First ice on area lakes and ponds may end up being the season's only ice, but, for a few hardy souls who enjoy ice fishing, it was fun while it lasted.
More fishing news
Fishing Notebook: Fly Tying Expo Saturday in Ohio
Events not put on ice by warm weather
There's no telling whether lakes will go back into a deep freeze, but the week or so of ice that was thick enough to auger yielded some of the season's nicest fish.
Lake Wilhelm had the lunker with a 51 1/2-inch, 37-pound muskie, while the Allegheny Reservoir's Chappel Bay -- where the 35-pound state record pike was caught through the ice on New Year's Day three years ago -- produced a crush of post-Christmas perch. And Lake Arthur's Muddy Creek arm gave up big numbers of trophy-weight bass and pike.
"I'm looking at my wall right now, at photos of the six- and seven-pound largemouths guys caught," said Ron Anderson of Appalachian Trails near Lake Arthur in Butler County. "I'm also looking at a forecast that shows 50 degree temperatures. That doesn't bode well for more ice."
Temperatures so far this month have been about 3.4 degrees above normal, said Accu-Weather senior meteorologist Ken Reeves.
"If you're hoping to ice fish on the Martin Luther King holiday weekend, you'll be hurting," he said, referring to Jan. 15-17.
"The second half of January will turn colder than normal, but, in winters where you have problems with ice hanging around, hoping that it will re-form and stay is optimistic at best."
Even if we get a colder than usual February, ice formed in late winter is usually short-lived, Reeves said. "In a normal pattern, ice is thinning in February anyway. The sun angle is higher, and temperatures are starting to climb from an average high of 36 on Feb. 1 to 43 degrees by the end of the month."
This is the first year in 12 years there hasn't been ice cover in January, said Anderson. By this time last year, Lake Arthur had frozen and stayed that way for more than a month. Joe McKay of Baldwin recalls catching 67 largemouth bass, including a 24-incher that weighed eight pounds and had a 24 1/2-inch girth, and five others of more than 20 inches, all pulled through the ice in mid-February. McKay holds out hope for this year, but said the season so far has been a surprise.
"As many years as I've been ice fishing, I can't remember the last time we had good ice that melted right away, where you're fishing and then all of a sudden you're not," he said.
In two days of ice fishing at Lake Arthur last month, McKay landed 22 bass. "Not too bad," he said. "I also weighed a largemouth for a little kid that was a notch below eight pounds."
First ice is considered best ice because it is clear enough to let light in, making it easy for fish to spot bait when they are active enough to chase it, said Anderson. "They also haven't been pressured in a while," he added.
Ice came off so quickly this year, the good fishing continued on lakes where mud and high water from runoff weren't a problem.
"It was like a mini ice-out," said Bob Mohra of Fergie's bait and tackle shop near Lake Wilhelm last week. "Guys were having a great time with crappie up at the Sheakleyville Bridge. They were getting a fish on every cast. They were also getting nice perch in the main lake."
On New Year's Day, Mike Kalafut of Uniontown reported releasing several five-pound plus smallmouth bass by the Youghiogheny Dam.
A mild winter can mean greater survival for most species, said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson. And early spring spawners, such as muskie, pike, walleye and sauger, could begin reproducing as soon as two weeks earlier than usual since they are cued by hours of daylight as much as water temperatures.
"Rivers tend to warm up faster than lakes because of rainfall and other things affecting surface flow, so this could mean good fishing for river anglers," he said. "Of course, a lot can happen between now and mid-February or March."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.