Robert F. Bukaty, Associated Press
The number of deers, especially antlerless deer, in Pennsylvania has become a hot topic these days.
Click photo for larger image.
Other items
In other action last week the Pennsylvania Game Commission meeting:
Approved the use of "cable restraint" devices for taking of furbearers such as coyotes and fox.
Eliminated the need for "paper permits" for motorists who wish to keep and consume road-killed deer. Motorists who pick up deer can now call a commission office or conservation officer to be issued a "permit number" by phone.
Authorized reserving one day for "youth hunting" of geese at Pymatuning and Middle Creek Waterfowl Management areas.
Approved providing names and addresses of 2,500 hunters to Penn State University for a study of attitudes toward Sunday hunting.
Proposed a September elk season for 2006, limited to agricultural areas near St. Marys, Elk County.
Voted to purchase 965 acres in Clarion County as a new state game lands.
Despite six weeks of intense lobbying from dissatisfied deer hunters, the Pennsylvania Game Commission proposed at its meeting Tuesday in Harrisburg to keep the 2005 deer seasons basically unchanged.
Deer hunters from across the state, especially in central and northern regions, asked, and in some cases demanded, that the Commission shorten the seasons for antlerless deer and reduce the number of antlerless deer licenses because they saw fewer deer during the 2004 hunt.
"Deer sign and deer sightings for most hunters are at an all time low," testified Greg Levengood, Board Chairman of the Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania. After testimony from 75 groups and individuals at a public comment period commissioners voted to maintain the controversial concurrent two-week season for bucks and does, continue with antler restrictions and to liberalize the Deer Management Assistance Program (DMAP) by allowing hunters to apply for and receive two DMAP deer permits for a specific property. Formerly, hunters have been limited to one DMAP tag per tract.
Commissioners also proposed to extend the season for antlerless deer by two weeks in two management units in southeastern Pennsylvania. A final vote on the measures will be made at the Game Commission's April 26 meeting.
Many hunters expressed concern that the Commission had abandoned its historic loyalty to hunters to appease conservation organizations, farm groups and the timber industry calling for smaller deer herds because of the animals' impact on forests and crops. But newly elected Commission President John Riley said that commissioners had the responsibility to consider a broad base of opinions.
"It is unfair to say that this board is anti-hunter," Riley said. "We just can't go with the hunters period. We are going to exhaust every avenue to resolve this but we have to consider all the people of the commonwealth, including the hunter. We have not sold out to anyone -- Bin Laden, the insurance companies or anybody else."
Commissioner Steve Mohr did not share Riley's broader view. "These [dissatisfied hunters] were sincere and they had good reason to be here but their pleas fell on deaf ears," he said. "We had a chance here to mend fences with the hunters and heal wounds but we failed the sportsmen again. I suggest every one of us on this board attend the Eastern Sports and Outdoor Show and listen to these sportsmen face to face and see if we can still ignore them. As far as their support, we are at an all-time low point."
Other items
In other action last week the Pennsylvania Game Commission meeting:
Approved the use of "cable restraint" devices for taking of furbearers such as coyotes and fox.
Eliminated the need for "paper permits" for motorists who wish to keep and consume road-killed deer. Motorists who pick up deer can now call a commission office or conservation officer to be issued a "permit number" by phone.
Authorized reserving one day for "youth hunting" of geese at Pymatuning and Middle Creek Waterfowl Management areas.
Approved providing names and addresses of 2,500 hunters to Penn State University for a study of attitudes toward Sunday hunting.
Proposed a September elk season for 2006, limited to agricultural areas near St. Marys, Elk County.
Voted to purchase 965 acres in Clarion County as a new state game lands.
Even though the Commission intends to keep the same structure for deer seasons, the depth of its commitment to balancing deer with forest health and other concerns won't be known until the April meeting when the agency announces the number of antlerless licenses it will issue for 2005.
Regardless of how the hunting seasons are scheduled, the number of antlerless "doe" tags allocated is the most important variable in managing the state's deer herd. The agency approved 1,039,000 antlerless licenses for the 2004 season, and many hunters want that figure drastically reduced.
Commissioner Russ Schleiden said the agency was using the recently established Wildlife Management Units to address deer issues in various parts of the state.
"We are, in fact, treating this problem through the antlerless allocations in the wildlife management units," Schleiden said. "The allocation numbers didn't seem that big when we went by counties, but when we combined counties and parts of counties into units, the allocation numbers seemed more startling.
One of the reasons we went with the bigger units was so hunters could have more flexibility to hunt in new areas but we found that people didn't do that. Do I blame them for that? Absolutely not."
Achieving appropriate deer numbers is difficult because of the diversity in forest types, agriculture, land ownership patterns and human habitation in various parts of the state. "There is a perception that the deer herd has been reduced," said Commission Vice-President Roxane Palone of Waynesburg. "I don't think that is true in the southwest. I think we still have a pretty abundant deer herd here. But before we can make any changes we have to wait for the data from butcher shops and our deer-check teams. We'll also be working with DCNR to do some infrared imaging in the field, and we'll soon have regional biologists on board to collect data. There is a lot of data we have to take into consideration and I don't want us to make any rash decisions."
The closest dissatisfied hunters came to winning a return to more restrictive hunting regulations came when Commissioner Thomas Boop asked for a review of the concurrent buck and "doe" season.
"Based upon 300 letters and e-mails I have received, and on my personal experience, I ask that the president direct the wildlife management committee to take a look at whether it is appropriate to continue having 12 days of concurrent hunting," Boop said. "I ask that the committee analyze this and make appropriate recommendations for the April meeting."
Levengood's Unified Sportsmen have announced they intend to sue the Game Commission if it does not allow deer numbers to rebound. Levengood questioned the Commission's ability to manage deer without a better estimate of statewide deer populations.
"This ongoing debate about deer numbers paralyzes everyone, and we need to get past it," Levengood said. "Plus, you do not want to subject yourselves and other Game Commission officials to such a verbal assault in the future. Let's get an accurate handle on the numbers and move on with the practice of managing deer."
Controversy over deer management intensified two weeks ago when a panel of recognized experts in forest ecology released a report entitled "Managing White-tailed Deer in Forest Habitat From an Ecosystem Perspective: Pennsylvania Case Study." Audubon Pennsylvania and a forum of conservation and sportsmen organizations known as the Habitat Alliance convened the panel. The report indicts past deer management policies for allowing herds to grow so large that they damaged plant communities, habitat for other wildlife, and the scenic and economic value of forests. Instead, the report calls for managing deer as one aspect of an interconnected forest ecosystem with diverse values for society.
Acknowledging the report, Riley said, "We have to look at this new study, see whether it will work and determine what's best for the hunters and for the forest resource. Give us a chance to look at the information. If we can't use it we'll abandon it. But if we can use it we will."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.