Anglers were back on the ice last week, as plummeting temperatures caused hopes to soar.

Fishing Notebook:

Erie walleye limits might be relaxed

"My phone was ringing off the hook," said Ron Anderson of Appalachian Trails, a Lake Arthur bait shop, just a day or two before 50 ice fishermen hit Muddy Creek and other eastern bays on one of Western Pennsylvania's best-liked winter fisheries. No sooner had they augered holes through the ice than heavy snows put a damper on the mid-season bite.

Advertise with us

As of Thursday, fishing had picked up, but it still wasn't as good as early in the season. "Snow made it tough for fish to see bait," Anderson said. "Not like in December, when ice was clear."

Fish also have had time to adapt to frigid water and are at their least active, said Mike Kuna, of Ross, a Lake Arthur regular who is competing this weekend in an Ice Team tournament on Silver Lake in Perry, N.Y., with his partner Bob Griffith of Vandergrift.

"They're finicky when their metabolism slows down," Kuna said. "You can have 100 fish around you, and fish and fish and fish without a bite. Of course, things should get better with ice-out."

Kuna took up ice angling just three years ago as a way to pass the time between other fishing seasons and now is hooked. Ice Team runs mostly Midwestern tournaments, though Kuna is trying to drum up support for competitive ice fishing around here. He and his partner have qualified for the Ice Team North American Championship in Minnesota in December.

Western Pennsylvania's ice fishing season is perhaps less predictable than that in most parts of the upper Midwest and it looked like there might not be a season until two weeks ago, when temperatures plunged. Joe McKay of Baldwin headed to Lake Arthur Tuesday as soon as surfaces seemed safe. By Thursday, he had released bass up to 19 inches and a 26-inch pike, but it took some scouting. "When your flags aren't going off, you have to be willing to move," he said.

Advertise with us

Though Kuna finds ice more challenging than open water, McKay thinks it's easier. "Once you decide where you want to put your bait, it stays there," he said. "You don't have to worry about current or wind and making constant adjustments like if you were fishing out of a boat." He escapes the cold with a fold-up tent and heater and uses a power auger after years of sawing through 18 inches at Highpoint Lake in Fayette County. He also purchased an underwater camera.

McKay targets pike, bass and perch by fishing with tip-ups one or two feet off the bottom, or by working them just below the surface. Walleye are a little harder to locate, if they are suspending in deeper water, he said, though he has caught nice walleye and sauger at Dunlap Lake, a trout-stocked impoundment in Fayette County. A couple of years ago, McKay bought wind-powered tip-ups that jig bait with every breeze. "I caught two beautiful 16-inch crappie at Arthur on these," he said. In Pennsylvania, ice anglers are allowed to fish with up to five devices in any combination of tip-ups, hand-lines or jigging rods. Holes cannot exceed 10 inches.

McKay uses braided nylon line in 40 pound test and steel leader for toothy critters such as pike. He seldom goes lighter than 20-pound fluorocarbon for perch, bass or trout since it has to stand up to friction from frozen surfaces.

He also traps for suckers and creek chubs in area streams. "Some of the dinkiest creeks have fish in them," said McKay, who baits traps with catfish pellets, bread and dry dog food. "A little trick when you trap in bigger streams is to wrap your bait in cheese cloth so the big fish can't get at it."

He likes large baitfish, though he caught some of his best bass on small fish at the end of last winter. His prize catch last February at Lake Arthur was close to an 8-pound largemouth bass, he said.

Advertise with us

Even experienced ice anglers such as McKay tend to buddy up not just for the camaraderie, but for safety since traipsing across frozen surfaces can be tricky. Anderson said he has seen plenty of near tragedies, which could have been easily avoided. "It amazes me how many folks don't take a $3 throw rope with them, or picks of life, which are cheap enough. One man fell through three years ago and the only thing that saved him was he held onto his Styrofoam bait bucket and used it as a flotation device. It was an hour before he was rescued and he was pretty near dead," McKay said. "The locals could have told him that where he was fishing was notorious for underwater springs."

Bait shops and park rangers are good sources of information about ice quality. For ice angling tips, visit www.fish.state.pa.us. For park contacts, visit www.dcnr.state.pa.us.

The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission will sponsor an ice-fishing clinic as part of Winter Fun Fest at Pymatuning State Park 9 a.m. until noon Saturday and noon until 3 p.m. Sunday. Ice fishing techniques and gear will be covered along with ice safety. Equipment will be provided. For details, call 814-336-2426.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.