," Thompson said. "People don't stick with the sport when they're frustrated by the wrong equipment or when they don't get the mentoring and education they need. Anyone who wants to be part of the fly fishing community has to develop a relationship with a fly shop."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.