Hunters and sportsmen, all good people, have been calling, e-mailing and writing for a month. It is all about deer hunting.

None have called to say they had a good season. Who would expect that anyway? When people are content they tend not to express it. All the correspondence has been about too few deer, by some reports none at all. Any sane person who grew up hunting and fishing in this state, who sampled the wonderful tradition that is now lamented everywhere, understands why many hunters are unhappy.

As hunters, we are accustomed to seeing a lot of deer.

Now, after a few years of a new direction in deer management, the real or perceived scarcity of deer is like a surprise party when the honored guest doesn't show. Deer hunting, though, is more important than a party to most of the people who have written. Deer hunting is how they backtrack their own lives, how they best remember loved ones. Their frustration is human nature.

Advertise with us

But none of that changes the hard cold truth that we are reaping now what we have sown for a long time. In Pennsylvania we ignored the problem of overabundant deer for at least half a century. Hunters and Pennsylvania Game Commission alike were able to do that because until fairly recently deer affected nobody but hunters, and nobody else had a reason to be interested. Only a few ignored academics understood or even wondered about the complex weave of Appalachian forests, and how deer in overabundance might unravel the threads.

Until the closing quarter of the 20th century there were few deer in the farm regions, landscaped suburbs scarcely existed at all, and there were fewer cars and roads to get deer into trouble. Even commercial forestry did not recognize the challenge of abundant deer when much of its stock was too young to cut and there was little reason yet to speculate about regeneration. For a hundred years we hunters had primacy in all deer matters and nobody else cared.

Now forests, including our public forests owned by everyone, are in a crisis of non-renewal. The forests are much like our hunting population itself, lots of older specimens but few young recruits. We hunters can protest as much as we like, but we cannot make forests carry more deer than they can feed, anymore than a man can carry five gallons of water from the spring to his camp in a 5-gallon bucket with holes shot through the sides.

More importantly, a forest has a capability to support only so much breathing, photosynthesizing, living tissue. Once that tissue was spread around among countless kinds of living things. Now, in much of our part of the world it is concentrated in white-tailed deer, red maple and hay-scented fern. We have come to the point where, if we try to make forests channel more of themselves into deer flesh, they will be damaged to a point where they may never recover.

Pennsylvania probably does have fewer deer now than a couple of years ago, but nobody knows when that will result in significant recovery of forest habitats. Certainly those habitats will not improve if we revert to the old style of deer management.

Advertise with us

We hunters made this problem as bad as it is because we never listened to anybody who tried to take it seriously. We never thought about it and granted, it was quite enjoyable not to think about it. We went on expecting our deer managers to proceed as if forests were nothing more than a mechanized venison-and-bone production line, but now we have hit a wall.

To get through this conflict with deer hunting intact we must:

1. Recognize that other people have legitimate interests in deer and the forests they inhabit.

2. Recognize that forests are dynamic systems that always produce some consequence in response to every management decision, or avoided decision.

3. Take constructive responsibility as informed hunters for as much of the situation as we can, if for no other reason than to remind society that hunting is more than a short-term thrill, that it merits an honored place in history and in the future.