Robert Pavuchak, Post-Gazette

Dr. Bill Giuliano, professor at California University, is doing a study on Pennsylvania's ruffed grouse.

Click photo for larger image.

Closing dates

Advertise with us

Here are the general closing dates or times of the month for winter grouse hunting in a number of states:

State

Date

Michigan

Jan. 1*

Advertise with us

Wisconsin (eastern)

early December

Wisconsin (northern)

late December

Wisconsin (western)

Advertise with us

late January

Minnesota

late December

Maine

late December

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania

mid-January**

Maryland

late January

Virginia

Advertise with us

early February

West Virginia

mid-February

Ohio

mid-February

Advertise with us

Kentucky

late February

Tennessee

late February

North Carolina

Advertise with us

late February

South Carolina

March 1

* Recently extended from mid-November in upper peninsula

** Proposed to late January

Advertise with us

You can't exactly call it the "grouse wars," reminiscent of the furor over deer management. It's more a case of "grouse angst," and the Pennsylvania Game Commission and grouse hunters are dealing with it right now.

Grouse angst stems from a passion for the bird and its pursuit among grouse hunters, balanced against biologists' collective uncertainty about the impact of hunting on grouse populations, winter hunting especially. States in the southern Appalachian portion of ruffed grouse range run their seasons longer into winter.

In the Kentucky, North Carolina and Tennessee mountains hunters can pursue grouse through the end of February. Northern states clustered around the Great Lakes are more conservative. Most close the season by late December. Most northern states, though, have a more liberal daily bag limit.

In parts of Michigan hunters may kill five grouse per day. Pennsylvania's daily limit is two birds.

Research on the impact of hunting on grouse populations has delivered conflicting results. Some early studies found that hunting mortality had no long-term affect. Others concluded that mortality from late season hunting, in particular, was "additive," meaning that birds taken by hunters in winter would otherwise have survived until spring to breed and nest.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania is the "equator" of sorts in the ruffed grouse's eastern North American homeland, blending some of the concerns and advantages from states to the north and south. The Pennsylvania Game Commission has generally chosen to err on the conservative side of grouse seasons but proposed a two-week statewide extension to the winter hunt at its meeting last month.

That would give hunters 76 days to pursue ruffed grouse next fall and winter, as opposed to 65 days in 2004-05, with the added days coming in late January. If commissioners vote final approval in April, the 2005-06 grouse seasons will run Oct. 15-Nov. 26; Dec. 12-23; and Dec. 26-Jan. 28.

The 2004-05 grouse season ended Jan. 15.

From 1982-92, 12 selected counties had a short winter season, which closed on the first Saturday after New Years, while 55 counties had a longer hunt running to the third Saturday in January.

Working with grouse-hunter cooperators who recorded their hunting activity, biologists compared flush rates in both sets of counties over the 10-year span. They detected no significant difference in flush rates, so the Commission made the longer season uniform across the state and continued it through 2000.

Advertise with us

In 1999, preliminary reports from a multistate, long-term research effort called the Appalachian Cooperative Grouse Research Project evoked concern that long winter hunting seasons could negatively impact grouse populations.

Reflecting that concern, Pennsylvania cut back the winter season to mid-January in '01, and substituted a week of December hunting between the close of deer season and Christmas.

Bill Palmer is the Game Commission's grouse biologist, and he has tracked grouse populations not subject to the influence of hunting. His findings noted the same cyclic fluctuations in grouse numbers on gamelands near State College as on lands used for hunting. He has also verified the widely held consensus that grouse thrive best in young, brushy forests.

Simultaneously, a later phase of the Appalachian project conducted in Kentucky, Virginia and West Virginia found winter hunting had little impact on populations, refuting earlier fears.

That new insight, combined with Palmer's surveys of hunters, which indicate that grouse hunters in Pennsylvania have declined by 60 percent the past 20 years, spurred him to recommend that commissioners extend the season to the end of January in 2006.

Advertise with us

Palmer reasons that because the number of grouse hunters has dropped so much, a longer winter season might impact local populations of birds in small accessible pockets of cover, but it won't affect the overall status of the bird statewide. He cites his own studies and research done in Wisconsin that shows that in areas of widespread suitable habitat, grouse from surrounding areas would quickly re-colonize overshot cover. Palmer cautions, however, that prime grouse habitat is becoming more fragmented as forests mature across the state.

Pennsylvania's proposal to extend the season is supported by the Ruffed Grouse Society, a national organization that works to promote sound grouse management. Its national headquarters is in Coraopolis.

"Normally, we don't get involved too much in recommending seasons and bag limits," said RGS regional biologist Mark Banker. "But we are confident that a season to the end of January won't affect the population across Pennsylvania as a whole, and that's why we testified at the Game Commission meeting in support of the extension."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.