Bigger trout and new fishing regulations may be in store for anglers in 2006 if the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission decides Tuesday to begin the process of revamping its trout management programs and eliminating restrictions on barbed hooks, angling hours and wading on blue-ribbon trout streams.

Fishing Notebook:

Retiree to receive Commission award

The commissioners were scheduled to get together tomorrow and Tuesday in Harrisburg for their first quarterly meeting of 2005, but the winter storm that hit the state yesterday changed that to a Tuesday teleconference, which might not be as lengthy or productive. Fish and Boat Commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick said the commissioners will likely meet in Harrisburg in the next couple of weeks to tackle the entire agenda.

Advertise with us

On the boating side, that will include whether to allow gasoline-powered boats on 19 lakes currently limited to watercraft with only electric motors or unpowered watercraft beginning next year.

Whether it is Tuesday or at a follow-up meeting, the nine-member board -- which is still without a representative from south-central Pennsylvania for going on two years -- will decide whether to seek public comment on the proposed changes before taking a final vote later this year.

The proposed changes are part of a plan to make streams more user friendly, generate license sales and give anglers what they have been asking for in a series of focus group meetings, said Fish and Boat Commission fisheries management chief Dick Snyder.

One of the requests is that certain restrictions, including barbless hooks, no wading and no fishing after dark, be lifted, Snyder said. Despite evidence that barbless hooks reduce delayed mortality in trout, the difference is too slight to justify the restriction, even on the Letort Spring Run and Spring Creek's Fisherman's Paradise, he said. The no wading rule was implemented on Fisherman's Paradise to protect in-stream habitat devices and minimize social conflict, and is no longer relevant, said Snyder. Neither is the dawn to dusk rule, which originally was implemented to aid law enforcement officers, he said.

The Wild Brook Trout Enhancement program and the Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only program will remain untouched, except for the lifting of hourly restrictions on the latter. So would the regulations on Spring Creek in Centre County and Valley Creek in Chester County, though the programs, now under "miscellaneous," would be renamed Catch and Release All Tackle.

Advertise with us

The following programs would be new:

Catch and release fly fishing only. This would replace Heritage Trout Angling and delayed harvest fly-fishing only with a new catch and release fly-fishing only program that would allow year-round angling with no harvest, and no restrictions on wading, barbed hooks or hours. Included would be Fisherman's Paradise on Spring Creek, Letort Spring Run and 31 other streams

Rename all tackle trophy trout to trophy trout all tackle. This would change the daily creel limit to one trout, at least 16 inches, and allow for year-round harvest, instead of just April to September. It would also remove wading restrictions.

It would also add the miscellaneous special regulations waters of the Allegheny River in Warren County. The program currently includes the Little Juniata, Penns Creek and parts of the Clarion and Youghiogheny rivers.

Rename the existing trophy trout program to trophy trout artificial lures only. This would combine the existing trophy trout and catch and release programs and allow for the daily harvest of one trout, at least 16 inches, year round. Existing lure definitions would remain the same, except barbed hooks would be allowed. Hourly restrictions would be removed

Advertise with us

Reaction from some members of Trout Unlimited, a cold water conservation group, was circumspect, especially with regard to the emphasis on trophy trout and the elimination of catch and release.

"Creel limits aren't limits, they're goals," said Bob Bachman of Denver, Pa., and Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited's representative to the Fish and Boat Commission focus group on trout-related issues. "Too many fishermen will fish and fish and fish until they kill their limit."

Trout Unlimited advocates catch and release on all wild trout streams, and no stocking of trout where wild trout exist, according to Bob Pennell of Harrisburg and a Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited regional vice president. But on Trophy Trout waters, creel limits should probably be based on a maximum small size, so larger fish will have a chance to reproduce, he said.

The board is expected to decide whether hatcheries should "upsize" trout from 10 inches to 11 inches and grow them 30 percent fatter, beginning next year. It would mean 20 percent fewer trout, since hatcheries cannot exceed 1.9 million pounds of trout per year, Snyder said. Instead of 4 million trout, there would be 3.2 million, including 15,000 trophy brood stock averaging 16 inches and 2 pounds, and 9,000 golden rainbows averaging 14 inches and 1.5 pounds. The Fish and Boat Commission would still receive 100,000 trout from the Allegheny National Fish Hatchery, 130,000 from a private hatchery in North Carolina and 1 million through its cooperative nursery program with fishing and conservation clubs, Snyder said.

The board is expected to take a final vote at some point on whether Fish and Boat Commission executive director Doug Austen should be given the authority to advertise some stocked streams more than others by providing anglers with a heads-up on the exact dates, times, locations and sizes of select stockings, so angler pressure can be redirected to under-utilized and more accessible streams.

Advertise with us

More discussion, and a possible vote, is expected on whether to increase the minimum age of operators of personal watercraft, such as SeaDoos and JetSkis, from 12 years old to 16, although the Fish and Boat Commission has received little public comment on the issue. The board also will consider allowing gas-powered boats on 19 lakes that are 100 acres or larger and currently restricted to electric or unpowered watercraft.

In Western Pennsylvania, some of the lakes would be Kahle Lake in Venango County, Tamarack Lake in Crawford County and High Point and Cranberry Glade lakes in Somerset County. The board also will look at expanding a program that would provide grants to communities wanting to build new launch facilities.

Finally, because the Pennsylvania Senate failed last fall to confirm Trout Unlimited's Len Lichvar for the Fish and Boat Commission board, the south central seat vacated in June 2003 by the ailing Rozell Stidd remains vacant. A senate spokesman cited landowner opposition to Lichvar, who is an outspoken advocate of public access on streams, as the reason he wasn't confirmed. Lichvar is active in Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited and the Mountain Laurel chapter. The governor's office has said it will re-nominate Lichvar this year.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.