Right now, aircraft are flying over Pennsylvania's state forests, training infrared cameras on the woods below. The pilots and their assistants know what they're doing. They fly rigid, pre-determined transect lines above the landscape, attempting to record on tape the image of the heat emitted by the bodies of white-tailed deer. Later, the deer-heat images can be counted and distinguished from the heat-prints of other animals such as coyotes and elk.
The Department of Conservation and Natural Resources has hired a contractor to make the flights, mostly over state forests in the northern and central mountains, and is sharing the data with the Pennsylvania Game Commission. For most people these flights are not exactly front-page news, but to deer hunters they have taken on the importance of a spacecraft sent to detect life on another planet.
Many hunters believe the flights will finally verify their claims that there are far fewer deer in the woods than the Game Commission's population models have indicated. If the deer counts are low, many have said, the flights will prove that over-hunting has destroyed the herd and a cutback in doe license allocations and a return to shorter seasons will be justified.
But, as with most human efforts to measure and quantify nature, it's not that simple. Topography and vegetation can influence the count. Conifer cover, such as hemlock, which dominates the stream bottoms across much of the surveyed forests, can obscure the camera's view of 60 percent of the deer hidden beneath them. Steep slopes can also affect the results. Managers who have used infrared surveys for deer say that interpreting the results is straightforward on small areas where personnel are intimately familiar with all the variables, but reading the data from larger zones--such as the 250,000 acres of surveyed state forests--demands more subtle interpretation.
Jeff Krause is a wildlife biologist with the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers at Raystown Lake. He participated in an aerial infrared survey of deer there on Nov. 26, just days before the 2004 deer season. The findings of the Raystown area flights, coupled with solid data about the condition of the forests there, offer a caution to anyone who thinks that deer numbers alone tell the entire story.
About 20,000 of Raystown's 22,000 acres are open to public hunting, and the area has a long history of active hunter use. Despite that, the flights found an assessed average density of 51 deer per square mile. More importantly, deer were not distributed randomly across the project. The western shore of Raystown Lake, where hunter access is most convenient, and where hunter activity has been consistently highest, held 80 deer per square mile before the season. Terrace Mountain, east of the lake, which is hard for hunters to reach, harbored 30 deer per square mile.
"We've also studied the browse and the regeneration of tree species. You need that to see the deer numbers in context," Krause said. "Our results show that habitat is more important than hunter access and hunter harvest. We know that on Terrace Mountain there are 0.2 pounds of browse per acre available to deer, while there are 3.5 pounds per acre on the west shore.
"We've counted the vehicles parked around the project in hunting season. There are as many as 400 vehicles parked on the west side of the lake and every year we see the highest harvests coming from that area."
Krause said the counts on Terrace Mountain would probably have been even lower if acorn mast hadn't been available there at the time of the survey.
"Even though we had high deer numbers [30 deer per square mile] on Nov. 26, that same area would not be able to support those deer year round," he said. "They had acorns that year but once the acorns were gone the deer would further damage the understory or move out."
In the Raystown example, if Krause looked at the raw deer numbers without considering other factors, habitat especially, he might conceivably cut back the number of DMAP coupons he has issued for the Terrace Mountain tract. Or, he might restrict hunter access even further. But because he knows the condition of the forest, he knows there's a reason for fewer deer that has nothing to do with hunting--unless it's a lack of hunting over the years.
According to Jim Grace, director of DCNR's Bureau of Forestry, the raw deer numbers will provide a starting point at best.
"This is a minimum count that will give us a snapshot of one point in time," Grace said. "Our goal is to have some accurate information as to what the deer herd is at that point and then have a discussion as to what it should be."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.