Paul Vathis, Associated Press
Former Pennsylvania Game Commission's Supervisor for Deer Management Gary Alt looks through racks of deer antlers outside the commission's headquarters in Harrisburg in April 2002. Alt resigned at the end of December.
Click photo for larger image.
Dr. Gary Alt's departure from the helm of Pennsylvania deer management has stirred celebration in some corners of the outdoor world and concern in others. Alt's letter to the Pennsylvania Game Commission made his resignation effective at the end of last year. No one knows how Alt's exit will affect the programs he pioneered, if at all. But Pennsylvanians from all perspectives are sure to be paying attention.
Long before his departure last week, Alt was vilified, reviled, cursed, slandered, threatened, credited and canonized for what he did and tried to do with deer management in this state.
A lot has been said and a great deal remains to be said about his vision and about his early leave -- Alt is 53. But right now, as one of 900,000 Pennsylvania deer hunters, I'll take this opportunity to thank him for respecting me and believing in me.
Thank you, Dr. Alt, for your faith that I could control my impulse to shoot long enough to count the points on a buck's antlers and that, if I was not sure, I would not shoot at all.
Your critics said I lacked that self-control. They claimed that my drive to kill a deer -- any deer -- was so uncontrollable, that I would drop any deer with antlers and leave it to rot if it had too few tines.
Thank you also for believing that I was a thoughtful and careful enough hunter to take a few seconds to distinguish a button buck from an adult doe and to make the decision to take the doe. You put the health and balance of the deer herd in my hands. You sensed that a vibrant, healthy deer herd, in which animals reached their full potential of vigor was important to me and gave me the discretion to help make it happen.
Likewise, thank you for my greater understanding of deer and their relationships with land and other wildlife. Your fawn mortality research underscored the importance of healthy habitat as escape cover from coyotes and bears. And your study of conception and gestation proved, yet again, that the true bottom line for deer numbers is the ability of the land to provide nutrition.
As one of thousands of hunters with busy lives and many responsibilities, I want to thank you for the new opportunities you helped give me to hunt. Particularly, I thank you for the two-week opportunity, including two Saturdays, during which I could try to take an antlerless deer when it best suited my schedule and my other obligations. You must have known that a harvested deer is something I value deeply, that I put aside other things in my life to care for that deer with the respect it deserves. The two-week season helped me to do that without conflicting with Christmas and my duties to my family at a hectic time of year.
As a parent, I thank you for wider opportunities to be with my son as he took his first few deer. We prowled the woods together, watching, evaluating and finally deciding he had a good shot at the right deer. We felt joy and accomplishment when he killed a deer and we acknowledged many good days together in the woods when he did not. If he becomes a lifelong, self-motivated hunter, despite all the other demands for his attention in the world of today's youth, I will gladly give you part of the credit.
As a Pennsylvania citizen, I appreciate your reminder that others' lives are affected by the deer I hunt. In my annual recreational preoccupation with deer, it is easy to forget that farmers must make a living year-round in their midst and that the livelihoods of thousands of loggers, mill workers, hardwood artisans and truckers depend on sustainable woodlands. Your point of view helped me question the label of "special interest" that some would pin on these productive Pennsylvanians.
Most of all, thank you, Dr. Alt, for believing I cared about the condition of the forests of my home state. The respect you showed by challenging me to restore the resource that is the backbone of Pennsylvania's natural heritage is not something to which I am accustomed. Normally, I hear only bad news about hunters -- stupid accidents, arrogant trespass, flagrant violations, and even violent rampages. But you told society through television, radio and newspapers, that hunters were a positive force, an unselfish ally that could "fix the forests" for the good of all. As a hunter, I appreciate that kind of faith and respect. Our hunting community needs it badly.
In addition to my gratitude, Dr. Alt, I also have a hope. I hope your successor, whoever he or she may be, has good reason to harbor the same faith and respect for hunters that you so widely expressed. What sir, do you think are the odds?
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.