Indications are that deer hunters will turn out in force at the Pennsylvania Game Commission meeting in Harrisburg Jan 23-25 to express their dissatisfaction with the 2004 season. These hunters' general theme will be that the current management program has decimated the deer herd and they will ask for change.
Some will suggest an end to antler restrictions. Others will call for abolishing the concurrent season for legal antlered and antlerless deer, and a return to the formerly separate seasons for "buck" and "doe." Some will advocate closing "doe" season altogether.
Their input represents their First Amendment right and commissioners should and will hear them. But there will be others in attendance exercising equally valid rights. The Commission will need to consider their views with equal care, especially before voting to abandon any of the advances it made in deer management the past five years.
One of those people will be Allie Dickinson, a Lehigh County woman whose 18-year-old daughter was struck in the head by a bullet while sitting in a car in her driveway during the deer season. Ms. Dickinson is expected to ask the Commission to outlaw the use of center fire rifles for hunting in "populated areas." Ms. Dickinson has approached her municipality with her concern and won a resolution of support from her township supervisors. Her daughter, thankfully, is recovering.
Also this past season, a bullet pierced a third-grade classroom in Fayette County, a woman was shot while driving in York County and several homes were hit around the state.
Statistically, deer hunting remains safer than most other recreational activities, and far safer than America's daily commute, but people do not forget incidents like those cited.
That is why, before they take any steps backward, game commissioners must appreciate the built-in safety insurance in their current deer regulations.
Antler restrictions, particularly the 4-point minimum in Western Pennsylvania, establish a class of "protected deer" smaller bucks that do not qualify as legal antlered or antlerless deer. The restriction requires, theoretically at least, a hunter to evaluate the antlers before shooting.
Those few seconds also provide an opportunity to check the line-of-fire beyond the deer, reducing the chance of an accident.
A similar argument can be made for the concurrent season. Hunters now have a longer time in which to take antlerless deer, discouraging quick shots at marginal opportunities. Under the "old" three-day "doe" season, hunters knew their time to tag an antlerless deer was limited. There was a built-in incentive to take more chances.
I suggest that hunters can verify this if they think about the pattern of shots they hear in the woods today. Formerly, there were frequent barrages of multiple shots. Today, there are fewer salvos but more single shots spaced through the day. This pattern of shooting indicates greater care and a reduction in the potential for tragedy.
In my experience, the most disturbing examples of irresponsible rapid-fire shooting -- the kind more apt to hit an unintended target--were heard during the former "doe" season. I believe that some hunters then assumed there were few surviving bucks, that any deer seen was a doe and started shooting. Those hunters can't do that now without a greater risk of shooting a protected deer.
Some may argue that this season's rash of incidents proves that the current setup is even more dangerous. But there is always natural variability in these kinds of events, no matter what the regulations, and there is no way to speculate how many accidents did not occur this season under regulations that encourage more prudent shooting. It just makes logical sense that if there were no antler restrictions, and if we had a short "doe" season representing the last chance to take a deer, that the potential for these unsavory outcomes would be even greater.
We hunters should note that Ms. Dickinson is not philosophically opposed to hunting. She is not an "anti-hunter," nor an "anti-gunner." She has simply been motivated by a personal tragedy that will become even more probable as the state's rural areas are urbanized.
She may not be technically correct in believing that shotgun slugs represent greater safety than center fire rifles, but that will not stop her township and other urbanizing municipalities from pressuring the Game Commission to curtail rifle use, or from taking steps to stop hunting altogether within their borders.
Antler restrictions and a long antlerless season discourage irresponsible shooting. Before making any reactive change, the Game Commission must be certain that it is protecting the safety of the public and the future of hunting to the greatest extent that it can.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.