The final weigh-in will be on April Fool's Day, but the contest is no joke.
With $5,000 at stake for biggest fish, Dan Seaman of Elk Creek Sports Store said he plans to go ahead with a month-long steelhead tournament on Erie County streams March 1-31, despite angler concerns about fallout from increased fishing pressure.
"You see things now on the stream when money isn't even an issue -- litter and all the other behaviors that cause people to post their land," said Jim Pfendler, president of the Northwest Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited, a cold water conservation group whose members also fish. "Big money will breed even more animosity."
Besides the $5,000 prize for the largest steelhead caught in March, $250 will be awarded for largest fish of the week, along with smaller daily prizes, said Seaman, who is sponsoring the contest with John Puline of Uncle John's Elk Creek Campground.
"We want to boost the local economy and raise money for the Erie Shriners Hospital," Seaman said. "The Shriners will get whatever is left once expenses are covered."
With support from Wal-Mart and other local businesses, Seaman said he needs 350 participants to break even. Last week, he said he had taken "a ton" of phone calls but didn't know how many anglers had paid the $35 entry fee, since applications are available at multiple locations. He is promising a new Chevy truck to whoever breaks the state steelhead record.
Some of the largest steelies, especially males, run in spring. The state record, a 20-pound, 3-ounce steelhead caught April 1, 2001.
Seaman's, and other Erie tackle shops, including Poor Richard's Bait and Tackle, hold steelhead contests in the fall, but not for big money. The Pennsylvania Steelhead Association, an organization that seeks to promote good landowner relations, recently issued a statement expressing concern about the possible impact of high-stakes tournaments without naming Seaman's specifically. But Matt Hrycyk, who works at Poor Richard's and, in April, will replace Poor Richard's owner Gary Heubel as the steelhead association president, said he plans to enter the tournament because, like a lot of anglers, he will be fishing for steelhead next month anyway.
And, he said, he is willing to reserve judgment until after the contest is held.
Seaman said he is urging contestants to be well behaved and will keep them honest with a lie-detector test when it comes to the top prize. "If something dire happens, we'll re-evaluate. But for now, we want people to give the contest a chance," he said. "The litter and land-owner problems have been stressed.
We're telling people to handle the smolts right, to release them carefully. If need be, snip off the line and let them go. We want people to do things right."
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission has permitted the contest and commission biologist Roger Kenyon said steelhead populations, including smolts, are "robust enough" to withstand increased pressure. But he's not so sure about property owners.
"People who live along the streams are very protective and rightly so. They're worried and rightly so," he said. "When you draw a lot of anglers to a concentrated area, the resource won't be harmed, but the people who want to get to it may trample on the privilege."
Steelhead guide and author John Nagy agrees. "I don't believe in competitive fishing because it can lead to confrontations, to trespassing, and even to illegal activity in some cases. When there's money on the table, all bets are off.
"I could never condone a contest that requires you to kill a steelhead. I'd rather see fishermen encouraged to appreciate the total angling experience instead of pressuring themselves to catch fish."
Steelhead activity has tripled in Erie in the past decade, generating a gold mine for the local economy. At the same time, littering, illegal parking and other behavior associated with big crowds have caused Erie property owners to post 'No Trespassing' signs at a rapid rate. It has become such a crisis that the Fish and Boat Commission introduced a Lake Erie stamp this year to raise money for the purchase of easements and other access.
While Pfendler has asked the Fish and Boat Commission to halt the contest, the agency said that isn't going to happen. Even the controversy that reached a boiling point on the popular Web site www.fisherie.com quieted some after Seaman posted a response defending his plans and advising that he was getting "sick and tired of criticism" that he said "bordered on slander."
"I think we're all sick of it," Heubel said. "At this point it's more like, let's wait and see how it goes."
Entry fees are $35, or $20 for those ages 16 and under. For more, visit www.fishingderbies.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.