Douglass Oster, Post-Gazette
Fishermen brave the fog while trying to catch steelhead near the mouth of 12 Mile Creek where it empties into Lake Erie.
Click photo for larger image.
Before leaving the Pittsburgh Downriggers meeting in Coraopolis Tuesday night for Erie, Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission executive director Doug Austen asked for tips on where to go steelhead fishing.
The unanimous advice was Elk Creek, where, it turns out, Austen fished for an hour before his Wednesday morning news conference on the economic impact of steelhead angling. Although he didn't catch anything, Austen had plenty to brag about when the cameras were turned on.
He joined Sen. Jane Earll (R-Erie) and business leaders in releasing a report on one of the state's most successful fisheries. Austen hopes to use it to develop new Fish and Boat Commission funding sources. While the bottom line is that anglers from October 2003, through April spent $9.5 million on trip-related expenditures to Erie, the report also details angling trends on Erie County streams, where steelhead fishing activity has tripled the past decade to 200,000 angler trips per season.
Prepared by Fish and Boat Commission biologist Chuck Murray and Penn State University agricultural economist Martin Shields, the report was based on interviews with 3,100 anglers at 23 sites on Elk, Walnut, Four, Seven, Twelve, Sixteen and Twenty Mile creeks, and Godfrey and Trout runs. Of the fishermen interviewed, 84 percent were Pennsylvanians and 13 percent were from Canada and 22 other states, chiefly Ohio (44 percent), then West Virginia, New York, Maryland and New Jersey. Just 3 percent of those surveyed were youth anglers.
Although fishermen came from all but seven of Pennsylvania's 67 counties, Erie, then Allegheny led the way. Those living along the I-79 corridor made up three-fourths of Pennsylvania steelhead fishermen.
Ninety-six percent of anglers surveyed targeted steelhead, 2 percent brown trout, 1.5 percent "anything that bites" and 0.1 percent Coho salmon, which were stocked for the last time last year. Anglers averaged 4.22 hours on the water per trip and made most of their trips (63 percent) in October and November. Forty-one percent of trips were to Elk Creek and 40 percent to Walnut Creek.
The report cited guaranteed public access as a big reason for the 454 percent increase in angler activity on lower Elk Creek (50,000 trips) and the 224 percent increase on lower Walnut Creek (30,000 trips). It also said newly acquired public access on Twenty Mile Creek generated a 1,561 percent increase in angler hours there. Seven percent of fishing trips were to the mouth of Trout Run, followed by Twenty Mile, Godfrey Run, Twelve Mile Creek, Four Mile, Seven Mile and Sixteen Mile.
Anglers caught more than 373,300 steelhead last fall through the spring, accounting for 63 percent of all species caught and 91 percent of the total harvest. Twenty-six percent of other catches were smolts (baby steelhead), 6 percent suckers and 3 percent brown trout. Anglers kept about one in five of the steelhead they landed, though creel retention was highest (42 percent) at the I-79 pool on upper Elk Creek and lowest (9 percent) at Elk Creek's Streuchen flats. Harvesting of steelhead was highest (35 percent) in October and lowest (13 percent) in December.
On average, anglers had to fish an hour and a half to catch a steelhead, and half of all anglers who targeted steelhead caught at least one. Catch rates and harvest rates were higher on eastside streams, where angler avidity and good sight fishing were big factors, the report said. Hourly catch rates were lowest in October, when anglers had to fish about three hours to land a steelhead, but more than doubled December through February, when they averaged one steelhead an hour. This implies that the more veteran anglers go after steelhead in winter months, said Fish and Boat Commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick.
About 40 percent of anglers said they fished for steelhead five or fewer times a season, though 10 percent reported 50 or more trips a season. The middle ground was 18 trips a season. About 14 percent of Pennsylvanians said they purchased a fishing license and trout stamp just to fish for steelhead, while 68 percent of non-resident anglers said they bought annual three-day or seven-day Pennsylvania licenses just to steelhead fish in Erie.
Three-fourths of anglers surveyed expressed support for a new Lake Erie stamp that would generate revenue for purchasing easements on Erie streams for the next five years, but most favored a $3 to $5 fee. The proposed stamp, which will be voted on next month as part of the license increase package, is $8 or $12 for a Lake Erie/trout combination stamp. The report cites access issues as critical in determining future growth of steelheading in Erie. Besides easements, efforts are being made to provide property owners with tax breaks, said Gary Heubel, a local bait shop owner active in the Pennsylvania Steelhead Association, who applauded the report but called findings "an underestimate, conservative."
As for how much money anglers spend during steelhead trips, the report shows that individuals who live outside Erie County spent about $61.27 per trip on food, lodging, bait and tackle, and transportation, in that order, while Erie residents spent about $6.60.
"It's way bigger than anybody anticipated," Bob Spaulding, CEO of the Erie Regional Chamber and Growth Partnership, said of the findings.
"Every time a steelhead hits the net, cash registers in the county jingle with $85 new dollars." Spalding said 219 jobs are directly related to steelhead angling. "We're looking to attract Bass Pro, Cabellas and some first-rate tournaments. Now we can say, 'Hey, look at us, look at what we have here.' "
For the complete report, visit www.fish.state.pa.us.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.